/en-tutor-prep-s6-economics-trade-barriers-welfare/
/en-tutor-prep-s6-economics-trade-barriers-welfare/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S6 Economics: Trade Barriers, Tariffs and Quotas in Welfare Terms (worked example Qd = 200 – 2P) Tutor Prep Guide with a 45-minute plan

S6 Economics: Trade Barriers, Tariffs and Quotas in Welfare Terms (worked example Qd = 200 – 2P) Tutor Prep Guide with a 45-minute plan

  • 2026-11-16

Students can draw the before-and-after tariff diagram yet cannot say where the consumer loss goes, because they have never balanced the books. This lesson uses one set of numbers to split a loss of 1,300 into producer gain, government revenue and deadweight loss, and demands that the three add up.

Objectives — By the end of the lesson students can: (1) compute imports of 60 at a world price of 30 from Qd = 200 – 2P and Qs = 20 + 2P; (2) compute the price of 40, imports of 20 and revenue of 200 after a tariff of 10; (3) compute consumer surplus falling from 4,900 to 3,600 and producer surplus rising from 1,600 to 2,500; (4) reconcile 1,300 as 900 plus 200 plus 200 and name the 200 as deadweight loss from overproduction and underconsumption; (5) explain why a quota of 20 with rent accruing abroad raises the total loss from 200 to 400.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Substitution At P = 30, what are Qd and Qs 140 and 80, so imports are 60
Triangle area Demand choke price 100, price 30, base 140 4,900
Linear equations Price rising from 30 to 40: how far do imports fall From 60 to 20, so 40 units
Surplus What consumer surplus measures The area below demand and above price

02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 min Entry check Substitution, triangle area, the import fall and the definition of surplus Spoken answers, working on paper
6-16 min Act one: free-trade equilibrium At P = 30, Qd is 140 and Qs is 80, so imports are 60; draw the three lines Students compute imports themselves
16-26 min Act two: a tariff of 10 Price 40, Qd 120, Qs 100, imports 20, revenue 200 Students state all four numbers
26-36 min Act three: four surplus blocks and the reconciliation Consumer surplus 4,900 to 3,600, producer surplus 1,600 to 2,500, deadweight loss 200 Students complete 1,300 = 900 + 200 + 200
36-42 min Demonstration then the quota case Same numbers with a quota of 20; rent goes abroad, so deadweight loss doubles Students explain the difference
42-45 min Exit check Three spoken questions: imports, consumer loss, the two deadweight triangles All three correct

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Act one: compute quantities first, draw second

Students rush to draw two lines and then guess positions. The order is quantities first: at a world price of 30, demand is 200 minus 60, which is 140, and supply is 20 plus 60, which is 80, so imports are the 60 between them. With those three numbers the diagram has anchors. Mark four things: the demand intercept of 100, the supply intercept of minus 10, the price line at 30, and the verticals at 80 and 140. The minus 10 matters because the producer surplus triangle has height 30 minus minus 10, which is 40; get it wrong and every surplus figure is wrong. The demand intercept of 100 does the same job on the other side, so finding both intercepts is always step one.

At a world price of 30 local firms supply 80 and consumers buy 140: who supplies the remaining 60?

Scene 2: Act two: a tariff does exactly one thing, lifting the domestic price by 10

A specific tariff of 10 moves the domestic price from 30 to 40 and everything follows: demand falls from 140 to 120, supply rises from 80 to 100, imports shrink from 60 to 20. Revenue is 10 times 20, which is 200, a rectangle paid by consumers and collected by the government. Teach the structure: a tariff creates three blocks, two triangles of deadweight loss from overproduction and underconsumption, and one rectangle of transferred revenue. The classic error is computing revenue as 10 times 60, using the free-trade quantity; make students ask before every multiplication whether the quantity used is the post-tariff one. One more point worth making: local production rises because the price rises, not because local firms became more efficient.

Why does domestic production rise after a tariff? Have local firms become more efficient?

Scene 3: Act three: the reconciliation is the only proof of understanding

Consumer surplus falls from 4,900 to 3,600, a loss of 1,300, which is 26.5 per cent of the original. That 1,300 does not vanish: producer surplus rises from 1,600 to 2,500, a gain of 900, because both price and quantity rise; the government collects 200; and 200 is deadweight loss, two triangles, one where local output replaces cheaper imports and one where consumers are priced out. Nine hundred plus 200 plus 200 is 1,300, and matching that total proves every figure. The loss can be checked a second way: half the tariff times the fall in imports, 0.5 times 10 times 40, is 200. Finally the quota: a quota of 20 produces the same price of 40 but no revenue, because the 200 becomes quota rent. If the rent stays at home the loss stays 200; if it accrues abroad the total loss is 400.

A quota and a tariff look identical on the diagram, so why can the welfare conclusions differ?

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Free-trade imports How many units are imported at a world price of 30 Substitute into demand and supply, then subtract Reporting only the quantity demanded
Post-tariff price and quantity How far do imports fall after a tariff of 10 Add 10 to price, recompute both quantities, subtract Using the pre-tariff import quantity for revenue
Surplus change How much consumer surplus is lost Triangle area at both prices, then subtract Heights must use the intercepts, not the tariff
Deadweight loss and reconciliation What is the deadweight loss, and does it add up Half the tariff times the fall in imports, then sum the three blocks A reconciliation needs all three blocks
Sanity check (teach this): Four checks: (1) imports are 60 before the tariff and 20 after, so revenue uses 20; (2) the surplus heights come from the intercepts 100 and minus 10; (3) 1,300 equals 900 plus 200 plus 200, and the three must add up; (4) the deadweight loss of 200 also comes from 0.5 times 10 times 40.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
World price 30, Qd = 200 – 2P, Qs = 20 + 2P: imports Qd 140, Qs 80, imports 60 Giving only Qd skips the subtraction
A tariff of 10: imports and revenue Imports 20, revenue 200 Revenue from 60 uses the wrong quantity
How much consumer surplus is lost 4,900 minus 3,600, so 1,300 Wrong heights give a different figure
Deadweight loss, and does it reconcile 200, and 900 plus 200 plus 200 is 1,300 No reconciliation means the answer is unfinished

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Using the pre-tariff quantity for revenue Answering that revenue is 10 times 60, so 600 Sixty is the free-trade quantity; after the tariff only 20 crosses the border.
Using the wrong surplus heights Answering that the consumer loss is 0.5 times 10 times 140 Ten is the tariff, not a price change relevant to demand. Compute the triangle at each price from the intercept of 100.
Reporting the loss as the social cost Answering that consumers lose 1,300, so society loses 1,300 The net social loss is 200; the rest is a transfer. Write out 1,300 as 900 plus 200 plus 200.
Copying the tariff conclusion to a quota Answering that a quota also costs 200 Follow the rent: at home it stays 200, abroad the loss becomes 400.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Imports and revenue after the tariff Imports 20, revenue 200 Review act two: revenue uses the post-tariff quantity
How much consumer surplus is lost 1,300 Review act three: find both intercepts first
What are the two deadweight triangles Overproduction and underconsumption Review act three on structure

09 Tutor FAQ

Is a diagram compulsory?

Yes, but only after the quantities are computed. The diagram fixes where the four blocks sit; it is not a tool for guessing numbers.

Is tariff revenue always part of domestic welfare?

Only if the government actually collects and uses it. If it is wasted, the 200 also becomes a loss and the total rises to 400.

Why does quota rent matter so much?

It decides whether the 200 stays at home or leaves the country, which changes the total loss from 200 to 400.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →