S1 Science: Rocks, Soil and Weathering — a 45-minute tutor prep guide with 45/5/25/25 soil, 30 per cent pore space and four common errors
- 2026-11-16
← Back to the Secondary Science chapter index
Students can name granite and marble but cannot say why one is harder, nor why Hong Kong hillsides are covered in loose fragments. They also treat weathering and erosion as one process, so the answer becomes the wind blew the rock away. This lesson builds on one 100 cubic centimetre soil sample and one freeze-thaw example, separating weathering from erosion first, then using rates to show how slowly soil forms, which is what makes the conservation argument quantitative.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Percentages | What is 45 plus 5 plus 25 plus 25 | One hundred, so the four components fill the whole volume |
| Volume and mass | Which is heavier, the same volume of rock or water | Rock, because its density is higher, which is why mass cannot measure pore space |
| Changes of state | Does water expand or contract when it freezes | It expands, by about nine per cent |
| Origin of sand | What is sand made from | Fragments of rock carried and deposited |
02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Entry check | Why Hong Kong hillsides are crumbly, whether wind can blow rock away, what soil is made of | Spoken answers written into two columns for weathering and erosion |
| 6-18 min | Act one: three rock families | Igneous from cooling magma, sedimentary from compacted fragments, metamorphic from heat and pressure, one example each | Students link the three names to their formation processes |
| 18-30 min | Act two: physical and chemical weathering | Freeze-thaw expands water by about nine per cent and splits rock; limestone dissolves in acid rain at 0.05 millimetres a year | Students name both mechanisms with an example |
| 30-40 min | Act three: soil composition and formation rate | Mineral 45, organic 5, water 25, air 25 per cent; 1 centimetre per 100 years gives 20 centimetres in 2000 years | Students compute 30 per cent porosity and the 2000 years |
| 40-43 min | Fresh numbers | 500 grams of dry soil contains 25 grams of humus, find the organic percentage | 5 per cent, teacher circulates |
| 43-45 min | Exit check | Three questions collected and marked, errors labelled by classification, mechanism or percentage | Completed independently |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Act one: rock classification follows origin, not colour
Give one formation process and one example for each rock family, and describe the rock cycle.
Scene 2: Act two: weathering breaks rock in place, erosion carries it away
State the nine per cent expansion and the 0.05 millimetres a year, and separate weathering from erosion.
Scene 3: Act three: soil is a mixture of four things and it forms very slowly
State the four percentages and compute 30 per cent porosity and 2000 years for topsoil.
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rock classification | Classify granite, sandstone and marble | Ask for origin first, then name and process | Igneous, sedimentary, metamorphic |
| Weathering type | Rock splitting after a freezing night, which weathering | Ask whether a new substance formed | Physical, specifically freeze-thaw |
| Soil composition | Find the total or the missing component of four percentages | The four add to 100 per cent | 45, 5, 25 and 25 |
| Formation rate | Topsoil forms at 1 centimetre per 100 years, find the time for 20 centimetres | Divide the depth by the rate, then multiply by 100 | 2000 years |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Rock classification | Sort six rocks into three families and give each process | Whether the process is written every time |
| Weathering type | Classify five examples as physical or chemical | Whether a new substance formed |
| Porosity | 150 cubic centimetres of dry soil rises from 150 to 195 grams, find the porosity | Whether water volume is divided by total soil volume |
| Formation rate | Find the time for 30 centimetres of topsoil | Whether the ratio of 1 centimetre per 100 years is used |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Weathering treated as erosion | Answering that wind blew the rock away so it shrank | Weathering breaks rock in place and nothing is removed, and removal is erosion. Confusing the two ruins every later answer about slope failure. |
| Naming without process | Answering that marble is metamorphic and stopping | Classification needs the process. Marble is limestone altered by heat and pressure and still calcium carbonate, which is why it fizzes in acid, and that sentence carries the marks. |
| Wrong porosity denominator | Answering 30 over 30, or 100 per cent | Porosity is pore volume over total soil volume, so the denominator is 100 cubic centimetres, not 30. A hundred per cent would mean the sample is entirely empty space. |
| Soil assumed to form quickly | Answering that fertile topsoil forms in a few decades | Topsoil forms at 1 centimetre per 100 years, so 20 centimetres needs 2000 years, longer than recorded civilisation, which is why several centimetres lost in one storm cannot be replaced. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Secondary Science prep guides — All chapters for the subject
- Tutor prep guide index — Similar chapters in other subjects
- Redo this chapter — Practice questions 1, 3 and 4: classification, porosity and formation rate
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Rock families | Granite cooled magma, sandstone compacted fragments, marble heat and pressure | Names alone mean act one again |
| Weathering and erosion | Weathering breaks in place, erosion carries away | The wind blew it away means act two again |
| Soil figures | The four components total 100, porosity 30, topsoil 2000 years | Percentages not totalising means act three again |
09 Tutor FAQ
Which rocks are common in Hong Kong?
Volcanic and granitic rock, both igneous, with small amounts of sedimentary rock. Deep weathering is linked to the hot wet climate, which makes local examples worth using.
Must students memorise every rock name?
No. They should know the three origins and one example of each, and derive the rest, which is more reliable than a memorised list.
How does rock relate to soil?
The mineral fraction of soil comes from weathering of the rock beneath, so local rock type affects soil acidity and nutrients, a link revisited at S3.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



