IGCSE Biology | Selective Breeding and Gene-Pool Narrowing: Tutor Prep Guide (Selection Response, Effective Population Size, Four Common Errors)
- 2026-11-16
Students answer that selective breeding means mating the best animals, yet they cannot explain why pedigree dogs carry so many inherited disorders. The missing link is the gene pool: only a few individuals become parents, effective population size collapses, the inbreeding coefficient climbs each generation, and recessive disorders surface. This lesson joins the chain with two sets of numbers.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Genes and alleles | How a pair of alleles determines a phenotype | The dominant form shows; two recessive alleles are needed |
| Sources of variation | What produces variation | Mutation and recombination during sexual reproduction |
| Phenotype and environment | Whether one genotype looks the same in different environments | It differs, so selection works on population means, not single animals |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Opening question | Ask why pedigree dogs carry so many inherited disorders | Write a guess and compare at the end |
| 6-16 min | Act 1: selection response | Write R equals h squared times S with the 200-cow example | Work out S and R themselves |
| 16-28 min | Act 2: effective population size | 2 bulls and 20 cows give Ne of 7.27 | Calculate and compare with the head count |
| 28-38 min | Act 3: inbreeding and inherited disease | Inbreeding rises 6.9 per cent per generation; a rare allele is lost with probability 86.4 per cent | Explain how recessive disease surfaces |
| 38-52 min | Calculation drill | Two questions: h squared from S, and change in F from Ne | Complete with units |
| 52-60 min | Exit check | Two questions collected and marked at once | Work independently |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Selection response: R equals h squared times S, and heritability sets the pace
Students do: fill S, h squared and R into a table and add one line answering what R becomes if h squared is 0.1.
Students say: why a low-heritability trait such as disease resistance responds so slowly, using the sentence that most phenotypic variation is environmental.
Scene 2: Effective population size: 200 cows do not mean 200 parents
Students do: calculate Ne for 2 bulls with 20 cows, 10 with 10, and 50 with 50, then say which comes closest to the head count.
Students say: why a more skewed sex ratio drives Ne down.
Scene 3: Two consequences of a narrow gene pool: inbreeding depression and uniform collapse
Students do: write three conservation recommendations for a local cattle breed with only 30 animals, each with a reason why it works.
Students say: why a narrower gene pool raises the risk that one disease can take out the whole population.
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Selection response | Herd mean 20.0 litres, selected mean 26.0 litres, h squared 0.3 | S is selected mean minus herd mean; multiply by h squared | R is 1.8 litres; next generation 21.8 |
| Effective population size | 2 bulls and 20 cows | Ne equals 4NmNf divided by Nm plus Nf | Ne equals 7.27 |
| Rate calculation | Change in inbreeding coefficient per generation | Delta F equals 1 over 2Ne, times 100 for a percentage | About 6.9 per cent |
| Evaluation | Whether purebred selection is always good | One column of benefits, one of risks, then a position | The position must match the reasons and mention the gene pool |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Herd mean 20.0 litres, selected mean 26.0 litres, h squared 0.3: find R and the next mean | R is 1.8 litres; the next generation averages 21.8 | Check the subtraction then multiplication, and units |
| Find Ne for 2 bulls and 20 cows | Ne equals 7.27 | Check they divide 4NmNf by the total |
| With Ne of 7.27, by what percentage does the inbreeding coefficient rise each generation | About 6.9 per cent | Check 1 over 2Ne and the conversion to a percentage |
| State two consequences of a narrow gene pool with an example each | Inbreeding depression (pedigree dog disorders); uniform collapse (single variety and blight) | Check both consequences include the mechanism |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Treating the selection differential as the response | Answer: the next generation gains 6.0 litres | 6.0 litres is how much better the chosen animals are, not how much is passed on. Multiply by heritability, 0.3. |
| Assuming a big herd means a big gene pool | Answer: 200 cows give a wide gene pool | Only 2 bulls and 20 cows pass on genes, so Ne is 7.27. Count parents, not animals. |
| Reporting an inbreeding rise of tens of per cent | Answer: it rises 14.5 per cent each generation | Delta F is 1 over 2Ne. A small Ne makes it rise fast, but you cannot skip the division. |
| Confusing selective breeding with genetic engineering | Answer: selective breeding cuts a gene out and inserts it | Selective breeding only decides which animals mate; the genes never leave the species. Cutting and inserting is genetic engineering. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- IGCSE Biology prep guides: inheritance index — Question types 1 to 4, focusing on selection response and Ne
- Genetic engineering and GM crops (related chapter) — Compare selective breeding with genetic modification
- Redo this chapter — Practice questions 1, 3 and 5: selection response, Delta F, conservation advice
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Selection response formula | R equals h squared times S, and R is smaller than S | Wrong: reteach Act 1 |
| Effective population size | Ne equals 4NmNf over Nm plus Nf; here 7.27 | Wrong: reteach Act 2 |
| Consequences of a narrow gene pool | Inbreeding depression; uniform collapse against one disease | Wrong: reteach Act 3 |
09 Tutor FAQ
Why does progress slow after several generations?
Additive genetic variance becomes fixed, so there is less variation left to select; inbreeding also reduces fertility and slows the whole programme.
How far can effective population size fall below the head count?
Very far. A skewed sex ratio or a handful of breeding animals can push Ne to a few per cent of the herd, as with 200 cows giving 7.27, so conservation plans count parents rather than animals.
Does conserving a gene pool block improvement?
No. Conservation keeps options: local breeds hold disease resistance and heat tolerance that may matter later. Selection can proceed in parallel; the aim is simply to avoid shrinking the pool beyond recovery.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



