/en-tutor-prep-s5-maths-conditional-probability-independence/
/en-tutor-prep-s5-maths-conditional-probability-independence/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Secondary Maths (DSE) | Conditional Probability and Independent Events: Tutor Prep Guide | Fix the denominator first

Secondary Maths (DSE) | Conditional Probability and Independent Events: Tutor Prep Guide | Fix the denominator first

  • 2026-11-22

Students multiply the first two fractions they see but cannot say which group the denominator comes from, so answers above 1 get copied down.

Objectives — By the end the student can: read 48 over 60 and 24 over 40 from the 100 student table and say why the denominator is 60 in one case and 40 in the other; compare 0.6 times 0.72, which is 0.432, with the overlap 0.48 and conclude the events are not independent; draw the tree for 5 red and 3 blue without replacement and show the second draw is still red with probability 0.625; use 1/2 times 1/6 equals 1/12 to show that an odd first die and a total of 7 are independent.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Reading percentages What percentage of 100 students is 60 students? 60 percent
Fractions to decimals What is 48 divided by 60? 0.8
Multiplying independent events A fair coin is tossed twice. What is the chance of two heads? 0.25

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-5 min Prior check Percentages, fractions to decimals, multiplying independent events Two of three correct before moving on
5-13 min Read the table Split the 100 students into tutored and untutored rows, pass and fail columns Student fills 48, 12, 24 and 16
13-23 min The right denominator Among those tutored the denominator is 60, not 100 Student gets 48 over 60, which is 0.8
23-33 min Compare with the whole group Untutored pass rate is 24 over 40, which is 0.6; overall it is 0.72 Student says 0.8 is above 0.72
33-43 min Definition of independence 0.6 times 0.72 is 0.432 against an overlap of 0.48 Student says not independent and quotes 0.048
43-53 min Multiply along the tree 5 red and 3 blue without replacement, so the second layer has a denominator of 7 Student gets 0.357 for two red and 0.107 for two blue
53-60 min Exit check Ask about the two dice Both sides give 1/12, so the events are independent

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Conditional probability only changes the denominator

Start with a table: of 60 tutored students, 48 pass and 12 fail; of 40 untutored students, 24 pass and 16 fail. The four cells add to 100, and that is the one check that must always be done.

Then ask: if we already know this student is tutored, how many people are we still talking about? The answer is 60. So the chance of passing among tutored students is 48 over 60, which is 0.8, not 48 over 100. Once the student says the sentence “the denominator is 60” out loud, the algebra almost writes itself.

Student must say: why does the denominator fall from 100 to 60?

Scene 2: Independence is a comparison, not a picture

Let A be tutored and B be passed. P(A) is 0.6 and P(B) is 0.72, so their product is 0.432. The overlap, both A and B, is 48 over 100, which is 0.48. The two numbers differ by 0.048, so the events are not independent.

Now two dice: the first die is odd with probability 1/2, and the total is 7 with probability 6 over 36, which is 1/6. The overlap is 1 with 6, 3 with 4 and 5 with 2, three outcomes out of 36, so 1/12. Since 1/2 times 1/6 is also 1/12, these two events are independent. Same rule, opposite conclusion, and the whole argument is a comparison of two numbers.

Student must say: independence is decided by comparing two numbers.

Scene 3: Multiply along the branches, and watch the denominator

A bag holds 5 red and 3 blue, so 8 in total. The first ball is red with probability 5/8. Without replacement only 7 balls remain and 4 of them are red, so the second ball is red with probability 4/7. Two reds is 5/8 times 4/7, which is 20/56, about 0.357.

The four branches must add to 1: two reds 0.357, two blues 0.107, and one of each in two orders at 0.268 each. Then ask the question students skip: what is the probability that the second ball is red? Add the two routes, 5/8 times 4/7 plus 3/8 times 5/7, and the answer is still 0.625, the same as the first ball. The symmetry is obvious once said, but the student has to add it himself.

Student must say: why is the denominator 7 on the second layer?

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Reading a two way table 60 tutored, 48 of them pass Denominator is the 60 tutored 0.8
Testing independence 0.6 times 0.72 against an overlap of 0.48 Compare the product with the overlap 0.432 is not 0.48, so not independent
Tree diagram 5 red and 3 blue, two draws without replacement Multiply along each route and add like outcomes 0.357 for two reds, 0.107 for two blues
Two dice Odd first die and a total of 7 Compare 1/2 times 1/6 with 3/36 Both are 1/12, so independent
Sanity check (teach this): Three sanity checks: a conditional probability must lie between 0 and 1, so an answer of 1.2 means the wrong denominator; the branches of a tree must add to 1, and 0.357 plus 0.536 plus 0.107 does; and both sides of an independence test must use the same units, since mixing percentages with decimals gives a false conclusion.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Conditional probability Of the 40 untutored students, 24 pass. Find the pass rate 0.6
Independence P(A) is 0.6, P(B) is 0.72 and the overlap is 0.48. Are they independent? No, because 0.432 is not 0.48
Tree diagram 5 red and 3 blue without replacement. Find the chance the second is red 0.625, the same as the first draw

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Using the whole group as the denominator 48 over 100 gives 0.48, written as a conditional probability 0.48 is the chance of both events. The question says among tutored students, so the denominator is 60 and the answer is 0.8.
Treating 0.432 and 0.48 as the same Writing independent because the numbers look close They differ by 0.048, and that difference is the dependence. Write the inequality, never an approximate equals sign.
Keeping the same denominator without replacement Writing 5/8 for the second ball being red One ball has gone, so there are 7 left and only 4 are red. The denominator changes, and that is the point of the question.
Forgetting the second route Writing only 0.268 for one red and one blue One red and one blue can happen in two orders, red then blue and blue then red. Both routes must be added, giving 0.536.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Denominator of a conditional probability Among tutored students the denominator is 60 An answer of 100 means the table must be rebuilt
Independence test 0.432 is not 0.48, so not independent If the comparison is unclear, run the rule again
Denominator without replacement The second layer is 7 and there are 4 red If it is written as 5/8, redraw the tree

09 Tutor FAQ

Why can a conditional probability never exceed 1

The denominator counts the people still in play once the condition is known, and the numerator is a part of that same group. A part cannot be bigger than the whole, so an answer above 1 always means the wrong denominator.

Are independent and mutually exclusive the same

No. Mutually exclusive events cannot happen together, so the overlap is zero. Independent events have an overlap equal to the product of the two probabilities, which is usually not zero.

When should replacement be discussed

Before drawing the second layer. With replacement the second layer is still 8 balls and 5 red; without replacement it becomes 7 balls and 4 red. Making the student write one line about how many are left removes most of these errors.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →