DSE Economics Externalities: rising external cost and policy comparison
- 2026-11-16
DSE Economics Externalities: rising external cost and policy comparison
Ten items build a full model with rising marginal external cost, solve both equilibria with the tax, revenue and deadweight loss, then compare an emissions cap, a negative consumption externality and the failure of the Coasean result when transaction costs are too high.
Revenue is not efficiency Two sums must be kept apart when judging a policy: the revenue transferred to the government and the deadweight loss removed. Merging them overstates what the policy achieves.
01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Questions | 10 |
| Suggested time | 25 |
| Difficulty mix | Foundation 4 · Intermediate 3 · Challenge 2 · Error redo 1 |
| Chapter | Chapter: Externalities |
| Level | Level: 10 challenge items |
02 Questions (10 items)
- FoundationDemand is P equal to 130 minus 2Q, private marginal cost is 10 plus Q and marginal external cost equals Q. What are the private equilibrium quantity and price?
- FoundationWhat are the efficient quantity and price?
- FoundationWhat are the optimal Pigouvian tax and total tax revenue?
- FoundationAt the private quantity of 40 units, how far does social marginal cost exceed the price, and how much deadweight loss is recovered by cutting the excess output?
- IntermediateThe government collects 900 dollars of tax, so why is the efficiency gain not 900 dollars?
- IntermediateA government caps total emissions at 40 units and firms face marginal abatement cost of 0.5A, where A is abatement. What is the equilibrium permit price?
- IntermediateA good has private marginal benefit of 100 minus Q, an external cost of 20 dollars per unit and constant private marginal cost of 20 dollars. What are the private and efficient quantities, and the excess?
- ChallengeIf the government taxes 20 dollars per unit, what is total revenue and is the excess output fully removed?
- ChallengeFactory pollution costs nearby residents 300 dollars, and bargaining could settle it if transaction cost were lower. With a transaction cost of 500 dollars, does the Coasean conclusion hold?
- Error redoSomeone says deadweight loss is simply the tax revenue collected. Why is that wrong?
03 Answers and one-line notes
| # | Answer | One-line note |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Forty units at a price of 50 dollars. | Setting 130 minus 2Q equal to 10 plus Q gives Q of 40, and substituting back gives 50 dollars. |
| 2 | Thirty units at a price of 70 dollars. | Social cost is 10 plus 2Q, and 130 minus 2Q equal to 10 plus 2Q gives Q of 30 with a price of 70 dollars. |
| 3 | Thirty dollars per unit and 900 dollars of revenue. | The tax equals marginal external cost of 30 dollars at Q of 30, and 30 times 30 gives 900 dollars. |
| 4 | The gap is 40 dollars and the deadweight loss is 200 dollars. | Social cost of 10 plus 40 plus 40 is 90 against a price of 50, a gap of 40 dollars, and 40 over 10 units halved gives 200 dollars. |
| 5 | Tax revenue is a transfer from buyers and sellers to the government, and the efficiency gain is the 200 dollars of deadweight loss removed. | Tax revenue is a transfer rather than a net benefit, so efficiency is measured only by the change in deadweight loss. |
| 6 | Twenty dollars. | At a cap of 40 units the last unit costs 0.5 times 40, or 20 dollars, and the permit price settles near that level. |
| 7 | Private output is 80 units, the efficient quantity is 60 units and the excess is 20 units. | Private choice sets 100 minus Q equal to 20 for 80 units, while efficiency sets 100 minus Q equal to 40 for 60 units. |
| 8 | Revenue is 1200 dollars and the excess is fully removed, with output back at 60 units. | The tax equals the 20 dollar marginal external cost, so 20 times 60 gives 1200 dollars and output lands on the efficient level. |
| 9 | It does not; the transaction cost exceeds the 300 dollars at stake, so bargaining fails and the market stays inefficient. | The Coasean result needs clear property rights and sufficiently low transaction costs, and it fails when either condition is missing. |
| 10 | It is wrong; tax revenue is a transfer from buyers and sellers to the government while deadweight loss is forgone net benefit, 900 against 200 dollars here. | Treating the two as one exaggerates the policy effect, since efficiency is judged only by the change in net benefit. |
04 What to do after marking
- After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
- Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
- Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.
When comparing policies, ask first whether the tool fixes price or quantity; the answer decides which way it errs when information is uncertain.Tutor Registration →
Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.



