S2 English: compare and contrast essays (tutor lesson plan)
- 2026-11-21
Eight sentences in ten say both are good. This lesson teaches one thing: every criterion needs a checkable number underneath it, or the sentence is not a comparison.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Comparatives | When do you use more effective and when the most effective? | More for two things, the most for three or more |
| Contrast connectors | How do however and whereas sit differently in a sentence? | However opens a sentence with a comma; whereas joins two balanced clauses |
| Topic sentences | What does the first sentence of a paragraph do? | States the one claim that paragraph makes |
02 Lesson flow (30 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-5 min | Write two sentences cold | Online or face-to-face, no data given | A position with no evidence |
| 5-12 min | Fix three criteria | Flexibility, interaction, concentration | Three noun phrases |
| 12-20 min | One data sentence each | Survey of 200: 140 chose online, 70 per cent | Three evidence sentences |
| 20-26 min | Evaluation paragraph | The position hangs on one criterion | One position, one criterion |
| 26-30 min | Exit check | Mark live and correct live | Three out of three |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Fix the criteria before the position: this is not an opinion piece
The criteria must be relevant and must be measurable. Three criteria make three body paragraphs, and 240 words divided by three is about 80 words each, which keeps the length even without effort.
The product of this step is a three-by-two table. If the table cannot be filled, the fault is in the reading, not in the writing.
Ask the student: which of your three criteria will be hardest to find a number for?
Scene 2: One data sentence per criterion: a comparison without a number is an opinion
The evidence sentence has four slots: criterion, subject, number, source. In the survey of 200 students, 70 per cent chose online lessons, compared with 30 per cent who chose face-to-face teaching.
Only then add the contrast connector. However opens a sentence with a comma; whereas joins two balanced clauses in the middle. Either is correct, but one per paragraph, or the paragraph reads as a list.
Ask the student: how many percentage points separate 70 per cent and 30 per cent?
Scene 3: Judge in the evaluation paragraph, and name the criterion
That sentence attaches the position to two criteria, flexibility and interaction. Writing both are good answers nothing, because the question asks to what extent.
Remind students how the marks fall: content 8, language 8, organisation 4, 20 in total. Content is not awarded for the right side; it is awarded for three criteria each carrying one piece of evidence. Organisation is awarded for four paragraphs with one job each.
Ask the student: which criterion does your position rest on, and why not the other one?
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Set the criteria | Three criteria for two things | Three noun phrases, each measurable | Flexibility, interaction, concentration |
| Evidence sentence | One data sentence per criterion | Criterion, subject, number, source | 70 per cent against 30 per cent, a gap of 40 points |
| Contrast connectors | Mark the difference with however or whereas | However opens with a comma, whereas joins balanced clauses | Online suits X, whereas face-to-face suits Y |
| Evaluation paragraph | Give the judgement at the end | Attach it to a criterion and a type of student | One sentence, no new criterion |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| 140 of 200 students chose online lessons: what percentage is that? | 70 per cent | Whether the division used the whole survey |
| How many percentage points separate that from the face-to-face share? | 40 percentage points | Whether the two shares were subtracted rather than divided |
| Three criteria in 240 words: how long is each body paragraph? | about 80 words | Whether the words were shared out rather than piled into paragraph one |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Position first, reasons afterwards | Opening with online lessons are better, then three paragraphs on the same point | Write the three criteria first and keep the judgement for the last paragraph. |
| Comparisons with no data | Writing online lessons are more convenient and stopping there | A comparison without a number is an opinion. Put 70 per cent in the sentence. |
| However and whereas mixed | Writing online is better, however face-to-face is better too | However opens a sentence with a comma; whereas needs two balanced clauses, once per paragraph. |
| Four paragraphs, one idea | Three paragraphs all about convenience | One criterion per paragraph. Overlapping criteria cost a paragraph of marks. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- S2 English writing paper, comparison task — Question 2: hand in the three-by-two criteria table before the 240 words; an essay without the table is returned unmarked.
- Same paper, contrast connectors — Question 4: rewrite five however sentences as whereas sentences with balanced clauses, in 12 minutes.
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| How many criteria does a comparison need | Three, one paragraph each | Answering as many as possible means reteach the first script |
| The gap between 70 and 30 per cent | 40 percentage points | Answering 2.33 times means points and ratios were confused |
| Where the judgement goes | The evaluation or closing paragraph, tied to a criterion | Answering paragraph one means reteach the third script |
09 Tutor FAQ
Must the essay have five paragraphs?
Four is enough: introduction, two criteria paragraphs and an evaluation. Three is rushed, and five leaves 48 words each at 240 words, which is too thin.
Is the first person allowed?
Avoid I think in an explanatory essay. The survey suggests or It is reasonable to argue keeps the register steady.
Must the data come from the question?
Yes. The survey figures in the question are the only source; invented numbers lose marks and weaken the argument.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



