/en-tutor-prep-s6-economics-comparative-advantage-trade-practice-4/
/en-tutor-prep-s6-economics-comparative-advantage-trade-practice-4/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

DSE Economics Comparative Advantage: ten common misjudgements

DSE Economics Comparative Advantage: ten common misjudgements

  • 2026-11-16

DSE Economics Comparative Advantage: ten common misjudgements

Ten items target the usual errors in comparative advantage: taking absolute for comparative advantage, using output instead of opportunity cost, assuming no imports when a country leads in both goods, treating trade as zero sum, misreading the split of gains, ignoring transport cost, inverting the reciprocal, and reversing the chain from appreciation to output.

Every error goes back to one rule The value of an error-correction paper is in sorting the mistakes: anything about export direction returns to opportunity cost, and anything about whether trade happens returns to net price against domestic cost.

01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)

Item Detail
Questions 10
Suggested time 25
Difficulty mix Error redo 10
Chapter Chapter: Comparative Advantage and International Trade
Level Level: 10 error-correction items

02 Questions (10 items)

  1. Error redoError: with A at 12 X or 8 Y and B at 4 X or 6 Y, a student answers that A exports both goods because it leads absolutely in both. What is the correct answer?
  2. Error redoError: a student uses higher output to decide comparative advantage. What is the correct standard?
  3. Error redoError: a student says a country with absolute advantage in both goods imports nothing. What is correct?
  4. Error redoError: a student claims one country gain must be the other loss. Using 60 hours each, why is this wrong?
  5. Error redoError: a student says any price above the exporter opportunity cost gives the exporter all the gain. What is correct?
  6. Error redoError: a student says a country cannot specialise while domestic demand is unmet. Test this with 100 hours, 10 X or 5 Y per hour, demand of 300 X and 200 Y, and a price of one for one.
  7. Error redoError: a student says exports should continue even when the world price is below domestic opportunity cost. What is correct with A at 0.5 Y and a price of 0.4 Y?
  8. Error redoError: a student sees a world price above domestic opportunity cost and concludes trade must occur. What is missing?
  9. Error redoError: a student turns one X costing 2 Y into one Y costing 2 X. What is correct?
  10. Error redoError: a student says appreciation immediately cuts export volume because output falls. What is the correct chain?

03 Answers and one-line notes

# Answer One-line note
1 A exports X and imports Y: its cost of X at 0.667 Y beats 1.5 Y, but its cost of Y at 1.5 X loses to 0.667 X. A can hold absolute advantage in both goods, yet export direction follows comparative advantage alone.
2 Compare opportunity cost per unit and the lower one wins; output levels only settle absolute advantage. Writing opportunity costs in the same unit side by side is the standard method.
3 It still imports the good in which its opportunity cost is higher, since trading is cheaper than making it. Absolute advantage does not make every good worth producing at home; imports turn on relative cost.
4 It is wrong: specialisation adds 120 X and 30 Y to world output, and both countries can consume more through the terms of trade. Trade is voluntary exchange, and with the price between the two opportunity costs both sides gain, so it is not zero sum.
5 The higher the price the larger the exporter share, but gains are shared within the band between the two opportunity costs. The split moves with the terms of trade, and only the two end points give one side everything.
6 It can: 1000 X are made, 200 X buy the 200 Y needed, and 800 X remain above the 300 X demand. After specialising the country imports with exports, and at a suitable ratio both domestic needs are met.
7 A should import X, because 0.4 Y is below its 0.5 Y cost and buying beats making. Buy when the world price is below domestic cost, and sell only when it is above.
8 Transport cost: with a price of 0.7 Y and freight of 0.3 Y the net price is 0.4 Y, below the 0.5 Y opportunity cost, so no trade occurs. The comparison must use the net price after freight and transaction cost.
9 One Y costs 0.5 X, since the two opportunity costs are reciprocals. The reverse direction takes the reciprocal, and copying the number across is the commonest slip.
10 Appreciation lifts the foreign currency price, weakening competitiveness and demand, and output then falls with demand rather than directly. Appreciation works through price first and demand second, as when 80 dollars goes from 10.4 to 12 US dollars.

04 What to do after marking

  • After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
  • Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
  • Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.

Write each of the ten errors as one rule on the first page of your notebook: direction uses opportunity cost, occurrence uses net price, and the split uses the terms of trade.Tutor Registration →

Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →