S5 Economics Public goods and common resources: ten errors to fix
- 2026-11-16
S5 Economics Public goods and common resources: ten errors to fix
This error-correction paper takes ten common misjudgements one by one: free access mistaken for a public good, horizontal instead of vertical summation, missing external cost, free riding read as zero supply, and confusion over who pays and who produces.
Free access is not a public good Only two characteristics define a public good, non-rivalry and non-excludability. Free access, public funding and public production all sit outside the definition.
01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Questions | 10 |
| Suggested time | 25 |
| Difficulty mix | Error redo 10 |
| Chapter | Chapter: Public goods and common resources |
| Level | Level: 10 error-correction items |
02 Questions (10 items)
- Error redoA student calls a free public park a public good. In the peak season it is crowded, so why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student adds the inverse demands P equal to 10 minus Q and 8 minus Q horizontally for a public good. What is the correct answer?
- Error redoA student uses only the private cost of 4 dollars and gets 1600 trips as the efficient level. What is missing?
- Error redoA student concludes that free riding means a public good will not be supplied at all. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student says modern lighthouses charge shipping firms, so they are no longer public goods. Is that right?
- Error redoA student blames population size for overuse of common resources. What is the real cause?
- Error redoA student says a publicly funded good must be produced by civil servants. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student proposes a 10 dollar user fee for a public good with zero marginal cost. What goes wrong?
- Error redoA student splits payments of 40, 20 and 0 dollars equally at 20 dollars each. Why is that poor practice?
- Error redoA student says an uncongested bridge is always a public good. How must this be revised once traffic exceeds capacity?
03 Answers and one-line notes
| # | Answer | One-line note |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The judgment ignores non-rivalry; crowding means one visit reduces another visit, so the park is a common resource. | A public good requires non-rivalry, and once use passes capacity users interfere with each other, changing the nature of the good. |
| 2 | Vertical summation gives 18 minus 2Q, which against a cost of 12 gives Q of 3 with payments of 7 and 5 dollars. | Everyone shares one quantity of a public good, so demands add vertically, while horizontal addition belongs to private goods. |
| 3 | The external congestion cost is missing; adding 0.01Q of social cost gives an efficient 800 trips. | Private cost excludes the delay imposed on others, so using it alone yields too many trips. |
| 4 | It is wrong; taxation, donations or sponsorship still provide the good, just below the efficient quantity. | Free riding causes underprovision rather than zero provision, and the two are different in degree. |
| 5 | No; charging does not change non-rivalry, since one more ship using the beam does not reduce its availability to others. | Excludability can be changed by institutions while non-rivalry is set by technology, so the core characteristic remains. |
| 6 | The real cause is unclear property rights, so users do not bear the full social cost of depletion. | Population is only pressure; if users faced the full cost, heavy demand would not produce overfishing. |
| 7 | It is wrong; the government can tender or contract the work, so a private firm may produce what the public purse funds. | What makes provision public concerns finance and use rather than who carries out production, which is a question of cost and efficiency. |
| 8 | It excludes users with positive net benefit; when marginal cost is zero the efficient price is zero. | An extra user adds no cost, so a fee cancels beneficial use and lowers total surplus. |
| 9 | The third user values the good at zero yet pays 20 dollars and objects; sharing by marginal benefit is consistent with efficiency. | Equal sharing ignores differences in valuation, overcharging the low valuer and undercharging the high valuer. |
| 10 | It must be revised; queues appear past capacity, non-rivalry disappears and the bridge becomes a common resource. | The nature of a good changes with the level of use, so the judgment must state both usage and capacity. |
04 What to do after marking
- After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
- Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
- Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.
Before checking, ask two questions: is the good non-rival, and is it non-excludable? Only when both answers are yes does the public good method apply.Tutor Registration →
Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.



