/en-s6-ethics-religious-studies-utilitarian-kant-virtue-organ-qaly-carbon-budget-bribery-demographics-practice-paper/
/en-s6-ethics-religious-studies-utilitarian-kant-virtue-organ-qaly-carbon-budget-bribery-demographics-practice-paper/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S6 Ethics and Religious Studies Practice Paper: Utilitarian Calculus, Kantian Duty, QALY Organ Allocation, Carbon Budgets, Bribery Costs and Religious Demographics

S6 Ethics and Religious Studies Practice Paper: Utilitarian Calculus, Kantian Duty, QALY Organ Allocation, Carbon Budgets, Bribery Costs and Religious Demographics

  • 2026-11-16

Senior Secondary Ethics and Religious Studies

S6 Ethics and Religious Studies paper: utilitarian calculus, Kantian duty, QALY organ allocation, carbon budgets, bribery cost-benefit, religious demographics, with answers.

Download  | Answer key PDF
Paper details S6 Ethics and Religious Studies practice paper with answers: utilitarian calculus, Kantian duty and virtue ethics, QALY organ allocation, carbon budgets, bribery cost-benefit and religious demographics.

Part A: Utilitarian Calculus (18 marks)

Three proposals for an elderly centre each cost 360,000 dollars. Proposal A serves 120 people, adding 6 utility units each; Proposal B serves 90 people, adding 9 units each; Proposal C serves 60 people, adding 14 units each. Answer items 1 to 4.

# Question Answer and marking notes
1 (1) Calculate the total utility units of the three proposals. Answer: A 720 units (120 times 6), B 810 units (90 times 9), C 840 units (60 times 14).
2 (2) Which proposal would act utilitarianism choose? Explain. Answer: Proposal C. It yields the highest total of 840 units; act utilitarianism weighs only the total consequences, not the number of beneficiaries.
3 (3) Per thousand dollars of cost, how many utility units does each proposal yield? Is the result consistent with item 2? Answer: A 2.0, B 2.25, C 2.33 units (total divided by 360). The ranking is the same because the cost is identical, so the ratio preserves the order of totals.
4 (4) Which two further factors would rule utilitarianism consider? Give one example of each. Answer: First, the long-run consequences of the rule itself, for example a centre that always maximises totals would permanently neglect large groups with small gains; second, the social effects of the rule being generally followed, such as predictability and a sense of fairness.

Part B: Kantian Duty and Virtue Ethics (16 marks)

In a trial of 200 participants a drug company found that 3 per cent suffered a serious adverse reaction. The company considers omitting that risk from the leaflet; 600 patients are expected to use the drug. Answer items 5 to 8.

# Question Answer and marking notes
5 (5) How many trial participants suffered a serious adverse reaction? Answer: 6 participants (200 times 3 divided by 100).
6 (6) If the risk is omitted, how many users could be affected? Answer: 18 users (600 times 3 divided by 100).
7 (7) Apply the universalisability test to the maxim that a company may omit a serious risk. Answer: If every company omitted serious risks, leaflets would no longer inform anyone and patients would stop trusting them, so the maxim destroys its own purpose and cannot be universalised.
8 (8) How would the Kantian principle that persons are ends in themselves, and virtue ethics, each evaluate the decision? Answer: The Kantian principle holds that concealing the risk uses patients as means and removes their autonomous informed choice, so it is wrong; virtue ethics asks what an honest and compassionate person would do and finds the omission a failure of integrity that erodes trust.

Part C: Organ Allocation and QALY (18 marks)

Only one kidney is available. Patient A could live 12 more years with quality of life 0.6; B, 8 years with 0.9; C, 20 years with 0.35; D, 5 years with 0.8. Answer items 9 to 12.

# Question Answer and marking notes
9 (9) Calculate the QALY of each patient and the total. Answer: A 7.2, B 7.2, C 7.0, D 4.0; total 25.4 QALY.
10 (10) On pure QALY maximisation, who should receive the kidney? What difficulty arises? Answer: A or B, both at 7.2. The scores tie, so QALY alone cannot decide and a further criterion such as waiting time or age is needed.
11 (11) What moral reasons support a first-come-first-served rule instead? Answer: A queue does not rank the worth of persons and so respects their equal standing; it is transparent and predictable, which reduces bias and manipulation and satisfies procedural justice.
12 (12) How do the positions that life is priceless and that quality of life matters conflict? Explain. Answer: The priceless-life view holds that any QALY arithmetic turns lives into numbers and demeans dignity; the quality-of-life view replies that ignoring quality merely prolongs suffering and neglects real wellbeing.

Part D: Carbon Budgets and Intergenerational Justice (16 marks)

A city is allocated a carbon budget of 60 million tonnes over the next 12 years. Its population is 7.5 million and current emissions are 4.5 tonnes per person per year. Answer items 13 to 16.

# Question Answer and marking notes
13 (13) What is the average annual allowance? Answer: 5 million tonnes (60 million divided by 12).
14 (14) At current per-capita emissions, what is the annual total? Answer: 33.75 million tonnes (7.5 million people times 4.5 tonnes).
15 (15) How much must annual emissions fall, and what share of the current total is that? Answer: A cut of 28.75 million tonnes, leaving 0.148 of the current total, roughly one seventh of present emissions.
16 (16) Argue from intergenerational justice why the present generation should not exhaust the whole budget. Answer: Future people cannot take part in today’s decisions yet must bear the consequences; exhausting the budget transfers irreversible harm to those with no voice, violating equality and the symmetry of responsibility.

Part E: The Cost-Benefit of Commercial Bribery (16 marks)

A firm considers paying a consultancy fee of 0.8 million dollars to win a 12 million dollar contract, on a profit margin of 12 per cent. If it refuses, a rival wins the contract. The chance of detection is one in four and the fine is 5 million dollars. Answer items 17 to 20.

# Question Answer and marking notes
17 (17) What profit would the contract generate? Answer: 1.44 million dollars (12 million times 12 divided by 100).
18 (18) After the consultancy fee, what is the net profit? Answer: 0.64 million dollars (1.44 million minus 0.8 million).
19 (19) Including the expected fine, what is the expected net gain? What does it show? Answer: The expected fine is 1.25 million (5 million times one quarter), so the expected net gain is minus 0.61 million (0.64 minus 1.25); even on consequences alone the plan fails.
20 (20) What would Kantian duty ethics and rule utilitarianism each conclude? Answer: Kant holds that bribery treats the official as a mere instrument and its maxim cannot be universalised, so it is unconditionally wrong; rule utilitarianism finds that permitting bribery destroys market trust and raises transaction costs for everyone, so it too must be prohibited.

Part F: Religious Demographics and Palliative Care (16 marks)

A region of 6 million people is 55 per cent adherents of religion A, 25 per cent of religion B, 12 per cent of religion C and 8 per cent of no religion. A hospital allocates 1,200 hours of chaplaincy in proportion to adherent numbers. Answer items 21 to 24.

# Question Answer and marking notes
21 (21) Calculate the number of people in each group. Answer: Religion A 3.3 million, B 1.5 million, C 0.72 million, none 0.48 million.
22 (22) If after ten years religion A falls by 6 per cent and religion B rises by 20 per cent, what are the new numbers? Answer: Religion A 3.102 million, religion B 1.8 million.
23 (23) How many chaplaincy hours does each group receive? Answer: A 660 hours, B 300 hours, C 144 hours, none 96 hours.
24 (24) What problems does allocation by numbers create for minorities, and should chaplaincy serve them? Answer: Minorities receive too few hours to employ qualified chaplains and are effectively excluded; care should rest on dignity and need, so even small groups need accessible support, for example shared or referred services.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone practice paper; original questions and passages, not publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →