/en-tutor-prep-s3-english-writing-argumentative-essay/
/en-tutor-prep-s3-english-writing-argumentative-essay/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S3 English|Writing: Argumentative Essay — Tutor Prep Guide|Five paragraphs, 420 words, a counter-argument

S3 English|Writing: Argumentative Essay — Tutor Prep Guide|Five paragraphs, 420 words, a counter-argument

  • 2026-11-19

Students agree with themselves for four paragraphs, give three reasons for the same point, and leave the counter-argument blank. This lesson fixes the job and length of five paragraphs and turns the counter-argument into a formula.

Objectives — By the end students can: (1) state the five-paragraph shape — an opening of 50 words, two body paragraphs of 130, a counter-argument of 60 and a conclusion of 50, 420 words in total; (2) finish in 50 minutes at 8 planning, 39 writing and 3 checking, about 10.8 words a minute; (3) use the counter-argument formula Some people argue that …, but … to state the strongest objection before answering it; (4) separate reason from example, keeping one example per paragraph and spending the other three sentences on explanation; (5) self-mark against 20 marks of content 8, language 8 and organisation 4, and say which paragraph loses organisation marks.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Stance sentences the difference between I agree that … and I partly agree … write one clear stance sentence
Connectives However, Therefore, Furthermore, On the other hand use two correctly in one paragraph
Sense of length how many handwritten lines 420 words take write 130 words and count the lines

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0–8 min Diagnostic give a topic and three minutes for a stance and three reasons check whether the three reasons are the same point
8–18 min Map of five paragraphs board 50, 130, 130, 60, 50 and 420 copy the five numbers onto an outline
18–30 min Counter-argument formula model Some people argue that …, but … and a one-line answer write a 60-word counter-argument for one topic
30–42 min Reason and example model one example and three explanatory sentences cut a two-example paragraph down to one
42–54 min Timed writing time 39 minutes for 420 words finish five paragraphs and mark each first sentence
54–60 min Exit check three oral questions, rewrite what is wrong self-mark on 20 marks and name the weakest paragraph

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Do the arithmetic before the first sentence

Act one fixes the quantity. Four hundred and twenty words split five ways: a 50-word opening with the stance and two signposts, two body paragraphs of 130, a 60-word counter-argument and a 50-word conclusion. Students routinely write four paragraphs, folding the counter-argument into a body paragraph, where it collapses to a single sentence and the organisation mark falls with it. The paragraphs have different jobs and cannot merge: the body argues your reasons, the counter-argument handles the strongest opposing reason, and a However turn must sit between them. The number of paragraphs is the first thing an examiner sees, so five complete paragraphs already secures the base organisation mark.
Students repeat: fifty, one hundred and thirty, one hundred and thirty, sixty, fifty, four hundred and twenty in total.

Students do: write the five numbers on an outline and fill one topic sentence per paragraph before drafting any prose.

Scene 2: The counter-argument formula: strongest objection, then one limit

Act two supplies the counter-argument, the paragraph students leave empty. Three steps: Some people argue that plus the strongest objection in 25 words, However plus a concession in 10 words, and one reason this does not convince me plus the answer in 25 words, about 60 words together. The common misunderstanding is that the counter-argument must agree with the other side, so students write a paragraph with no stance, or make the objection stronger than their own case. The right move is to grant the objection its best form and then name one limit: if uniforms reduce comparison, say that the effect is weak in senior years.
Students repeat: give the objection its strongest form, then name one limit.

Students do: write two counter-arguments on one topic, one that only concedes and one that concedes then answers, and compare which keeps the stance alive.

Scene 3: One example, three explanations

Act three is the body paragraph. A 130-word paragraph holds one example and three explanatory sentences: one for the cause, one for the consequence, one tying back to the stance. Students instead line up two examples, so both sentences carry facts and neither carries reasoning, and the content mark stalls. The check is to count names and numbers: two or more means too many examples. The second one is either deleted or rewritten as explanation with This means that or As a result. A workable split of 130 words is 20 for the topic sentence, 40 for the example, 50 for explanation and 20 for the tie-back.
Students repeat: one example a paragraph, the other three sentences explain.

Students do: label every sentence in a 130-word paragraph as topic, example, explanation or tie-back, and delete any sentence that fits none of the four.

Scene 4: Fifty minutes and twenty marks

Act four ties time to marks. Fifty minutes divide into 8 for planning, 39 for writing and 3 for checking. Writing 420 words in 39 minutes is about 10.8 words a minute, which leaves no room for composing sentences mid-flow. The writing minutes split again: 5 for the opening, 12 for each body paragraph, 6 for the counter-argument and 4 for the conclusion. The 3 checking minutes do two things only: count the paragraphs and confirm the counter-argument contains However and an answer. Self-mark on 20 marks of content 8, language 8 and organisation 4, and note that the organisation mark most often falls in the counter-argument, the one paragraph students skip.
Students repeat: eight planning, thirty-nine writing, three checking, ten point eight words a minute.

Students do: self-mark once on the 20-mark table and circle the paragraph most likely to lose organisation marks.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Stance I agree that school uniforms should be relaxed because they cost families money. one stance, one reason, no repeated I think I agree that school uniforms should be relaxed.
Body topic First, uniforms place an unnecessary cost on low-income families. the reason is the first sentence, no background First, uniforms place an unnecessary cost on families.
Example A winter uniform set costs about 900 dollars, while plain clothes cost about 300. one concrete number or situation A winter uniform set costs about 900 dollars.
Counter-argument Some people argue that uniforms reduce bullying, but the evidence is mixed. strongest objection first, then a limit Some people argue that uniforms reduce bullying.
Conclusion In conclusion, the cost outweighs the benefit, so schools should relax the rule. returns to the stance, no new reason In conclusion, the cost outweighs the benefit.
Sanity check (teach this): Four checks: (1) four paragraphs means the counter-argument was folded in, which costs organisation marks; (2) a counter-argument without However or an answer argues the other side for free; (3) two or more names or numbers in a body paragraph means too many examples and too little explanation; (4) fewer than 3 checking minutes usually means a missing paragraph and a missing counter-argument, so writing must stop earlier.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Five-part outline write one topic sentence per paragraph for a topic all five present 50, 130, 130, 60, 50
Counter formula write a 60-word counter-argument a concession and an answer Some people argue that …, but …
Slim an example turn a two-example paragraph into one example and three explanations one example only This means that …
Timed run write 420 words in 39 minutes five paragraphs and the word count met about 10.8 words a minute
Self-mark mark content 8, language 8, organisation 4 name the weakest paragraph the counter-argument loses most

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Four paragraphs the counter-argument folded into a body paragraph as one concession Five paragraphs are the base mark. The counter-argument needs its own 60 words; folded in, the objection is never handled.
No answer in the counter-argument the whole paragraph agrees with the other side Give the objection its strongest form, then name one limit so the stance survives.
Two examples in a body paragraph two facts and no reasoning Keep one example and spend the other three sentences explaining the link.
No checking time writing to the last second with a paragraph missing The three checking minutes are scoring minutes: count paragraphs and confirm However appears.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Five lengths 50, 130, 130, 60, 50 and 420 cannot give 60, redo act one
Counter formula concede, then answer no answer sentence, redo act two
Timing 8, 39 and 3 minutes cannot give 39, redo act four

09 Tutor FAQ

Can the essay be three paragraphs

Not advisable. Three paragraphs usually means an opening, one body and a close, so content is capped and the objection is never handled.

How strong should the counter-argument be

Strong enough to be the best objection, then limited in one sentence. Making it stronger than your own case defeats the essay.

What if the word count falls short

Add explanation, not examples. Two explanatory sentences per paragraph usually restore fifty words and lift the content mark too.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →