DSE Economics Externalities: ten errors to fix
- 2026-11-16
DSE Economics Externalities: ten errors to fix
This error-correction paper takes ten common misjudgements one by one: externalities treated as a production-only issue, missing marginal external cost, revenue read as efficiency, the Coase theorem read as price control, subsidies read as rescue, and the output direction of positive and negative externalities confused.
Ask which line was left out Nine out of ten externality errors come from a missing line, either external cost or external benefit. Restore that line and the answer follows.
01 Paper details (check answers afterwards)
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Questions | 10 |
| Suggested time | 25 |
| Difficulty mix | Error redo 10 |
| Chapter | Chapter: Externalities |
| Level | Level: 10 error-correction items |
02 Questions (10 items)
- Error redoA student says externalities arise only in production and never in consumption. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student uses only the private marginal cost of 10 plus Q and gets 40 units as the efficient quantity. What is the correct answer?
- Error redoA student counts 900 dollars of tax revenue as the efficiency gain. What is the correct view?
- Error redoA student believes the Coase theorem requires the government to set the correct price first. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student thinks subsidies exist only to rescue loss-making firms. What do subsidies do in the education and vaccine cases?
- Error redoA student concludes that a Pigouvian tax drives output to zero. Why is that wrong?
- Error redoA student says market output exceeds the efficient level under a positive externality. What is the correct direction?
- Error redoA student says producers bear most of a tax when demand is perfectly inelastic. What is the correct sharing?
- Error redoA student proposes that the government set the permit price at zero to spare firms the cost. What problem follows?
- Error redoA student thinks adding external cost to the price solves the externality. Why is that wrong?
03 Answers and one-line notes
| # | Answer | One-line note |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The judgment ignores negative consumption externalities, since second-hand smoke, late-night noise and drink driving all impose costs on third parties. | Externality depends on who bears the spillover, not on whether the activity is production or consumption. |
| 2 | Marginal external cost of Q must be added, so social cost is 10 plus 2Q and the efficient quantity is 30 units. | Dropping the external cost mistakes private cost for social cost and overstates the efficient quantity by 10 units. |
| 3 | The efficiency gain is the 200 dollars of deadweight loss removed, while tax revenue is a transfer from buyers and sellers to the government. | Revenue and deadweight loss are separate sums, and merging them overstates the policy effect. |
| 4 | It is wrong; the theorem needs only clear property rights and low transaction costs, and the parties reach the efficient outcome by bargaining. | The theorem rests on property rights and transaction costs rather than price control, which is a different policy tool. |
| 5 | They correct a positive externality, raising private benefit to social benefit and moving output from 40 to the efficient 60 units. | The role of the subsidy is to internalise external benefit, which has nothing to do with whether a firm is profitable. |
| 6 | It is wrong; the tax equals marginal external cost at the efficient quantity, so output only falls to the efficient level. | The tax internalises the external cost and brings output down to the efficient level rather than shutting the market. |
| 7 | It is the opposite; the producer omits external benefit, so market output of 40 falls short of the efficient 60. | An omitted benefit keeps price too low and output too small, the mirror image of an omitted cost. |
| 8 | Consumers bear the whole tax, because perfectly inelastic demand means they cannot cut their purchases. | The less elastic side bears the larger share, and with perfect inelasticity that share is the whole tax. |
| 9 | Free permits remove any reason to abate, so the cap has no effect and the efficient outcome cannot be reached. | Permits must reflect marginal abatement cost, which at a cap of 40 units is 20 dollars. |
| 10 | Adding to the price only shifts the cost to buyers, and if output does not fall the total external cost remains. | The test is whether output falls to the efficient level, and price is only one means to that end. |
04 What to do after marking
- After marking, redo only the wrong items and write down which step went wrong (formula, unit, or misread number).
- Repeat the same item two days later; move to the next paper only when both attempts are correct.
- Parents only need the answer and note columns; there is no need to explain every item.
Before checking an answer, ask whether social cost or benefit already includes the external part. If not, add it first and then intersect with demand.Tutor Registration →
Questions and answers are written originally by the TutorZone team and are not taken from any school, publisher or examination authority paper. Every value is checked by computer.



