IB Economics | Exchange Rates and the Balance of Payments Lesson-Prep Guide (for tutors) | Depreciation, Marshall-Lerner, Accounts
- 2026-11-16
Students repeat that depreciation helps exports, then cannot say by what percentage the exchange rate moved or how far the export price fell, and they regularly swap the financial and capital accounts. The marks sit in three places: quote direction, percentage pass-through, and the bookkeeping logic of the accounts. Once all three are computed, nothing has to be memorised.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Supply and demand | What happens to quantity demanded when price rises | Distinguish movement along a curve from a shift |
| Price elasticity | What an elasticity above one means | Quantity changes proportionally more than price |
| Percentage change | Moving from 7.8 to 8.1 | Write (new minus old) over old |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-8 min | Entry question | Ask whether a weaker Hong Kong dollar raises or lowers the US dollar price of exports | Write an answer first, compare at the end |
| 8-22 min | The exchange rate is a price | Market supply and demand, quote direction, percentage change | Compute 3.85 percent |
| 22-36 min | Pass-through to prices | Export price in foreign currency falls, import price in domestic currency rises | Compute 96.3 and 810 |
| 36-48 min | Quantity effect and Marshall-Lerner | Elasticities 0.7 plus 0.6 | Decide and justify the trade balance |
| 48-56 min | Structure of the accounts | Current, capital and financial accounts summing to zero | Fill in a table whose total is zero |
| 56-60 min | Exit check | Two questions collected and marked, errors labelled (quote, elasticity or bookkeeping) | Work independently |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: An exchange rate is a price: settle the quote direction first
A quote moving from 7.8 to 8.1 means the same US dollar now costs more Hong Kong dollars, so the Hong Kong dollar has become cheaper. That is depreciation, and the only formula needed is (new minus old) divided by old: 0.3 divided by 7.8 is 3.846 percent. Insist on a percentage answer, not a decimal, because examiners award the figure and the communication mark separately.
Drill the direction until it is automatic: depreciation and appreciation always describe the domestic currency. A weaker Hong Kong dollar is the same event as a stronger US dollar, but the subject must stay fixed through the paragraph or the analysis reads as self-contradictory.
Then separate the regimes in one line each: floating rates are moved by supply and demand, fixed rates are held by central bank purchases and sales of reserves. That single sentence is enough for most policy parts.
Teacher line: “The quote goes up, the domestic currency goes down. Depreciation always describes our own currency, not theirs.”
Scene 2: How depreciation reaches prices, then quantities
An export priced at 780 Hong Kong dollars sells for 100 US dollars at 7.8. At 8.1 the same price equals 96.30 US dollars, a fall of 3.70 percent, so foreign buyers see a cheaper good. Imports run the other way: a 100 US dollar item costs 780 dollars at 7.8 and 810 at 8.1, an increase of 3.85 percent.
The price effect alone does not settle total revenue. Cheaper exports raise quantity but earn less foreign currency per unit, so the outcome depends on elasticity. The Marshall-Lerner condition compares the sum of the absolute export and import demand elasticities with one: here 0.7 plus 0.6 equals 1.3, above one, so the quantity effect outweighs the price effect and the trade balance improves.
If the sum were below one, the balance would worsen at first and improve later, which is the J-curve. One sentence naming the J-curve earns credit in evaluation parts and shows the condition is a threshold rather than a guarantee.
Teacher line: “A lower price does not mean lower revenue. Add the two elasticities: above one means the quantity effect wins and the balance improves.”
Scene 3: The balance of payments: three parts that always sum to zero
The current account has four parts here: goods -120 (imports exceed exports), services +40 (tourism and financial services in surplus), income +15, and transfers -5, giving -70 in total.
The capital account records transfers of assets and purchases of non-produced, non-financial assets, here +5; the financial account records direct investment, portfolio flows and reserve changes, here +65. Negative 70 plus 5 plus 65 equals zero, so the current account gap is financed by inflows, which means the economy is drawing on foreign saving.
Under a fixed rate the central bank plugs the gap by buying or selling reserves, so the reserves line inside the financial account moves; under a floating rate the exchange rate does most of the adjusting and reserve changes stay near zero.
Teacher line: “The accounts always sum to zero because of double entry, not because the economy is strong. Then ask which line is the gap and which line fills it.”
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compute a depreciation or appreciation | (New minus old) over old, times one hundred | State clearly that the subject is the domestic currency | |
| Find post-depreciation prices | Domestic price divided by the new rate, or foreign price times the new rate | Fix the quote direction before substituting | |
| Judge the trade balance | Add the two elasticities in absolute value and compare with one | Above one improves; below one, mention the J-curve | |
| Complete a balance of payments table | Four current account items plus capital and financial accounts summing to zero | Name the gap and the balancing item |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| The Hong Kong dollar moves from 7.8 to 8.1. By what percentage has it depreciated? | about 3.85 percent | 0.3 divided by 7.8 |
| An export priced at 780 Hong Kong dollars is sold when the rate is 8.1. What is its US dollar price? | about 96.30 US dollars | 780 divided by 8.1 |
| Export elasticity 0.7 and import elasticity 0.6: does depreciation improve the trade balance? | Yes, the sum is 1.3, above one | State the Marshall-Lerner condition |
| Current account -70 and capital account +5: what must the financial account be? | +65 | The three parts sum to zero |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Reversing the quote direction | Answering that a higher quote means the domestic currency appreciated | A higher quote means more domestic currency per foreign unit, so the domestic currency fell. Keep the subject fixed: our currency, not theirs. |
| Dividing by the new value | Computing 0.3 over 8.1 and getting 3.7 percent | Percentage change always divides by the old value. Dividing by the new one understates the move and loses the communication mark. |
| Assuming depreciation always helps | Writing that the balance must improve without checking elasticities | The two elasticities must sum above one. Below one the balance worsens first, and that is the J-curve. |
| Swapping the two accounts | Recording direct investment in the capital account | Direct and portfolio investment sit in the financial account. The capital account holds asset transfers and non-produced, non-financial assets. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- IB Economics chapter index — All chapters in the subject
- Lesson-prep master index — Parallel chapters in other subjects
- Redo this chapter — Practice items 1, 3 and 4: depreciation, Marshall-Lerner, balancing item
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Quote direction | A higher quote means a weaker domestic currency | Getting it backwards means repeat scene one |
| Two-step pass-through | Prices first, quantities second, elasticity decides | Price only means repeat scene two |
| Three parts to zero | Current, capital and financial accounts | Dropping the financial account means repeat scene three |
09 Tutor FAQ
Do I need the full Marshall-Lerner derivation?
No. IB expects the comparison of the summed elasticities with one and a numerical judgement of direction.
How much should I write on fixed versus floating rates?
One mechanism sentence each: floating is set by supply and demand, fixed is held by central bank reserve operations. More than that drifts off task.
Must the balance of payments total zero?
Yes, by double entry. A complete answer still names which line is the gap and which line fills it.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



