Junior English — Comparing Two Texts Lesson Prep Guide (for tutors) — comparison matrix, tone counts, quotations and comparative language
- 2026-11-21
Students who finish two texts usually write two separate summaries with no comparison. This lesson uses one matrix, a set of tone counts and three comparative patterns to turn the question into cells to fill and sentences to write.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Finding the main idea | Where does a paragraph usually state its main idea | Usually in the first or last sentence |
| Tone words | What do words such as harsh and encouraging show | The writer attitude towards the topic |
| Comparative patterns | Does whereas join two similar or two opposite ideas | Two opposite ideas |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-8 min | Diagnostic start | Give two sentences with opposite stances and ask which text each belongs to | Write one sentence and underline the clue words |
| 8-20 min | Act one: the matrix | Model a three by two matrix and align points cell by cell | Fill a three row matrix for two short texts |
| 20-36 min | Act two: tone and stance | Count tone words, compute the net value and state the contrast | Circle tone words and record the counts |
| 36-50 min | Act three: patterns, quotes and time | Model comparative patterns, short quotes and the word budget | Write one sentence with whereas and one with by contrast |
| 50-56 min | Independent practice | Hand out three items and patrol, prompting only | Work alone and circle the comparison step |
| 56-60 min | Exit check | Read three items, collect answers and count wrong ones | Answer orally and note one fuzzy idea |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Act one: build the matrix before writing
The usual habit is to read text A and write a paragraph, then read text B and write another, with no comparison between them. Change the order: open a matrix first, with three rows for the dimensions being compared, usually main claim, supporting reason and tone, and two columns for text A and text B. Each cell holds a short phrase, never a sentence.
Why a matrix? Because the mark scheme rewards contrast, not two summaries. With four shared points and two opposite ones, the shared share is 66.7 per cent and the opposite share 33.3 per cent, so a blank cell is visible at a glance and shows what has not been read.
Time the reading too: 320 and 380 words at 200 words per minute take 1.6 and 1.9 minutes, 3.5 minutes in all. Have students time one pass so they know whether they read too slowly or too fast.
Open the matrix first; a blank cell is an unread point
Scene 2: Act two: count tone, do not describe a feeling
Tone is not settled by writing that the text feels positive. Circle the tone words and count them: text A has five positive words such as encouraging and promising against one negative, a net of plus four; text B has one positive against four negatives such as harsh and wasteful, a net of minus three. The stances are opposite, which is the strongest material for a comparative sentence.
Warn against vague wording such as the writer likes it. Name the adjective, give its paragraph, and show what it signals. Tone items are most often lost because the stance is stated without evidence.
Add one check: if both texts share a stance, the answer should say both are concerned to different degrees and use a comparative rather than a contrastive pattern. This stops students forcing whereas into a similarity.
Count positive and negative words and cite the paragraph
Scene 3: Act three: patterns, short quotes and the clock
Three patterns cover almost every comparison: whereas for contrast, by contrast for a turn, and both for similarity. Each needs one worked example, and students should write two sentences on the same topic rather than recite the pattern.
Keep quotes short: eight words at most each, three at most per answer, twenty four words in total. Long quotes eat the analysis. A six mark item gives two marks per text plus two for comparative language; at fifteen words a mark the answer is about 90 words, so 150 words usually means too much quotation and too little comparison.
Teach the clock as well: eight marks out of 40 in a 50 minute paper is 20 per cent, so ten minutes. Many students spend twenty minutes here and run out of time on the long writing task, which is a planning problem rather than a language problem.
Ninety words and ten minutes for six marks, with at most three quotes
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matrix alignment | Two texts each give one supporting reason; how do they line up | Three rows, two columns, one phrase per cell | Same row, A on the left and B on the right |
| Tone comparison | Text A has 5 positive and 1 negative word, text B 1 positive and 4 negative | Compute the net value for each and compare | Opposite stances, nets of plus 4 and minus 3 |
| Comparative pattern | Write the opposing views of one practice in one sentence | Join with whereas or by contrast | Whereas text A supports it, text B calls it wasteful |
| Word and time budget | How long should a six mark comparison be and how long should it take | Fifteen words a mark; time in proportion to marks | About 90 words and 10 minutes |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Two texts of 400 words each at 200 words per minute; how long to read both | Two minutes each, four minutes in all | Check whether only one text was timed |
| Text A has 3 positive and 2 negative words, text B none positive and 3 negative; find the nets | Plus 1 for A and minus 3 for B | Check whether positive and negative were added instead of subtracted |
| A 50 minute paper of 40 marks has an 8 mark item; what share and how many minutes | 20 per cent, so 10 minutes | Check whether marks were used directly as minutes |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Writing two summaries | One paragraph on text A, one on text B, with no contrast | Every paragraph should hold both sides and use whereas, by contrast or both to mark similarity or difference. |
| Describing tone as a feeling | Writing that text A is positive and text B is negative | Count the tone words and cite the paragraphs, for instance 5 positive against 1 negative in A and 1 against 4 in B. |
| Quoting too much | Copying a twenty word sentence that fills half the answer | Quote at most eight words each and three per answer, and spend the saved words on analysis. |
| Losing the clock | Spending twenty minutes on an 8 mark item and running short later | Eight of 40 marks is 20 per cent, so ten minutes; build the matrix first instead of writing while reading. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- S3 English: reading inference and author purpose, section 07 practice — Do the three section 07 items and underline the tone word supporting each answer
- S3 English: reading for evidence and long answers, section 07 practice — Do only the quotation and long answer items as practice for quote length
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Two texts of 300 words each at 200 words per minute; how long in total | Three minutes | Wrong here means reteach the timing in act one |
| Besides stance, what must a tone comparison include | The number of tone words and the paragraph they come from | Wrong here means reteach act two |
| Roughly how many words should a six mark comparison take | About 90 words | Wrong here means reteach the word budget in act three |
09 Tutor FAQ
Which year is this written for
It fits the S3 English course. S4 to S6 comparison tasks allow more words, but the matrix, tone and pattern steps stay the same.
Is 60 minutes enough
Yes. Each act takes about twelve minutes, with three practice items and the rest for oral checking.
Are there practice questions
Yes. The homework rows link to section 07 practice on the inference and evidence chapters, with answers on the page.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



