/en-tutor-prep-s3-english-reading-evidence-long-answers/
/en-tutor-prep-s3-english-reading-evidence-long-answers/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S3 English|Reading: Long Answers with Evidence — Tutor Prep Guide|a 1, 2, 1 mark frame, quotations of ten words, forty-word answers

S3 English|Reading: Long Answers with Evidence — Tutor Prep Guide|a 1, 2, 1 mark frame, quotations of ten words, forty-word answers

  • 2026-11-19

Students either copy whole sentences or give an opinion with no evidence at all. This lesson splits a four-mark question into one mark of claim, two of evidence and one of link, and caps every quotation at ten words.

Objectives — By the end students can: (1) split a 4-mark long answer into three boxes — claim 1, evidence 2 (a quotation of no more than ten words plus an explanation of what it proves) and link 1; (2) explain that a 6-mark question is two 4-mark units with one link dropped, so it needs two claims with two quotations rather than one claim repeated; (3) quote only the ten essential words in quotation marks and keep the quotation to a quarter of a 40-word answer; (4) finish a question in 5 minutes at 1 for reading, 2 for finding evidence, 1 for writing and 1 for checking, and three questions in 15 minutes; (5) plan with T, E and L margin notes and join evidence to claim with This shows that…

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Command words explain, compare and suggest need different shapes of answer circle the command word and name the shape
Quotation marks quoted words take quotation marks, paraphrased words do not turn two sentences into a ten-word quotation
Link phrases This shows that, which suggests and therefore as link openers write a link sentence for one piece of evidence

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0–8 min Diagnostic show one 4-mark question and two answers, one all quotation, one with no evidence count the quoted words in each answer
8–20 min Three boxes board 1, 2, 1 and forty words at ten words a mark write the three boxes as headings
20–32 min Ten-word quotations and T, E, L model squeezing twenty words into ten, model the margin notes make two ten-word quotations from one passage
32–44 min Five minutes a question time two questions, calling each minute two answers of 40 words, quotations under ten words
44–54 min The 6-mark pair model one claim with two pieces of evidence and explain the difference write a 6-mark answer as two T and E pairs
54–60 min Exit check three oral questions, rewrite the weak box explain the difference between a 4-mark and a 6-mark answer

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: A four-mark answer is three boxes

Act one separates the marks. A 4-mark long answer is not a longer paragraph; it is three boxes: claim 1 (answer the question directly and never restate it), evidence 2 (a quotation of ten words or fewer, plus an explanation of what those words prove), and link 1 (one This shows that… sentence tying evidence to claim). Three boxes is four marks; missing evidence caps the answer at two, missing the link caps it at three. The common error is rewriting the question as a claim — the writer thinks the plan is bad because it is bad — which is a circle, not a claim. Have students draw the three boxes on rough paper and fill them before writing a connected paragraph.
Students repeat: one mark of claim, two of evidence, one of link, four in total.

Students do: take one 4-mark question, draw three boxes, fill each, then join them into a 40-word answer.

Scene 2: Ten words of quotation, the rest in your own words

Act two is quotation length. Students believe more quotation earns more marks and copy twenty words, so half of a 40-word answer is the passage and there is no room to explain: a quotation should be about a quarter of the answer, ten words, leaving thirty for explanation and link. The method is to underline the key sentence, then lift only the ten most probative words, usually a verb and its object such as rose by 12% or refused to comment, put them in quotation marks and follow immediately with This shows that… Copying a whole sentence also costs time: twenty words takes over a minute, and five minutes a question cannot afford it.
Students repeat: ten words of quotation, a quarter of the answer.

Students do: turn one twenty-word passage into two different ten-word quotations, each followed by a This shows that… sentence.

Scene 3: A six-mark question is two four-mark units

Act three covers the 6-mark question. Six marks is not a longer version of four; it is 2 × (1 + 2) = 6, two claim-and-evidence pairs with the second link dropped. So the answer needs two different points, each supported from a different part of the passage. The usual failure is one point made twice in different words: the length looks right but there is one piece of evidence and the answer caps at three. Have students write two points in the margin and underline two separate passages, one per point. If the question says Give two reasons, the two underlinings must come from different paragraphs, which is the fastest self-check.
Students repeat: six marks is two four-mark units with one link dropped.

Students do: split a 6-mark question into two T and E pairs and underline one passage for each, confirming they sit in different paragraphs.

Scene 4: Five minutes a question, T E L in the margin

Act four is pace. Five minutes a question split 1 reading, 2 finding evidence, 1 writing, 1 checking, and three long answers in fifteen minutes, leaving the rest of the paper for short answers and multiple choice. The two evidence minutes work by returning to the command word, scanning topic sentences and quoted speech, underlining on sight and marking the margin T for claim or E for evidence; writing then expands the notes without rereading the passage. The checking minute does three things: count the quoted words, confirm a This shows that… sentence, confirm the claim answers the command word. Time the class aloud; the third question is where they overrun, and that is their true pace.
Students repeat: one minute reading, two finding, one writing, one checking.

Students do: answer two questions under a minute-by-minute clock and write the actual time used beside each answer.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
4-mark frame The writer opposes the plan because it is “too costly for a small school”. claim, ten-word quotation, link The writer opposes the plan because it is “too costly”.
Quotation too long The writer says the plan “would take money away from the music room and the library at the same time”. twenty words quoted, half the answer … “would take money from the music room”.
Link sentence This shows that cost, not space, is the writer’s main concern. one sentence tying evidence to claim This shows that cost is the main concern.
6-mark pair One reason is cost: “too costly”. Another is timing: “the site opens in June”. two claims, two quotations, different paragraphs Two reasons: cost and timing.
Weak claim The writer is negative about the plan. no quotation, no link, one mark only The writer calls the plan “too costly”.
Sanity check (teach this): Four checks: (1) no quotation marks means the evidence box scores zero, so add a ten-word quotation; (2) a quotation over ten words takes half the answer, so cut to the most probative words; (3) no This shows that… sentence loses the link mark; (4) both underlinings in a 6-mark answer coming from one paragraph means one point only, so find a second paragraph.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Three boxes write a 4-mark answer as three headings each box filled claim 1, evidence 2, link 1
Squeeze a quotation turn twenty words into ten two versions “rose by 12%”
Link it write one This shows that… sentence per quotation ties back to the claim This shows that…
Two units write a 6-mark answer as two T and E pairs two different paragraphs 6 = 2 × (1 + 2)
Timed three three questions at five minutes each fifteen minutes in total 1, 2, 1, 1

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Copying the whole sentence half the answer is the passage, with no explanation Cap the quotation at ten words and explain the rest.
Claim with no evidence The writer is negative about the plan. Every claim needs quoted words after it.
One point twice at six marks two paragraphs both about cost Two points, two passages, two underlinings.
Answering the wrong command word describing when the question says suggest Circle the command word before choosing the shape.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Four boxes claim 1, evidence 2, link 1 cannot say it, redo act two
Quotation cap ten words, a quarter of the answer says twenty, redo act three
Six-mark shape two four-mark units, one link dropped says longer, redo act five

09 Tutor FAQ

Can students paraphrase instead of quoting

They can, but the evidence mark needs to point at specific words, so the paraphrase must still name the phrase being used.

Is a quotation over ten words always penalised

Ten words is a teaching cap that preserves room to explain. A copied sentence squeezes out the explanation, and that is where the marks go.

Can a 6-mark answer make one point deeply

It can, but it then needs two pieces of evidence behind that one claim, or it earns only one evidence pair.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →