Secondary Maths (DSE) | Second Derivative and Curve Sketching: Tutor Prep Guide | Read the sign, not the size
- 2026-11-22
Students can recite that a positive second derivative means a minimum, then fall apart on points of inflexion because nobody made them say the word concavity.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Differentiating | What is the derivative of x cubed? | 3x squared |
| Solving a quadratic | Solve 3x squared minus 12x plus 9 equals zero | x equals 1 or x equals 3 |
| Solving an inequality | For what x is 6x minus 12 greater than zero? | x greater than 2 |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-5 min | Prior check | Differentiate, solve a quadratic, solve a linear inequality | Two of three correct before moving on |
| 5-14 min | Stationary points | Factorise 3x squared minus 12x plus 9 into 3 times x minus 1 times x minus 3 | Student writes x equals 1 and x equals 3 |
| 14-24 min | The second derivative | Differentiate again to get 6x minus 12, then substitute 1 and 3 | Student gets minus 6 and plus 6 |
| 24-34 min | Function values | f of 1 is 5 and f of 3 is 1 | Student writes the maximum at 1 comma 5 and the minimum at 3 comma 1 |
| 34-44 min | Points of inflexion | Second derivative zero at x equals 2, negative to the left and positive to the right | Student gets the point 2 comma 3 |
| 44-54 min | A quartic | Second derivative 12x squared minus 8 is negative at 0 and positive at plus or minus 1.414 | Student finds inflexions at plus and minus 0.816 |
| 54-60 min | Exit check | Ask whether a zero second derivative always means an inflexion | No, the sign has to change |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Stationary points first, classification second
Write f of x as x cubed minus 6x squared plus 9x plus 1. The first derivative is 3x squared minus 12x plus 9, which factorises as 3 times x minus 1 times x minus 3, so the stationary points are at x equals 1 and x equals 3. None of this uses the second derivative, and the points have to be found before anything can be classified.
Now differentiate again: 6x minus 12. Substituting 1 gives minus 6, a negative number, so the curve bends downwards there and the point is a maximum. Substituting 3 gives plus 6, so the curve bends upwards and the point is a minimum. Make the student say the whole sentence: negative is a maximum, positive is a minimum, zero needs a second look. Once that sentence is fluent, the chapter is basically done.
Student must say: what do a negative, positive and zero second derivative each mean?
Scene 2: An inflexion needs a sign change, not just a zero
Setting the second derivative to zero gives 6x minus 12 equals zero, so x equals 2. That is only a candidate. Check both sides: at x equals 1 the second derivative is minus 6 and at x equals 3 it is plus 6, so the sign really does change and x equals 2 is a point of inflexion, with f of 2 equal to 3, giving the point 2 comma 3.
The counterexample must be taught: for g of x equals x to the fourth, the second derivative is 12x squared, which is zero at 0, but it is positive on both sides, so the concavity does not change and 0 comma 0 is a minimum rather than an inflexion. After that contrast, no student will treat a zero second derivative as the definition of an inflexion.
Student must say: why is 0 not a point of inflexion for x to the fourth?
Scene 3: A quartic: four candidates, two turning points and two inflexions
For g of x equals x to the fourth minus 4x squared, the first derivative is 4x cubed minus 8x, which is 4x times x squared minus 2, so the stationary points are at 0 and at plus or minus 1.414. The second derivative is 12x squared minus 8: at 0 it is minus 8, so 0 is a maximum with value 0; at plus or minus 1.414 it is 16, so both are minima with value minus 4.
Setting the second derivative to zero gives x squared equals two thirds, so x is plus or minus 0.816. Check the sign: at 0 the second derivative is minus 8 and at 1 it is plus 4, so both of those points are inflexions and the function value there is about minus 2.222. Finish by making the student read the five numbers as one sentence: maximum 0, minima minus 4, inflexions at plus and minus 0.816.
Student must say: why can a quartic have two minima?
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stationary points | 3x squared minus 12x plus 9 | Factorise as 3 times x minus 1 times x minus 3 | x equals 1 or x equals 3 |
| Classification | Second derivative minus 6 at 1 and plus 6 at 3 | Read the sign only | Maximum 5 and minimum 1 |
| Point of inflexion | 6x minus 12 equals zero | Find the root, then check both sides | x equals 2, giving 2 comma 3 |
| Concavity intervals | 12x squared minus 8 | Solve the sign of the quadratic | Downwards within 0.816 of zero, upwards outside |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Classify | Stationary points at 1 and 3 for the cubic | Maximum at 1, minimum at 3 |
| Inflexion | Second derivative 6x minus 12 | x equals 2, so the point is 2 comma 3 |
| Concavity | Second derivative 12x squared minus 8 at 0 and at 1 | Downwards at 0, upwards at 1 |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Treating a zero second derivative as an inflexion | Solving to x equals 2 and writing the point of inflexion straight away | Zero only makes it a candidate. The sign must change, so write negative on the left and positive on the right. |
| Reversing maximum and minimum | Calling minus 6 at x equals 1 a minimum | Negative means the curve bends downwards like a cap, so it is a maximum. Cap is maximum, cup is minimum. |
| Forgetting the function value | Writing that the maximum is at x equals 1 | A turning point needs two coordinates. f of 1 is 5, so the answer is 1 comma 5, and a bare x value loses marks. |
| Confusing stationary points with endpoints | Treating the ends of the curve as extremes | The derivative need not vanish at an endpoint. Decide first whether the domain is closed, then check the endpoints separately. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Maths subject index — All chapters in this subject
- Related chapter: applications of differentiation — Questions 1 to 4 of the practice set
- Related chapter: integration and area — Questions 4 to 6 of the practice set
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning of the second derivative | Negative maximum, positive minimum, zero needs checking | If unclear, repeat the sentence |
| Inflexion condition | Zero plus a change of sign | A bare zero means repeating the x to the fourth example |
| Writing an extreme point | As a coordinate pair such as 1 comma 5 | A bare x value means one more question |
09 Tutor FAQ
What if the second derivative test fails
When the second derivative is zero the test gives no answer, so go back to the first derivative and check the sign on both sides, or compare nearby function values. Do not force a conclusion from the second derivative.
Why bother finding points of inflexion
They are where the concavity changes, so the sketch bends the other way. Almost every curve sketching question expects them, and leaving them out makes the shape wrong.
Can a cubic have two points of inflexion
No. The second derivative of a cubic is linear, so it has one root at most, which means one inflexion. Finding two means an arithmetic slip or a turning point mistaken for an inflexion.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



