/en-tutor-prep-s1-english-writing-paragraph-structure/
/en-tutor-prep-s1-english-writing-paragraph-structure/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S1 English|Writing: Paragraph Structure — Tutor Prep Guide|Topic sentence, evidence, explanation, closing

S1 English|Writing: Paragraph Structure — Tutor Prep Guide|Topic sentence, evidence, explanation, closing

  • 2026-11-19

Students pile every idea into one sentence, then move to the next idea, so the paragraph never builds. This lesson fixes four slots with a word count and a job each, so students can count which sentence is missing.

Objectives — By the end students can: (1) name the four slots of a paragraph — a 15-word topic sentence, 25 words of evidence, 30 of explanation and 20 of closing, 90 words in total; (2) write a topic sentence that can be proved, without a question mark and without I think; (3) use the explanation sentence to state the link between evidence and stance instead of adding another example; (4) work at 5 minutes planning, 30 minutes writing and 5 minutes checking, which at 10 words a minute yields 300 words or three 90-word paragraphs plus a 30-word opening; (5) self-mark a paragraph against an 8-mark table of topic 2, evidence 2, explanation 3 and closing 1, and name the sentence to rewrite.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Complete sentences the difference between a subject-verb-object sentence and a fragment rewrite three fragments as full sentences
Connectives First, In addition, For example, As a result, In short pick the right two for one paragraph
Sense of 90 words how many handwritten lines 90 words take write 90 words and count the lines

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0–8 min Diagnostic give a topic and ask for one paragraph in five minutes count the sentences and the shortest one
8–18 min Map of four slots board 15, 25, 30, 20 and the total of 90 write the four numbers beside the four sentences
18–30 min Three topic patterns model three provable patterns and three weak ones rewrite three weak topic sentences
30–42 min Evidence and explanation model facts in sentence two, links in sentence three move the second example into an explanation
42–54 min Timed writing time 30 minutes for three paragraphs of 90 words finish three paragraphs with a connective in each
54–60 min Exit check three oral questions, rewrite what is wrong self-mark the weakest paragraph on the 8-mark table

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: A paragraph is four sentences, not one

Act one fixes the shape. A paragraph is 90 words in four sentences, each doing one job: a 15-word topic sentence states the stance, a 25-word evidence sentence carries one checkable fact, a 30-word explanation sentence says how that fact supports the stance, and a 20-word closing sentence returns to the topic. The four numbers add up to 90. The usual failure is packing all four jobs into one long sentence held together with commas, so no topic sentence can be found. Length is not the point: 110 words usually means a second example has crept in and the explanation has thinned out. Full stops are the tool that separates one job from the next.
Students repeat: topic fifteen, evidence twenty-five, explanation thirty, closing twenty, ninety in total.

Students do: label the four sentences of their last paragraph with 15, 25, 30 and 20, then circle whichever sentence overruns.

Scene 2: A topic sentence must be provable

Act two is the topic sentence. A usable one can be supported by a single fact, so three patterns work: Schools should … because …; … is more important than …; The main reason for … is …. Three do not work: a question such as Why should school start later?, because it carries no stance; an I think opening, because it turns the claim into a private opinion no evidence can settle; and a statement everyone already accepts. The test is simple — if you cannot name one checkable fact in support, it is not a topic sentence.
Students repeat: provable, no question mark, no I think.

Students do: rewrite three weak topic sentences, one question, one I think and one empty claim, in fifteen words each.

Scene 3: Evidence and explanation have separate jobs

Act three handles the easiest place to lose marks. The evidence sentence carries facts only: a year, a number, one concrete situation, all within 25 words. The explanation sentence never repeats the fact; it says so what — how that fact supports the stance. When the two blur, students add a second example in the explanation slot and the paragraph becomes two examples and no reasoning, which loses the three explanation marks outright. The check is mechanical: read the explanation sentence and count new names or new nouns. A single new example means it has become evidence, so rewrite it as a link such as This shows that or As a result.
Students repeat: facts in the evidence, links in the explanation, no new example.

Students do: delete the second example in a paragraph and rewrite it as a 30-word explanation opening with This shows that.

Scene 4: Forty minutes and the eight-mark table

Act four ties time to marks. The writing task runs 40 minutes: 5 planning, 30 writing, 5 checking. At 10 words a minute, 30 minutes yields 300 words — three paragraphs of 90 plus a 30-word opening, which is the safest length at this level. The planning minutes produce one thing only: three topic sentences of fifteen words. The checking minutes do two things only: count the sentences in each paragraph and look for about or also inside the closing sentence. Self-mark on the 8-mark table, topic 2, evidence 2, explanation 3, closing 1. One mark for explanation means the paragraph never developed, so sentence three is rewritten rather than padded.
Students repeat: five minutes planning, thirty writing, five checking, explanation worth three of eight.

Students do: mark the weakest paragraph on the table, name the sentence to rewrite and rewrite it on the spot.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Topic sentence Schools should start later because teenagers need more sleep. stance plus reason in fifteen words Schools should start later because teenagers need more sleep.
Evidence A survey of 200 students found that 68 per cent felt sleepy in the first lesson. checkable facts or numbers only A survey of 200 students found that 68 per cent felt sleepy.
Explanation This shows that an early start costs attention, which extra homework cannot repair. the link, never a new example This shows that an early start costs attention.
Closing In short, a later start would protect the first lesson of every day. returns to the topic, no new claim In short, a later start would protect the first lesson.
Connectives First, In addition, For example, As a result, In short at most two in a paragraph For example opens the evidence, As a result opens the explanation
Sanity check (teach this): Four checks: (1) a paragraph past 110 words usually hides a second example that belongs in the explanation slot; (2) if no checkable fact can be named, the topic sentence is not a claim; (3) a closing sentence containing about, also or another has opened a new topic; (4) one explanation mark out of three means the paragraph never developed, so the third sentence is rewritten rather than lengthened.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Topic rewrite turn I think school is good into a provable claim stance and reason within fifteen words Schools should … because …
Add an explanation given the evidence sentence, add 30 words of explanation links only, no new example This shows that …
Word control write one paragraph and count each sentence 15, 25, 30, 20, 90 in total over budget means cutting the extra example
Connective marking add First, In addition and In short to three paragraphs at most two per paragraph For example for evidence
Self-mark mark one paragraph on the 8-mark table name the weakest sentence and the fix topic 2, evidence 2, explanation 3, closing 1

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
One long sentence per paragraph every idea joined with commas and a single full stop A paragraph is four sentences in four jobs. Full stops separate the jobs, they are not decoration.
Question or I think as the topic Why should school start later? I think it is good. The topic must be provable. Questions and I think cannot be proved, so write Schools should … because … instead.
A second example in the explanation forty words on another example and five words of explanation Turn the second example into explanation: say how the fact supports the stance.
About in the closing In short, school should also think about lunch time. The closing returns to this topic only. About or also opens a new front, so delete the sentence.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Four slots 15, 25, 30, 20, total 90 cannot give the total, redo act one
Topic rule provable, no question, no I think still writing a question, redo act two
Explanation job the link between fact and stance still adding examples there, redo act three

09 Tutor FAQ

Does a longer paragraph score higher

No. Four sentences with four jobs are enough at 90 words. Past 110 words there is usually an extra example and a thin explanation.

What if there is no time for three paragraphs

Write the topic sentences first, then add evidence and explanation. A paragraph with a topic sentence still scores; one without it scores near zero.

Can students memorise a model paragraph

Phrases yes, whole paragraphs no. A different topic breaks the memorised evidence, and the explanation turns empty.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →