/en-tutor-prep-s2-english-modals-ability-obligation-deduction/
/en-tutor-prep-s2-english-modals-ability-obligation-deduction/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Junior English | Modal verbs prep guide (for tutors) | Ability, obligation and deduction

Junior English | Modal verbs prep guide (for tutors) | Ability, obligation and deduction

  • 2026-11-19

Students write “You must not wear a tie” meaning “you do not need to”, and treat “must have been” as a present tense. This lesson turns nine modals into three function tables and one four-step routine: ask the meaning, ask the time, ask the polarity, ask the register.

Objectives — Students can: (1) name the nine core modals and sort them into ability and possibility, obligation and prohibition, and deduction and advice; (2) separate mustn’t (prohibition) from don’t have to (no obligation) and say in one sentence that the two are near opposites; (3) write a deduction on the can’t, may, must ladder, switching time with be or have plus a past participle; (4) use three modals correctly in a sixty-word message, justifying each choice.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Present simple What happens to a third-person singular verb It takes s, but a modal never does
Past participle What is the past participle of go Gone, used in must have gone
Imperatives Which word form starts a rule sentence The base verb, for example Keep quiet

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-8 min Three-sentence opening Write must, mustn’t and don’t have to in one contrast set Choose first, compare at the end
8-22 min Nine modals into three tables Put the nine words in three columns with one example each Add three examples of their own
22-34 min Obligation and prohibition Use school rules for must, mustn’t, don’t have to and should Rewrite four rules
34-46 min Deduction ladder Rank can’t to must, model must be and must have been Write three deductions about one situation
46-56 min Four question steps Do a multiple choice and a correction item together, naming each step Do four items alone
56-60 min Exit check Collect three items, mark them, name the error type Work independently

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Nine modals, three function tables

Act one gives the list: can, could, may, might, must, shall, should, will and would, that is nine, plus four semi-modals, have to, ought to, used to and need to. The three tables are ability and possibility (can, could, may, might), obligation and prohibition (must, have to, should, ought to, mustn’t) and deduction and advice (must, may, might, can’t, should). One word can sit in two tables, so the sentence decides, not the word: can marks ability and possibility, may marks permission and deduction. Three form rules go on the board at the same time: a modal takes the base verb, never takes s, and never takes to, with ought to and have to as the only exceptions.
Students repeat: a modal takes the base verb, no s and no to, and one modal can belong to two function tables.

Students do: copy the nine words into three columns, adding one example sentence that names the situation.

Scene 2: mustn’t prohibits, don’t have to removes obligation

Act two attacks the pair students confuse most. Mustn’t means prohibition; don’t have to means no obligation; they are not near synonyms but near opposites. Use school rules: You mustn’t run in the corridor forbids running, while You don’t have to wear a tie means a tie is optional. The affirmative and the negative of must sit in different tables, and that has to be said plainly. Should and ought to give advice and sound softer than must, which suits a note to a classmate; have to reports an outside rule, while must reports the speaker’s own insistence. The four rewriting items are completed in class, with the tutor asking after each one whether it is a ban or a choice.
Students repeat: mustn’t bans, don’t have to frees you, and the negative of must means something different from must.

Students do: rewrite four school rules as mustn’t or don’t have to and circle the key word in each.

Scene 3: Deduction runs on a ladder, and time sits after the modal

Act three covers deduction. Can’t means almost certainly not (about five per cent), may or might means even odds (fifty), must means almost certainly (ninety); those three numbers are a classroom scale for ranking, not a statistic. Time comes from what follows: must be is now (He must be tired), must have been is past (He must have been tired), must have been doing is past continuous. The deductive can’t can never be replaced by mustn’t, because mustn’t only prohibits, and that is the single most common slip in this unit.
Students repeat: can’t, may and must form the deduction ladder, and be against have done fixes the time.

Students do: write three deductions about a classmate asleep on the desk using can’t, might and must, then one about yesterday.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Multiple choice, function You ___ bring your book; I have a spare. Ask the meaning, then the polarity, then the ladder don’t have to, not mustn’t
Correction She musts finish it today. A modal never takes s She must finish it today
Deduction rewrite I am sure he is at home. Use must. must plus be, no to He must be at home
Sixty-word message Tell a classmate to bring three things tomorrow, one of them optional Three modals, three jobs: must, don’t have to, can Must contain must, don’t have to and can in fifty to seventy words
Sanity check (teach this): Four sanity checks: (1) a modal followed by to is wrong unless it is ought to or have to; (2) whatever follows mustn’t should be something forbidden, so an optional action means don’t have to was intended; (3) a deduction never uses must plus not, so can’t is the only negative; (4) the message must run fifty to seventy words, and if it is longer, cut words only after counting that all three modals are present.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Gap fill You ___ wear a helmet; it is the law. An outside rule takes have to have to
Correction He mustn’t to go now. No to after a modal He mustn’t go now
Deduction Her light is on, so she is certainly at home. Use must. must be for the present She must be at home

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
mustn’t read as no obligation Writing You mustn’t wear a tie to mean a tie is optional mustn’t prohibits; no obligation is don’t have to, and the two are near opposites.
Adding s or to to a modal Writing She cans swim, or He must to go A modal takes the base verb with no s and no to, except ought to and have to.
mustn’t used for deduction Writing He mustn’t be at home to mean he is certainly away Negative deduction takes can’t; mustn’t only prohibits.
must have been read as present Writing He must have been ill to describe his state now Have plus a past participle is past; the present is must be.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Nine modals can could may might must shall should will would Missing one means rewrite the list
Ban versus choice mustn’t against don’t have to Calling them synonyms means repeat act two
Ladder and time can’t, may, must, with be or have done Using mustn’t for deduction means redo the item

09 Tutor FAQ

Should shall be taught

Yes, but only for written suggestions such as Shall we go; spoken English usually takes will or should.

What separates must from have to

Must is the speaker’s own insistence; have to is an outside rule or a law. The negatives differ even more: mustn’t prohibits, don’t have to frees you.

Do students memorise the percentages

No. Learn the order only: can’t lowest, may in the middle, must highest; the numbers are just a classroom scale.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →