Senior English | Proofreading and Editing guide for tutors | four error types, three passes, 40 seconds a line
- 2026-11-21
Students edit by ear, so a line with two errors keeps one of them. This lesson splits 12 errors across 12 lines into four types of three, and sweeps them in eight minutes at 40 seconds a line.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Tense consistency | Which tense does a past event need | Past tense, unless it is a general truth |
| Agreement | Does the list of items take is or are | is, because the subject is list |
| Word form | What is the adjective of success | successful |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-8 min | Diagnose | Hand out a passage with 12 errors and give three minutes | Circle only, no correction, count the circles |
| 8-20 min | Pass one: tense and agreement | Show how to find the subject from the verb and label tense | Write T or A beside each of the 12 lines |
| 20-34 min | Pass two: prepositions and word form | Teach depend on and interested in, and the position rule | Write P or W on the right of each line |
| 34-46 min | Pass three: timed sweep | Time eight minutes and let students work alone | Finish all 12 lines and label each type |
| 46-52 min | Independent practice | Hand out three new passages and patrol without correcting | Circle each error and write the correction |
| 52-60 min | Exit check | Read three items and record the weakest type | Answer orally and note the weakest type |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Act one: why reading for flow is not enough
Students read the passage once and stop where it sounds wrong. The trouble is a line with two errors: fix one and the sentence sounds fine, so the second survives. Twelve errors in 200 words is one every 16.7 words, denser than students ever meet in reading, so the ear alone will miss three or four.
So give a frame instead of a feeling: four types, tense, agreement, preposition and word form, three of each, twelve in total. Students are not hunting for errors, they are naming a type on every line. Missing answers drop from three or four to one or two.
Be explicit about the marks: 12 marks out of a 60 mark paper is 20 per cent. Proofreading has the highest hit rate in the paper because the errors are guaranteed to be there, unlike composition. Eight minutes for 12 marks is 1.5 marks a minute, the best value in the exam.
Four types of three, twelve errors; one error every 16.7 words
Scene 2: Act two: tense and agreement come from the subject
The commonest tense error is a passage that starts in the past and drifts into the present. Method: circle every verb, write its tense in the margin, then check the whole passage in one line. If the passage states a general truth, such as water boils at 100 degrees, the present is correct, so teach the narrative case and the general case apart.
Agreement must be found from the subject, not from the nearest noun. In the list of items is long the subject is list; in the students who won the prize were praised the subject is students. Students cannot hear the difference, so they must mark the subject on each line before deciding whether the verb takes s.
This pass takes twelve minutes: eight teaching, four practice. In practice students do only two things, circle the subject and label the tense, and they do not correct yet. Marking before correcting cuts errors sharply, because most wrong corrections come from writing before looking.
Circle the subject, label the tense, then correct
Scene 3: Act three: prepositions and word form are tables and positions
Prepositions are memorised: depend on, interested in, good at, married to, consist of. Give a table of twelve common pairs and have students check the table rather than guess. This type is usually three items, so the table is direct marks.
Word form is position: adjectives before nouns, adverbs modifying verbs, nouns as subject or object. He speaks English fluent needs fluently; a success attempt needs successful. The rule is simple, but students must say which part of speech the slot needs rather than saying it sounds wrong.
Close with the timed sweep: 3 minutes labelling, 4 minutes correcting, 1 minute checking, eight in total. At 40 seconds a line and 25 words a minute, students should compute the speed once themselves before they believe eight minutes covers 12 lines.
3 plus 4 plus 1 is 8 minutes; 40 seconds a line, 25 words a minute
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tense | Last summer, we go to Cheung Chau and stay for a week. | Circle the verbs and check the tense across the passage | go becomes went, stay becomes stayed |
| Agreement | The list of items are on the desk. | Decide from the subject list | are becomes is |
| Preposition | It depends of the weather. | Check the pair depend on | of becomes on |
| Word form | She speaks English very fluent. | An adverb modifies the verb | fluent becomes fluently |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| He is good in Maths. Which type, and what is the correction? | Preposition, in becomes at, good at | Check whether the table was used rather than a guess |
| The number of students have increased. Which type? | Agreement, have becomes has, the subject is number | Check whether the subject was written down |
| This is a very importance point. Which type, and what is the correction? | Word form, importance becomes important | Check whether the student named the part of speech needed |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Editing by ear | I correct what sounds wrong and leave what sounds fine | The ear catches about half. Name the four types on every line and make the count reach twelve. |
| One error a line | Fix one and move down | Some lines carry two. Re-read the line and check pattern, tense and pair before moving on. |
| Never re-reading | Correct it and move on | Read the line again after correcting; if it does not run, the correction is wrong, and that is three of the twelve marks. |
| Making the whole passage present tense | Present tense everywhere is safest | A past passage needs the past; only general truths take the present, so uniformity loses everything. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- S4 English: descriptive writing and sensory detail, section 07 practice — Do the three section 07 items, then edit your own paragraph with the four types and count the changes
- S2 English: narrative short story writing, section 07 practice — Do only the tense and agreement items, circling the subject before labelling the tense
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| What are the four error types and how many of each | Tense, agreement, preposition and word form, three of each | Wrong here means reteach the frame in act one |
| Twelve lines in eight minutes: how long a line, how many words a minute | 40 seconds a line, 25 words a minute | Wrong here means reteach the timing in act three |
| How long is each of the three passes | 3 minutes labelling, 4 correcting, 1 checking | Wrong here means reteach the pass order in act three |
09 Tutor FAQ
Which year is this written for
It fits S4 best. S5 and S6 papers have more lines, but the four types and the three passes stay the same, with fewer seconds a line.
Is eight minutes enough for 12 lines
The arithmetic says 40 seconds a line. What eats the time is hesitation, so label the type before correcting.
Are there practice questions
Yes. The homework rows link to section 07 practice on those chapters, with answers on the page; check that each type appears three times.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



