/en-tutor-prep-s2-chinese-argumentative-text-reading-claims-evidence/
/en-tutor-prep-s2-chinese-argumentative-text-reading-claims-evidence/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S2 Chinese | Argumentative Reading Comprehension Tutor Prep Guide | Claims, Evidence, Four Reasoning Methods, 14 Marks

S2 Chinese | Argumentative Reading Comprehension Tutor Prep Guide | Claims, Evidence, Four Reasoning Methods, 14 Marks

  • 2026-11-17

Ask a student what an argumentative passage argues and the answer is often that the author thinks this matters, followed by nothing. They cannot separate the central claim from the sub-claims, they do not label evidence, and an answer saying examples were used never says which kind or which sub-claim it supports. This lesson takes a 720-character, five-paragraph sample split 120, 450 and 150, and unpacks one central claim, three sub-claims, five pieces of evidence, four reasoning methods and one rebuttal.

Objectives — Students can: (1) state the central claim in one sentence and say which part of it each of the three sub-claims supports; (2) sort five pieces of evidence into three facts, one statistic and one quotation, and link each to a sub-claim, an average of 1.67 per body paragraph; (3) name example, quotation, contrast and analogy reasoning, and explain why analogy alone cannot replace factual evidence; (4) answer four questions worth 14 marks in the pattern of position, evidence type and the sub-claim supported.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
What counts as a claim Is we should waste less food a claim Yes, but too broad, since a claim needs scope and reason
Evidence types A survey showing 70 per cent of households waste food daily is which type A statistic
Why sub-claims exist Why split one claim into three Each sub-claim can be proved separately
What a rebuttal does A paragraph states the opposing view then answers it, what is it called A rebuttal

02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 min Three opening questions Central versus sub-claim, evidence types, characters per paragraph in 720 over five Oral answers, teacher writes claim and evidence in two columns
6-18 min Act one: one claim, three sub-claims The central claim usually closes the 120-character introduction; sub-claims open the three body paragraphs Students write one central claim and three sub-claims
18-32 min Act two: label five pieces of evidence Three facts, one statistic, one quotation, each linked to a sub-claim, 1.67 per body paragraph Students label and draw links to the sub-claims
32-41 min Act three: four reasoning methods and one rebuttal Example, quotation, contrast, analogy; the rebuttal states the opposing view before answering Students mark the four methods and rewrite the rebuttal sentence
41-43 min Swap in a body paragraph One new body paragraph, ask which two methods appear Oral answers, teacher follows up on evidence type
43-45 min Exit check Three questions collected and marked at once, errors tagged as claim, evidence or reasoning Independent

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Act one: one central claim, three sub-claims, and the relation must be spoken

Give one test first: the central claim must be what the whole passage proves, and it usually closes the 120-character introduction. Then require a because-therefore rewrite; if no reason can be supplied, the sentence is a slogan rather than a claim. Sub-claims are stricter: together they must cover the central claim, with no gap and no overlap. The teaching move is to place the three sub-claims side by side and ask which is weakest and what evidence it lacks. That turns reciting a claim into judging a claim, which is the step S2 students most need.

One central claim, and three sub-claims that together cover it.

Scene 2: Act two: labelling evidence is not enough, it must match a sub-claim

Label five items: three facts, one statistic, one quotation. A frequent error is calling a statistic a fact, when a statistic carries an explicit quantity and source and therefore persuades differently. The second move is linking: each item points at one sub-claim, and 450 characters of body text carry five items, about 1.67 per paragraph. If one paragraph holds two items and another holds none, the argument is unevenly supported, and that observation belongs in an evaluation answer. Warn students about quotations: citing a famous line is not proof, so the answer must still explain how the line bears on the sub-claim.

Every piece of evidence gets a type and a sub-claim.

Scene 3: Act three: analogy only assists, rebuttal concedes then answers

Demonstrate the four methods: example reasoning rests on a specific case, quotation on authority, contrast on the gap between two situations, analogy on a shared structure that clarifies an abstraction. State one limit clearly: analogy makes a reason easier to grasp but cannot replace fact, so an answer naming analogy must add that factual evidence is still required. The rebuttal paragraph, paragraph four in the sample, needs two steps: state the opposing position, then give the answer and the concession boundary. Students usually omit the concession and write simply that the opponent is wrong, which earns half marks because the opponent position is never acknowledged.

Analogy only clarifies, and a rebuttal concedes before it answers.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Find the central claim Which sentence does the whole passage prove Read the close of the introduction and apply the because-therefore test One provable position, not a slogan
Map sub-claims Which part of the claim does each of three sub-claims support Place all three side by side and look for overlap or gaps Three parts covering the claim
Classify evidence A survey shows 70 per cent of households waste food Check for quantity and source A statistic supporting the first sub-claim
Analyse the rebuttal What does paragraph four do first and then State the opposing view, then answer and concede One concession plus one answer, both required
Sanity check (teach this): Four checks: the central claim must fit in one sentence, and two or three sentences usually means sub-claims have been mixed in; the three sub-claims together must cover the claim, and an obvious gap means a paragraph was skipped; the evidence count must match the sample at five items split three facts, one statistic and one quotation, and mislabelling a statistic costs the classification mark; marks must reconcile at 4, 4, 3 and 3 for 14, and a self-marked total above 14 means a point was counted twice.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Write the claim State the position in one sentence Does it survive the because-therefore test
Link sub-claims Match three sub-claims to parts of the claim Any overlap or gap
Label evidence Classify five items and link them Is a statistic called a fact
Rewrite the rebuttal Turn the opponent is wrong into concession plus answer Is the reasonable part acknowledged

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Sub-claim written as the central claim Answer reads we should waste less food That covers one paragraph only. The central claim governs all three, so line up the three opening sentences and find the one they serve, usually the last line of the introduction.
Statistic called a fact A survey showing 70 per cent labelled as a fact Anything with a quantity and a source is a statistic. It persuades more strongly than a single event because it stands for the whole, and the answer should say so.
Analogy treated as proof Answer says the analogy proves the point convincingly Analogy clarifies but cannot replace fact. Add that factual evidence is still needed, otherwise the reader finds the passage pleasant rather than persuasive.
Rebuttal without concession Answer says the author finds the opponent completely wrong A rebuttal normally grants part of the opposing case before limiting it. Without the concession the answer earns half marks because the opponent position is never stated.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Central claim One sentence passing the because-therefore test Two or three sentences means re-teaching act one
Evidence types Three facts, one statistic, one quotation A statistic called a fact means re-teaching act two
Rebuttal structure One concession plus one answer Opponent is wrong only means re-teaching act three

09 Tutor FAQ

Is four reasoning methods too advanced for S2?

All four sit inside the junior secondary range and each has an operational clue: example shows a case, quotation shows a source, contrast shows two situations, analogy shows a shared structure. Recognise first, evaluate later.

Must evidence always be three facts?

No, that is this sample. Real passages may carry two facts and one statistic. What matters is that students can label each item and link it to a sub-claim rather than memorise a count.

How does this differ from the expository chapter?

Expository answers cover what is explained and by which method; argumentative answers cover what is proved and by which evidence. Both require naming methods, but argumentative writing adds a position and a rebuttal that must appear in the answer.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →