Junior Secondary Geography | Hong Kong Manufacturing to Services: Deindustrialisation and the Four Pillars (Tutor Guide)
- 2026-11-21
Students have heard that Hong Kong factories moved to the mainland, yet cannot say which stage moved, how far the share fell, or which service industries replaced them. Three numbers carry the whole topic: manufacturing fell from 22.8 per cent of GDP to about 1, employment from 41.2 per cent to 2.5, and the four pillars now hold about 59.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Industrial location | Which three groups of factors decide where a factory goes | Land, labour, transport and market |
| Production cost | What rising wages and rents do to a factory | Costs rise, margins fall, so firms look elsewhere |
| GDP | What kind of value GDP measures | The final goods and services produced in a place in a period |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Check and hook | Ask three prerequisite questions, open with a 1980s factory photograph | List the three groups of location factors |
| 6-20 min | Why they moved | Two push factors on wages and rents, two pull factors on cheap land, labour and tax | Write two push and two pull factors |
| 20-34 min | Front shop, back factory | Split ordering, production and export between Hong Kong and the Pearl River Delta | Draw a two-box division diagram |
| 34-46 min | Numbers and graphs | Work from 22.8 to 1 per cent and 41.2 to 2.5 per cent | Write the percentage fall and the ratio |
| 46-55 min | Four pillars | One example and one share for each service pillar | Complete four rows and check the total |
| 55-60 min | Exit check | Ask whether manufacturing employment or its GDP share fell faster | Answer with one pair of numbers |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Why the factories left
Do not open with the phrase reform and opening up; open with cost. Through the 1980s Hong Kong wages and rents climbed together, pushing up both payroll and floor space, while the Pearl River Delta offered cheap land, plentiful labour and duty-free import of materials under processing trade rules. One side pushed, the other pulled.
Have students keep two columns: push covers wages, rents, environmental rules and scarce land; pull covers cheaper land and labour, tax incentives and a nearby port. The factor students forget is transport: a lorry from a Delta factory reaches the Hong Kong container terminal in hours, which is exactly what makes the front-shop-back-factory model work.
What moved was the production stage, not the whole firm
Scene 2: Front shop, back factory
Write three stages on the board: orders and design stay in Hong Kong, production sits in the Delta, exports pass through Hong Kong port. Students often conclude that the city lost its industry altogether, when what remained was management, design, finance, logistics and trading, all of which count as services.
Close with one sentence: manufacturing jobs left Hong Kong, but manufacturing services stayed. That sentence is the hinge between deindustrialisation and the rise of services, and it sets up the four pillars.
Shop in Hong Kong, factory across the border
Scene 3: Numbers make deindustrialisation visible
Manufacturing fell from about 22.8 per cent of GDP in 1980 to about 1 per cent recently, a fall of 95.6 per cent; its employment share fell from about 41.2 per cent to about 2.5 per cent, a sixteen-fold contraction. Over the same period services rose from about 67.3 to about 93.5 per cent: services were already 2.95 times manufacturing in 1980, and the gap is now about 94 times.
Give the four pillars with shares: finance and insurance about 22.4, trading and logistics about 22.5, professional and producer services about 12.6, tourism about 1.5, together about 59, with other services about 34.5 to reach 93.5. Require both halves every time, or students will treat the four pillars as the whole service sector.
From 22.8 to 1 per cent: that fall is deindustrialisation
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Data description | Describe the change in the manufacturing share of GDP | Give start, end, direction and size, all four | From about 22.8 per cent in 1980 to about 1 per cent, a fall of about 95.6 per cent |
| Factor analysis | Explain why factories moved to the Delta | Two push and two pull factors, each tied to cost | Push: wages and rents; pull: cheap land and labour, tax incentives |
| Division of labour | Use front shop, back factory to describe the link | Assign ordering, production and export to each side | Orders and design in Hong Kong, production in the Delta, export through Hong Kong |
| Impact evaluation | What deindustrialisation did to Hong Kong | Two positive and two negative points | Positive: service upgrading and higher incomes; negative: low-skill job losses and a narrow base |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing falls from 22.8 to 1 per cent of GDP: how many percentage points, and what percentage fall? | 21.8 percentage points, which is a 95.6 per cent fall | Did you separate percentage points from per cent |
| Write two push and two pull factors for the relocation | Push: wages and rents; pull: cheap land and labour, tax incentives | Is each factor tied back to cost |
| What share do the four pillars hold, and what is left for other services? | About 59 per cent, with other services about 34.5, giving 93.5 | Do the two add to 93.5 |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Mixing points with per cent | The manufacturing share fell by 21.8 per cent | From 22.8 to 1 is a fall of 21.8 percentage points, which is 95.6 per cent in relative terms. Saying it fell by 21.8 per cent implies 17.8 per cent remains, which contradicts the data. |
| Assuming industry vanished | Hong Kong has no manufacturing left at all | A small sector remains, still near 1 per cent of GDP, making food, printed matter, jewellery and new industrial products. Say that manufacturing shrank sharply rather than that it disappeared. |
| Treating four pillars as all services | Hong Kong services are finance, logistics, professional services and tourism, full stop | The four pillars hold about 59 per cent; the other 34.5 per cent covers retail, food, education, health and public administration. Leaving that out turns 93.5 into 59 and contradicts itself. |
| Ignoring transport in location | Factories moved to the Delta only because wages were lower | Many places have low wages; the Delta was chosen because it is close. Materials and finished goods can move between factory and container terminal within a day, which is what makes the two-part model viable. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Write 80 words describing deindustrialisation using both number pairs — Four figures, with direction and size of change
- Draw a front-shop-back-factory diagram labelling ordering, production and export — Two boxes and arrows, three roles clear
- List the four pillars with one Hong Kong example and an approximate share each — Four rows, total about 59 per cent
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| What was the manufacturing share of GDP, before and after? | About 22.8 per cent down to about 1 per cent, a fall of 95.6 per cent | Reteach act three and its numbers |
| Name the three stages of the front-shop-back-factory split | Orders and design in Hong Kong, production in the Delta, export through Hong Kong | Reteach act two and the diagram |
| What share do the four pillars hold together? | About 59 per cent, with other services about 34.5 | Reteach act three and the four-row table |
09 Tutor FAQ
Must students memorise the CEPA year?
2003 signature and 2004 implementation are enough. The point is that it lowered barriers for Hong Kong service firms entering the mainland, which matches the direction of the shift.
Is the shift to services good or bad?
Both sides. Incomes and professional standards rose, while the industrial base narrowed and low-skill workers struggled to transfer.
Do S1 students need exact percentages?
Approximate figures are enough: 22.8, 1, 41.2, 2.5, 93.5 and 59. Require the word about so the class does not treat them as exact statistics.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



