/en-tutor-prep-s4-physics-stationary-waves-resonance/
/en-tutor-prep-s4-physics-stationary-waves-resonance/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Senior Physics | Stationary Waves and Resonance Teaching Guide | Superposition before nodes

Senior Physics | Stationary Waves and Resonance Teaching Guide | Superposition before nodes

  • 2026-11-22

Students can draw nodes and antinodes, then half of them double the frequency when the tension doubles. Frequency follows the square root of tension, not the tension itself.

Objectives — By the end the student can: (1) explain a stationary wave as the superposition of an incident and a reflected wave, and state that adjacent nodes are half a wavelength apart; (2) calculate that a string of wave speed 240 metres per second and length 0.8 metres sounds 150 hertz, 300 hertz and 450 hertz as the first three modes; (3) explain that four times the tension doubles the speed and the frequency to 300 hertz, and that doubling the tension gives only 1.41 times; (4) calculate the closed pipe resonances at 340 and 1020 hertz against 680 hertz for an open pipe of the same length, and use a 4 hertz beat to decide which way to tune.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Wave equation What speed gives 150 hertz with a 1.6 metre wavelength? 240 metres per second
Wave on a string What speed for 230.4 newtons on 4 times ten to the minus three per metre? 240 metres per second
Superposition What happens when two equal waves meet in opposite directions? They superpose into a fixed stationary pattern

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 min Prerequisite check Wave equation, string speed, superposition Two of three correct before starting
6-16 min Where a stationary wave comes from Incident plus reflected, nodes cancel Student gives the node spacing
16-28 min Fundamental and harmonics on a string Whole numbers of half wavelengths between fixed ends Student reaches 150 and 300 hertz
28-38 min Tension and the square root Four times tension, twice speed, twice frequency Student explains why it is not four times
38-48 min Resonance in closed and open pipes Closed is a quarter wavelength, open is half Student reaches 340 and 680 hertz
48-56 min Beats and tuning Beat frequency equals the difference Student says whether to loosen or tighten
56-60 min Exit check How much does the fundamental rise when tension doubles? 1.41 times, not twice

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: A stationary wave is superposition, not a stopped wave

Whip a rope fixed at one end until one large loop forms: that is the fundamental, with two nodes and one antinode. Ask the class why the nodes never move. The incident and reflected waves arrive exactly out of phase there and cancel every moment.

Then ask for the distance between adjacent nodes. Count on the diagram: one full wavelength contains two nodes, so neighbours are half a wavelength apart. Here the wavelength is 1.6 metres, so nodes sit 0.8 metres apart, and the 0.8 metre string holds exactly one loop.

Only now write the condition: between two fixed ends the length must be a whole number of half wavelengths, so f equals n times v over 2L. One sentence rebuilds the formula, which is why students should never memorise it separately.

Student must say: why does a node stay still, and how far apart are adjacent nodes?

Scene 2: Tension changes the speed, not the mode shape

The speed on a string is the square root of tension over mass per unit length. With 230.4 newtons and 4 times ten to the minus three, the speed is 240 metres per second. A 0.8 metre string then sounds 150, 300 and 450 hertz for the first three modes.

Multiply the tension by four and the speed becomes 480 metres per second, so the fundamental rises to 300 hertz. Put both rows on the board and let the class read off four times tension, two times frequency. Then ask what tension takes 150 hertz to 151 hertz: 1.0134 times, an increase of 1.34 percent. A student who gets that owns the square root.

Close with the physical reason: the ends stay fixed, so any mode must still hold a whole number of half wavelengths. That is why harmonics are integer multiples and 1.5 times is impossible.

Student must say: double the tension, what happens to the fundamental, and why?

Scene 3: Air columns: quarter wavelength closed, half wavelength open

Use a resonance tube: fix the speaker at 340 hertz and raise the water level. The first loud resonance is a quarter wavelength above the water, so L equals lambda over four. At 0.25 metres with sound at 340 metres per second, the fundamental is 340 hertz, the second resonance at three quarter wavelengths is 1020 hertz and the third is 1700 hertz, so only odd multiples appear.

The open pipe has antinodes at both ends, so the lowest mode is half a wavelength and the fundamental is 680 hertz, exactly twice the closed pipe, with all multiples present. That factor of two is a standard comparison question, so make students write the two rows side by side.

Finish with beats: 440 and 444 hertz together pulse 4 times a second, and the beat frequency is the difference. If the beats get faster while tuning, you are moving away, so turn the other way. Two tuning forks prove it in ten seconds.

Student must say: how many times larger is the open pipe fundamental than the closed one?

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
String fundamental L 0.8 metres, v 240 metres per second f equals v over 2L 150 hertz
String harmonics Same string f equals n times v over 2L 300 and 450 hertz
Closed pipe L 0.25 metres, sound at 340 f equals v over 4L 340 hertz
Beats 440 and 444 hertz together Beat frequency equals the difference 4 hertz
Sanity check (teach this): Three sanity checks: wavelength must equal speed over frequency, so a wavelength more than twice the string length means a harmonic was used as the fundamental; a closed pipe fundamental must be half the open pipe of the same length, so a mismatch means the quarter wavelength became a half; changing tension changes speed and frequency but never the number of nodes, so a changed node count means the wrong mode was drawn.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Closed pipe 0.40 metre pipe, sound at 340 metres per second Fundamental about 212.5 hertz
Find the speed 0.65 metre string, fundamental 200 hertz 260 metres per second
Beats Standard fork 256 hertz, beat frequency 3 hertz The other fork is 253 or 259 hertz, and a second test decides which

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Assuming frequency is proportional to tension Answering that double the tension doubles the frequency Frequency follows the square root. Double tension gives 1.41 times, four times gives double, so write the calculation on the board.
Using half a wavelength in a closed pipe Answering f equals v over 2L for a stopped pipe A closed end is a node and the open end an antinode, a quarter wavelength apart, so the fundamental is v over 4L.
Treating node spacing as a wavelength Answering that nodes are 1.6 metres apart Adjacent nodes are half a wavelength apart, 0.8 metres here; one wavelength contains two nodes, so count them on the sketch.
Tuning the wrong way when beats quicken Answering that faster beats mean keep turning the same way Faster beats mean a bigger difference, so reverse. Turn a little at a time and stop when the beats slow.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Stationary wave Incident plus reflected, nodes cancel Saying the wave stopped means redoing the rope demo
Tension Frequency goes as the square root of tension Saying proportional means redoing the 1.34 percent question
Pipe modes Closed is a quarter wavelength, open is half Reversing them means redrawing both waveforms

09 Tutor FAQ

Why does a stationary wave carry no net energy

The two travelling waves carry equal energy in opposite directions, so the averages cancel. Energy oscillates locally between kinetic and elastic forms instead of travelling along the string.

Why only odd harmonics in a closed pipe

The closed end must be a node and the open end an antinode, which sit an odd number of quarter wavelengths apart. Only one, three, five times fit, so even multiples cannot satisfy both ends.

Why does the beat frequency equal the difference

Two nearby frequencies drift in and out of phase. When in phase the sound is loud, when opposite it is quiet, and the number of loud-soft cycles per second is exactly the difference.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →