S2 Physics | Energy Sources and Generation Lesson-Prep Guide (for tutors) | Classification, Chains, Efficiency, Renewables
- 2026-11-20
Students can say solar power is green, but they cannot trace the light of a lamp back through its energy chain, and they cannot say why efficiency must stay below one. This lesson turns energy talk into two tools: the conversion chain and the efficiency ratio.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Energy forms | Which energy forms appear when a torch is switched on? | Chemical to electrical, then light and heat |
| Power | What does 1000 watts mean? | One thousand joules of energy every second, which is one kilowatt |
| Percentages | Write 38 out of 100 as a percentage | 38 percent, that is 0.38 |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Diagnose | Ask where the electricity for a lamp comes from and write it as a chain | Write first, then mark every missing link |
| 6-18 min | Classify sources | Sort ten sources into renewable and non-renewable and discuss the Hong Kong mix | Nuclear is low carbon but non-renewable |
| 18-32 min | Chains and generation | Trace coal to lamp link by link, then compare wind and solar | Every link needs a named loss |
| 32-46 min | Efficiency sums | A plant takes 1000 megajoules and delivers 380 for 38 percent, then a 60 watt lamp gives 6 watts of light | Divide in the same unit |
| 46-55 min | Capacity and emissions | A 3 megawatt turbine at 30 percent averages 0.9 megawatts and 7884 megawatt hours a year, then 300 units of carbon | Capacity factor is not efficiency |
| 55-60 min | Exit check | Three quick questions: classify, chain, efficiency | All three right before the student leaves |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Two classes of source: exhaustible and renewable
Write ten sources in two columns: coal, oil, gas and nuclear fuel are non-renewable, while sun, wind, water, geothermal, biomass and tides are renewable. The only test is whether people use them faster than nature replenishes them. Warn students that nuclear power is low carbon yet still non-renewable, so low carbon and renewable are two different rulers and must not be mixed.
Make it concrete with Hong Kong: almost no local fuel deposits, so generation depends on imported fuel plus a small renewable share, which means any energy discussion must include supply security and price. Push it with questions: what happens at night with solar only, and who absorbs price swings when gas is imported.
Tutor line: classification is a tool, so the reason matters more than the list.
Scene 2: One conversion chain beats ten definitions
Have students write coal, boiler, steam, turbine, generator, transformer and lamp as a chain, naming the energy form and the loss at each link: burning is chemical to thermal, the turbine and generator lose energy to friction and heat, and transmission lines lose energy to resistance. Wind skips the first links, while solar converts light to electricity directly, so the chain is short but weather dependent.
Then compare the same lamp powered by coal and by a rooftop panel: which links disappear, which appear. Students discover that renewables do not remove losses, they relocate them and add intermittency as a cost. This is the step that turns a slogan into an engineering judgement.
Tutor line: a link that only says becomes electricity has done no work, so name the loss.
Scene 3: Efficiency turns every green argument into arithmetic
Efficiency is useful output over total input in the same unit, always below one. A coal plant taking 1000 megajoules and delivering 380 megajoules of electricity is 38 percent efficient, with 62 percent leaving through cooling towers and flue gas. A 60 watt lamp gives 6 watts of light and 54 watts of heat, so 10 percent, which is why lighting moved to LEDs: efficiency, not fashion.
Then use capacity factor for renewables: a 3 megawatt turbine at 30 percent averages 0.9 megawatts and produces 7884 megawatt hours over 8760 hours. Capacity factor is not efficiency, it is actual output over rated output, and mixing the two is the most common conceptual error. Close with emissions: at 0.7 kilograms of carbon dioxide per unit of electricity, a household using 300 units emits 210 kilograms a month, which is the arithmetic behind every policy debate.
Tutor line: put efficiency and capacity factor side by side on one sheet and define both.
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classification | Sort solar, gas, nuclear fuel and wind into two classes | Ask about replenishment speed, then flag nuclear as low carbon but non-renewable | Renewable: solar and wind; non-renewable: gas and nuclear fuel |
| Conversion chain | Write the chain from coal to a lamp | Name the energy form and the loss at each link, at least five links | Chemical, thermal, mechanical, electrical, then light and heat |
| Efficiency | A plant takes 1000 megajoules and delivers 380: efficiency? | Useful over total input times 100 percent, same unit | 38 percent |
| Capacity and output | A 3 megawatt turbine at 30 percent: annual output? | Multiply by 0.30 for average power, then by 8760 hours | 0.9 megawatts, 7884 megawatt hours |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiency match | A 60 watt filament lamp and a 9 watt LED give the same light: how many times more efficient? | Compare input power at equal light output, roughly 6.7 times |
| Missing links | What is missing from the chain wind to electricity? | The mechanical stage and the generator |
| Emissions estimate | At 0.7 kilograms per unit, what does 300 units emit? | Expect 210 kilograms |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Low carbon equals renewable | Putting nuclear fuel in the renewable column | Two different rulers, and nuclear fuel is exhaustible |
| Capacity factor as efficiency | Writing that a turbine is 30 percent efficient | Capacity factor compares output with rated power, efficiency compares energy forms |
| Mixed units | Dividing megajoules by kilowatt hours | Convert everything to one unit first |
| Chains without losses | Stopping at the generator converts motion into electricity | Name the friction and resistance losses or efficiency cannot be explained |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Physics chapter index — All chapters in this subject, starting with one item from each question type
- Junior secondary overview — Check how this chapter links to S3 work and energy
- S2 science index — Extension: the chapter on energy forms and efficiency
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Classification | State the test used | A memorised list needs the replenishment rule added |
| Efficiency sum | 1000 megajoules in, 380 out | Only 38 percent counts as a pass |
| Capacity factor | One sentence on how it differs from efficiency | Any confusion means re-teaching with the turbine example |
09 Tutor FAQ
Should we quote the exact Hong Kong generation mix
Keep it qualitative, fossil fuel dominant with a small renewable share, to avoid numbers that age badly.
Do we take a side on nuclear power
No, present low carbon and non-renewable side by side and let students weigh them.
Do efficiency questions include losses
Yes, require the main loss to be named, with the calculation limited to one step.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



