/en-tutor-prep-s5-economics-public-goods-commons-practice-3/
/en-tutor-prep-s5-economics-public-goods-commons-practice-3/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

DSE Economics Public goods and common resources: congestion pricing and efficient provision

DSE Economics Public goods and common resources: congestion pricing and efficient provision

  • 2026-11-16

DSE Economics Public goods and common resources: congestion pricing and efficient provision

Ten items combine vertical summation, cost sharing by marginal benefit, congestion pricing of external cost, fixed cost sharing in a club good and the funding gap left by free riding.

Put external cost into the price A congestion charge makes each road user face the marginal external cost they impose, cutting trips from 1600 to the efficient 800.

01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)

Item Detail
Questions 10
Suggested time 25
Difficulty mix Foundation 4 · Intermediate 3 · Challenge 2 · Error redo 1
Chapter Chapter: Public goods and common resources
Level Level: 10 challenge items

02 Questions (10 items)

  1. FoundationTwo users have inverse demands of P equal to 12 minus Q and 8 minus Q, with marginal cost of 8 dollars. What are marginal social benefit, the efficient quantity and each user payment?
  2. FoundationIf the cost were split equally at 4 dollars each, what problem arises?
  3. FoundationA road has inverse demand P equal to 20 minus 0.01Q, a private cost of 4 dollars per trip and external congestion cost of 0.01Q per trip. What are the private equilibrium trips and price?
  4. FoundationWhat is the socially efficient number of trips, and what congestion charge per trip achieves it?
  5. IntermediateAfter the charge, how many trips are removed and what is the percentage fall?
  6. IntermediateA private pool has fixed cost of 60 000 dollars a year and near zero marginal cost. What is the fee per member with 200 members, and with 300?
  7. IntermediateWhy does charging for a good with zero marginal cost create an efficiency loss?
  8. ChallengeA public good has 1000 users each willing to pay 2 dollars and costs 1500 dollars to provide. What are total willingness to pay and net social benefit, and should it be provided?
  9. ChallengeIf only 400 users actually pay, what is collected and how large is the gap?
  10. Error redoSomeone says non-excludability means no fee can be charged, so public goods must be supplied by government. Why is that wrong?

03 Answers and one-line notes

# Answer One-line note
1 Marginal social benefit is 20 minus 2Q, the efficient quantity is 6 units, and the users pay 6 and 2 dollars, summing to 8. Vertical summation gives 20 minus 2Q, setting it to 8 gives Q of 6, and substituting back gives payments of 6 and 2.
2 The second user values the good at 2 dollars, below the 4 dollar share, so that user objects or refuses to pay. Equal sharing ignores differences in marginal valuation, overcharging the low valuer and undercharging the high valuer.
3 The equilibrium is 1600 trips at a price of 4 dollars. Private decisions count only private cost, and 20 minus 0.01Q equal to 4 gives Q of 1600.
4 Eight hundred trips with a charge of 8 dollars. Social cost is 4 plus 0.01Q, and 20 minus 0.01Q equal to 4 plus 0.01Q gives Q of 800 where external cost is 8 dollars.
5 Eight hundred trips are removed, a fall of 50 percent. Subtracting 800 from 1600 leaves 800, and 800 out of 1600 is 0.5.
6 Three hundred dollars with 200 members and 200 dollars with 300 members. Fixed cost is shared among members, and more members lower the share, which is the scale benefit of a club good.
7 An extra user costs nothing, so a positive price shuts out users who could have benefited at no cost. When price exceeds marginal cost some transactions with positive net benefit do not happen, so total surplus falls.
8 Total willingness to pay is 2000 dollars, net benefit 500 dollars, so provision is worthwhile. A thousand users at 2 dollars gives 2000, less 1500 leaves 500, and a positive net benefit means provision raises efficiency.
9 Eight hundred dollars is collected and 700 dollars is missing. Four hundred at 2 dollars gives 800, and 1500 less 800 leaves 700, so free riding leaves funding short.
10 It is wrong; non-excludability only means users cannot be excluded, and government can subsidise or contract private suppliers. Difficulty in charging concerns who pays rather than who produces, and the two questions must be handled separately.

04 What to do after marking

  • After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
  • Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
  • Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.

On an external cost question, write social cost first and intersect it with demand; using private cost alone always gives excessive use.Tutor Registration →

Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →