/en-tutor-prep-s5-economics-public-goods-commons-practice-4/
/en-tutor-prep-s5-economics-public-goods-commons-practice-4/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S5 Economics Public goods and common resources: ten errors to fix

S5 Economics Public goods and common resources: ten errors to fix

  • 2026-11-16

S5 Economics Public goods and common resources: ten errors to fix

This error-correction paper takes ten common misjudgements one by one: free access mistaken for a public good, horizontal instead of vertical summation, missing external cost, free riding read as zero supply, and confusion over who pays and who produces.

Free access is not a public good Only two characteristics define a public good, non-rivalry and non-excludability. Free access, public funding and public production all sit outside the definition.

01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)

Item Detail
Questions 10
Suggested time 25
Difficulty mix Error redo 10
Chapter Chapter: Public goods and common resources
Level Level: 10 error-correction items

02 Questions (10 items)

  1. Error redoA student calls a free public park a public good. In the peak season it is crowded, so why is that wrong?
  2. Error redoA student adds the inverse demands P equal to 10 minus Q and 8 minus Q horizontally for a public good. What is the correct answer?
  3. Error redoA student uses only the private cost of 4 dollars and gets 1600 trips as the efficient level. What is missing?
  4. Error redoA student concludes that free riding means a public good will not be supplied at all. Why is that wrong?
  5. Error redoA student says modern lighthouses charge shipping firms, so they are no longer public goods. Is that right?
  6. Error redoA student blames population size for overuse of common resources. What is the real cause?
  7. Error redoA student says a publicly funded good must be produced by civil servants. Why is that wrong?
  8. Error redoA student proposes a 10 dollar user fee for a public good with zero marginal cost. What goes wrong?
  9. Error redoA student splits payments of 40, 20 and 0 dollars equally at 20 dollars each. Why is that poor practice?
  10. Error redoA student says an uncongested bridge is always a public good. How must this be revised once traffic exceeds capacity?

03 Answers and one-line notes

# Answer One-line note
1 The judgment ignores non-rivalry; crowding means one visit reduces another visit, so the park is a common resource. A public good requires non-rivalry, and once use passes capacity users interfere with each other, changing the nature of the good.
2 Vertical summation gives 18 minus 2Q, which against a cost of 12 gives Q of 3 with payments of 7 and 5 dollars. Everyone shares one quantity of a public good, so demands add vertically, while horizontal addition belongs to private goods.
3 The external congestion cost is missing; adding 0.01Q of social cost gives an efficient 800 trips. Private cost excludes the delay imposed on others, so using it alone yields too many trips.
4 It is wrong; taxation, donations or sponsorship still provide the good, just below the efficient quantity. Free riding causes underprovision rather than zero provision, and the two are different in degree.
5 No; charging does not change non-rivalry, since one more ship using the beam does not reduce its availability to others. Excludability can be changed by institutions while non-rivalry is set by technology, so the core characteristic remains.
6 The real cause is unclear property rights, so users do not bear the full social cost of depletion. Population is only pressure; if users faced the full cost, heavy demand would not produce overfishing.
7 It is wrong; the government can tender or contract the work, so a private firm may produce what the public purse funds. What makes provision public concerns finance and use rather than who carries out production, which is a question of cost and efficiency.
8 It excludes users with positive net benefit; when marginal cost is zero the efficient price is zero. An extra user adds no cost, so a fee cancels beneficial use and lowers total surplus.
9 The third user values the good at zero yet pays 20 dollars and objects; sharing by marginal benefit is consistent with efficiency. Equal sharing ignores differences in valuation, overcharging the low valuer and undercharging the high valuer.
10 It must be revised; queues appear past capacity, non-rivalry disappears and the bridge becomes a common resource. The nature of a good changes with the level of use, so the judgment must state both usage and capacity.

04 What to do after marking

  • After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
  • Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
  • Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.

Before checking, ask two questions: is the good non-rival, and is it non-excludable? Only when both answers are yes does the public good method apply.Tutor Registration →

Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →