S5 Economics Profit maximisation: ten errors to fix
- 2026-11-16
S5 Economics Profit maximisation: ten errors to fix
This paper takes the ten most common confusions one by one: price versus marginal revenue, treating total cost as marginal cost, revenue versus profit maximisation, fixed cost, tax handling, the shutdown condition and the denominator of a markup.
Why price is not marginal revenue Only a perfectly competitive firm is a price taker, so there price equals marginal revenue. A monopolist must cut the price on every unit to sell one more, so marginal revenue sits below price and price has to be read from the demand curve.
01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Questions | 10 |
| Suggested time | 25 |
| Difficulty mix | Error redo 10 |
| Chapter | Chapter: Profit maximisation and MR equals MC |
| Level | Level: 10 error-correction items |
02 Questions (10 items)
- Error redoA student uses price equal to marginal cost to solve a monopoly question: demand P equal to 60 minus 2Q, MC of 20 and TC equal to 20Q plus 50. He gets Q of 20 and P of 20. What went wrong?
- Error redoA student treats the monopolist marginal revenue as the price and so gets a price of 20 from MC of 20. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student takes the total cost function 100 plus 2Q squared as marginal cost itself. What is the correct marginal cost?
- Error redoA student confuses revenue maximisation with profit maximisation: TR equals 100Q minus 4Q squared and MC is 2Q plus 20. What outputs maximise revenue and profit?
- Error redoA student thinks raising fixed cost from 100 to 200 dollars changes the profit-maximising output. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student simply subtracts a 20 dollar per-unit tax from the price and concludes output is unchanged. What is the right method?
- Error redoA student says a firm must shut down as soon as it makes a loss. What is the correct short-run shutdown condition?
- Error redoA student claims marginal revenue equals price when elasticity is 1. With a price of 50 dollars and elasticity of 2, what is the correct marginal revenue?
- Error redoA student computes the markup as 32 divided by 36 giving 88.89 percent, with a price of 68 and marginal cost of 36. What is the correct markup?
- Error redoA student assumes a price ceiling always makes a monopolist cut output. With a ceiling of 36 dollars against an original price of 68, what happens to output and profit?
03 Answers and one-line notes
| # | Answer | One-line note |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | He applied the competitive condition; the correct answer is Q of 10 and P of 40 with profit of 150 dollars. | A monopolist needs MR equal to MC: with MR of 60 minus 4Q the answer is Q of 10, while his figures give a loss of 50 dollars. |
| 2 | Because a monopolist marginal revenue lies below the price, and the price must be read off the demand curve. | Only a competitive firm has price equal to marginal revenue; a monopolist must add the step of reading price from demand after equating MR with MC. |
| 3 | The correct marginal cost is 4Q. | Marginal cost is the derivative of total cost, so the constant 100 disappears and 2Q squared differentiates to 4Q. |
| 4 | Revenue peaks at 12.5 units with TR of 625 dollars, while profit peaks at 8 units where TR is only 544 dollars. | Revenue maximisation sets MR to zero and gives 12.5 units, while profit maximisation sets MR equal to MC and gives 8 units. |
| 5 | Fixed cost does not enter marginal cost, so output and price stay put and only profit falls from 220 to 120 dollars. | The decision depends only on the marginals, and fixed cost never enters marginal cost, so it only changes the size of profit. |
| 6 | Add the tax to marginal cost: MC moves from 2Q plus 20 to 2Q plus 40, output falls to 6 units and the price rises to 76 dollars. | A tax shifts the cost curve rather than the shelf price, so solve for the new output first and then read the buyer price off demand. |
| 7 | Compare price with average variable cost and shut down only when price falls below its minimum. | While price still covers average variable cost, producing recovers part of the fixed cost, whereas shutting down loses all of it. |
| 8 | Marginal revenue is zero at elasticity of 1; at a price of 50 with elasticity 2 it is 25 dollars. | Marginal revenue is price times one minus the reciprocal of elasticity, so elasticity 2 gives 50 times 0.5 which is 25 dollars. |
| 9 | The correct markup is 47.06 percent, since the denominator must be the price rather than marginal cost. | Markup is price minus marginal cost over price, so 32 divided by 68 is 47.06 percent. |
| 10 | Output rises from 8 to 12 units, the price falls to 36 dollars and profit falls from 220 to 142 dollars. | The ceiling makes marginal revenue flat at 36 dollars, still above marginal cost, so output expands to 12 units, and TR of 432 against TC of 290 leaves 142 dollars. |
04 What to do after marking
- After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
- Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
- Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.
Before checking, ask whether the firm is a price taker or a price setter; that single step stops the two conditions being swapped.Tutor Registration →
Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.



