/en-tutor-prep-s5-physics-transistor-switch-logic-gates/
/en-tutor-prep-s5-physics-transistor-switch-logic-gates/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Secondary Physics (DSE) | Transistor Switches and Logic Gates: Tutor Prep Guide | Base current before saturation

Secondary Physics (DSE) | Transistor Switches and Logic Gates: Tutor Prep Guide | Base current before saturation

  • 2026-11-22

Students can recite that a small current controls a large one, but ask whether a 100 kilohm base resistor will drive a relay and eight in ten say yes, because saturation was never calculated.

Objectives — By the end the student can: describe what the base, collector and emitter each do and estimate collector current from base current times gain; calculate that 6 V through 100 kilohms gives 53 microamps and at most 10.6 milliamps against the 18.18 milliamps needed to saturate, so the device is not saturated; show that 47 kilohms does saturate and drops dissipation from 26.5 to 3.64 milliwatts; and write truth tables for AND, OR and NOT and verify them with all four input combinations.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Ohm’s law What current flows from 6 V through 100 kilohms? 53 microamps
Series division What current flows from 6 V into 330 ohms? 18.18 milliamps
Binary What is binary 101 in decimal? 5

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 min Prior check Ohm law, series division, binary Two of three correct before moving on
6-16 min The three terminals Base controls, collector to emitter conducts Student says base current sets collector current
16-26 min Base and collector currents 100 kilohms gives 53 microamps, times 200 is 10.6 milliamps Student works out the 47 kilohm case
26-36 min Saturation test Load needs 18.18 milliamps, so 90.9 microamps minimum Student finds the 58.3 kilohm limit
36-44 min Power in a switch Saturated VCE is 0.2 V, 3.64 milliwatts Student compares with 26.5 milliwatts in the linear region
44-54 min Three basic gates AND, OR and NOT circuits with truth tables Student fills all four rows
54-60 min Exit check Ask why the 100 kilohm case does not saturate Base current is too small

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Build the valve model before any arithmetic

Open with a tap: a little water at the handle controls a lot of water in the main pipe. Students accept small-controls-large immediately, but then assume it scales linearly, so add at once that the ceiling comes from the supply and the load, not from the gain of 200.

Name the terminals clearly: emitter to ground, collector to the load and the positive rail, base through a resistor to the control signal. Conduction needs about 0.7 V from base to emitter. Write that number up, because every calculation starts there.

Then the gain: collector current is roughly 200 times base current. Students must hear that 200 is a ceiling coefficient; the actual current is set by the load resistance and the supply, and beyond that the device saturates.

Student must say: if base current grows, does collector current grow without limit?

Scene 2: One set of numbers, two outcomes: saturated or not

First case: 6 V and a 100 kilohm base resistor give base current (6 minus 0.7) over 100,000, which is 53 microamps. Times 200 that is 10.6 milliamps. But a 330 ohm collector resistor only allows 18.18 milliamps, so the transistor delivers 10.6 milliamps, unsaturated, with VCE still at 2.5 V.

Second case: change the base resistor to 47 kilohms. Base current becomes 112.8 microamps, which would support 22.6 milliamps, past the 18.18 milliamp ceiling, so the transistor saturates, VCE falls to about 0.2 V, and it behaves like a closed switch.

Make the student find the threshold: saturation needs 18.18 milliamps divided by 200, which is 90.9 microamps, so the base resistor must be no more than 58.3 kilohms. That is why 100 kilohms fails and designs use 47 or 22 kilohms.

Student must say: why can 100 kilohms not saturate the transistor?

Scene 3: Why saturation is good, and how gates follow

Compute dissipation: unsaturated, VCE is 2.5 V at 10.6 milliamps for 26.5 milliwatts; saturated, VCE is 0.2 V so it falls to 3.64 milliwatts. A switch belongs in saturation; the middle region is for amplification, not switching.

Turn the switch into logic: NOT is one transistor with a pull-up resistor, high input conducts and the output goes low. AND is two switches in series, OR is two in parallel. Students draw the three circuits themselves, then fill the four rows 00, 01, 10 and 11.

Close with a count: three inputs give eight combinations, two give four, and n inputs give two to the power n. That question checks whether students understand where the rows come from rather than memorising a number.

Student must say: how many rows in a two-input AND truth table, and why?

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Find base current V equals 6 V, RB equals 100 kilohms IB equals (V minus 0.7) over RB 53 microamps
Find maximum collector current IB equals 53 microamps, gain 200 IC equals gain times IB 10.6 milliamps
Test saturation RC equals 330 ohms saturation current equals VCC over RC 18.18 milliamps
Find the base resistor limit needs 90.9 microamps RB equals (V minus 0.7) over IB 58.3 kilohms
Sanity check (teach this): Three sanity checks: base currents are microamps, so milliamps means the thousand in kilohms was dropped; collector current cannot exceed VCC over RC, so anything larger means saturation was ignored; and a truth table always has two to the power of the number of inputs rows, so three rows for two inputs means a missing case.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Find IB 5 V through 47 kilohms 91.5 microamps
Decide gain 200, IB 90 microamps, RC 220 ohms, VCC 6 V It saturates, because 18 mA is allowed and the load permits 27.3 mA
Truth table AND gate with inputs 1 and 0 Output 0

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Assuming the gain scales without limit Answering that collector current keeps rising 200 times base current The ceiling is the supply and the load. With 6 V and 330 ohms the most is 18.18 milliamps; more base current changes nothing.
Treating the transistor as voltage driven Answering that any base voltage switches it and current does not matter Collector current is set by base current. Voltage only produces that current, and changing the resistor changes the effect for the same 6 V.
Thinking saturation is damage Answering that saturation means a burnt out transistor Saturation is the normal on state, VCE 0.2 V, lowest dissipation. The risky state is unsaturated with a large current, where 26.5 milliwatts becomes heat.
Miscounting truth table rows Answering that an OR gate with two inputs needs three rows Each input has two states, so the combinations are 2 times 2 equals four: 00, 01, 10, 11. Three inputs give eight.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Three terminals Base controls, collector to emitter conducts Treating them as symmetric means redrawing the circuit
Saturation test gain times IB against VCC over RC Gain alone means reworking the 100 kilohm case
Truth tables Rows equal two to the power of the inputs Three rows means filling in four

09 Tutor FAQ

Why can a transistor act as a switch

A few tens of microamps at the base can make the collector-emitter path almost a short, with 0.2 V across it when on and nearly no current when off. Both states waste little power, which is what a switch needs.

Why is a base resistor necessary

The base-emitter junction is a forward diode, so connecting it straight to a supply lets the current run away. The resistor limits base current and therefore decides whether the transistor saturates.

How do logic gates differ from relays

A relay uses mechanical contacts: slow, audible, and limited by contact wear. Gates switch in nanoseconds with no moving parts, which is why computers are built from gates rather than relays.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →