S4 Chemistry | Separation and Purification Prep Guide (for tutors) | Four properties, four methods, one yield calculation
- 2026-11-17
Students memorise six method names and still freeze when a question gives salt water with sand. This lesson holds one thread: ask first which property differs, solubility, boiling point, particle size or adsorption to the stationary phase. The property picks the method, and the method picks the apparatus.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Solubility | Which of salt and sand dissolves in water | Salt dissolves, sand does not |
| Boiling points | Boiling points of ethanol and water | 78 and 100 degrees Celsius |
| Particle size | What filter paper holds back | Insoluble solid particles, not dissolved ions |
| Percentage work | 3.60 g as a percentage of 5.00 g | 72.0% |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-8 min | Entry questions | How would you separate salty water from sand, ethanol from water, dyes in ink and invisible impurities in tap water | Oral answers; the tutor writes four columns: solubility, boiling point, adsorption, particle size |
| 8-22 min | Act 1: the property picks the method | Filter first to take the sand, then evaporate the filtrate to crystallise the salt; oil and water go through a separating funnel; dust from air comes out on a filter membrane | Students write one method and one reason for each of three mixtures |
| 22-36 min | Act 2: distillation and fractional distillation are not the same | A gap of 22 degrees allows simple distillation; a fractionating column repeats vaporise and condense cycles for close boiling mixtures such as crude oil; the thermometer bulb sits at the side arm | Students draw the apparatus and label the condenser water direction |
| 36-48 min | Act 3: Rf is a ratio | A spot travels 4.8 cm while the solvent front travels 8.0 cm, so Rf is 4.8 over 8.0 which is 0.60; under the same conditions Rf is a characteristic value for identification | Students compute Rf and explain why the front must be marked |
| 48-56 min | Yield and purity | 5.00 g of crude salt giving 3.60 g of crystals is a 72.0% yield; 2.10 g of pure substance in a 2.50 g sample is 84.0% purity; the two percentages use different denominators | Students compute both and write one sentence each |
| 56-60 min | Exit check | Collect three questions and mark at once, labelling errors as method choice, apparatus or calculation | Independent work |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Act 1: ask about the property before the method
Student: Filter it.
Tutor: Why filtration and not distillation?
Student: Because sand does not dissolve.
Tutor: That is the whole answer. Salt dissolves and sand does not, so solubility decides. Filtration removes the sand and the filtrate is evaporated to crystallise the salt.
Student: What if both parts are liquids?
Tutor: Then look at boiling points and distil, because filter paper cannot hold back a liquid.
Students write a two-step plan for salt water with sand, each step with a reason.
Scene 2: Act 2: distillation versus fractional distillation
Student: The ethanol.
Tutor: The vapour is condensed and collected, which is simple distillation. The thermometer bulb sits at the side arm so it reads the vapour temperature, not the boiling liquid.
Student: And fractional distillation?
Tutor: The column forces the vapour to condense and revaporise many times, which is many simple distillations in a row, so even close boiling fractions of crude oil separate.
Students draw the apparatus and label thermometer position and water in at the bottom, out at the top.
Scene 3: Act 3: Rf is a ratio, not a distance
Student: 0.60.
Tutor: Right, and it can never exceed 1 because the spot cannot outrun the front. If you get 1.67 you divided upside down.
Student: Why does the same dye give a different Rf on another day?
Tutor: Because Rf depends on solvent, stationary phase and temperature, so identify a spot only against a standard run with the same solvent, same paper and same conditions.
Students compute one Rf and state the conditions that must match for identification.
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insoluble solid and liquid | Salt water with sand | Filter, wash and dry the residue, then evaporate the filtrate | Sand plus salt |
| Miscible liquids, large boiling gap | Ethanol and water | Simple distillation with the bulb at the side arm and water in at the bottom | Ethanol distillate, water left behind |
| Miscible liquids, close boiling points | Crude oil | Fractional distillation with repeated vaporise and condense cycles | Separate fractions |
| Trace component identification | Ink dyes | Spot, develop, mark the front, compute Rf, compare with a standard | Rf 0.60 |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Crude salt of 5.00 g is purified to 3.60 g of pure salt. Find the yield | 72.0% | Whether students use 3.60 over 5.00 rather than upside down |
| A 2.50 g sample holds 2.10 g of pure substance. Find the purity | 84.0% | Whether the difference between yield and purity is clear |
| A spot travels 4.8 cm with the front at 8.0 cm. Find Rf and state whether it can exceed 1 | 0.60, and it cannot exceed 1 | Whether students explain that the spot cannot pass the front |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Naming a method without a property | Choosing distillation for sand and salt water because it was the last topic taught | State which property differs first, then the method follows; a method without a property is a guess. |
| Thermometer in the wrong place | Bulb dipped into the boiling liquid | The bulb belongs at the side arm to read the vapour temperature, otherwise the collected fraction is judged by the wrong number. |
| Condenser water flowing the wrong way | Water in at the top and out at the bottom | Water enters low and leaves high so the jacket stays full; reversed flow traps air and cooling collapses. |
| Mixing up yield and purity | Answering 72.0% purity for 3.60 g obtained from 5.00 g | Yield is mass obtained over mass expected; purity is mass of pure substance over mass of sample. Different denominators. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Secondary chemistry chapter index — Revise the ion tests and lab safety chapters before this worksheet
- Ion tests: flame and precipitation — Questions 2 to 4 on confirming which ion survived the separation
- Lab safety and waste disposal — Extension: how organic solvent waste must be handled before disposal
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| First step for sand mixed with salt water | Filter, because sand is insoluble | Filter plus the solubility reason means pass |
| Ethanol at 78 and water at 100: which distillation | Simple distillation, since the 22 degree gap is wide enough | Simple distillation plus the boiling gap means pass |
| Spot at 4.8 cm with the front at 8.0 cm gives which Rf | 0.60 | 0.60 means pass; 1.67 means the ratio was inverted |
09 Tutor FAQ
Students cannot recall six methods, so what memory hook helps?
Do not memorise methods, memorise four questions: does it dissolve, how far apart are the boiling points, how different are the particle sizes, how differently do they adsorb. Each question filters the method list automatically.
Why not collect everything that distils over?
Because as the temperature climbs the next component starts to come across. Collect only the fraction that distils at a steady temperature if purity matters.
Does a low yield always mean a mistake?
No. Transfer losses, washing and incomplete crystallisation all lower the yield. Separate operational losses from a wrong theoretical value before blaming the method.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



