S2 English: problem and solution essays (tutor lesson plan)
- 2026-11-21
Students write we should recycle more and cannot say how much is recycled or how far short the school is. This lesson drills one move: turn the problem into a number, then make each fix answer that number.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Percentages | What percentage of 120 is 45? | 37.5 per cent, from 45 divided by 120 |
| Modal verbs | How do should, could and must differ? | Should advises, must requires, could is weaker |
| Paragraph jobs | How many jobs does one paragraph do? | One; the problem paragraph proposes nothing |
02 Lesson flow (30 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-5 min | Write one opinion cold | Ask whether the waste problem is serious | Serious, but with no number |
| 5-12 min | Measure the problem | 120 kg a day, 45 kg recycled, 37.5 per cent | Two numbers and one percentage |
| 12-20 min | Three solutions | Bins plus 20, food waste 15, paper 10 | Three sentences, each with a number |
| 20-26 min | Cost and limits | 45 bins at 180 dollars, 8,100 dollars in total | Say who pays and who runs it |
| 26-30 min | Exit check | Mark live and correct live | Three out of three |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Turn the problem into numbers, never adjectives
Put it in one sentence: The school throws away 120 kg of waste a day, but only 45 kg, or 37.5 per cent, is recycled, which is 45 kg short of the 75 per cent target.
That sentence is the floor of the essay. Every solution then answers one question: how much of the 45 kg does it close?
Ask the student: at a 75 per cent target on 120 kg, how many kilograms must be recycled?
Scene 2: Attach a number to every solution and make the three add up to the gap
Then price it: 45 bins at 180 dollars each is 8,100 dollars. With numbers and a price, a solution becomes a plan rather than a wish.
Ask the student: do your three cuts add up to exactly 45 kg, and what if they overshoot?
Scene 3: Cost and limits first, payoff second
The essay runs 250 words in four parts of 30, 80, 85 and 55, with 5 minutes planning, 20 writing and 5 checking. Content is 8 marks, language 8 and organisation 4; content is awarded for three measured solutions, not for taking a side.
Ask the student: where do the money and the people come from for your second solution?
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Measure the problem | 120 kg a day, 45 kg recycled | Total, handled, percentage | 37.5 per cent, 45 kg short of 75 per cent |
| Solution with a number | What the three fixes cut together | One number each, summing to the gap | 20 plus 15 plus 10 is 45 kg |
| Cost calculation | 45 bins at 180 dollars | Quantity times unit price, plus staffing | 8,100 dollars |
| Limit sentence | What limits the plan | Money or staffing first, payoff second | Two student helpers per floor at lunch |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| 120 kg is thrown away and 45 kg is recycled: what is the recycling rate? | 37.5 per cent | Whether the division used the total, not 45 |
| At a 75 per cent target, how much must be recycled, and what is the gap? | 90 kg, a gap of 45 kg | Whether the target share was applied to the total |
| 45 bins at 180 dollars each: what is the total cost? | 8,100 dollars | Whether quantity and unit price were multiplied correctly |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Adjectives instead of numbers | Writing our school has a serious waste problem and stopping | Serious is an adjective, not evidence. Put 120 kg and 45 kg in the sentence. |
| Solutions with no number | Writing we should recycle more and use less paper | Every solution carries a cut. A fix with no number changes nothing. |
| Cuts that miss the gap | Solutions adding to 60 kg against a 45 kg gap | The three cuts must sum to the gap, and an overshoot needs a reason why it is still worth doing. |
| No cost and no limit | Ending after the third solution | Say who pays the 8,100 dollars and who runs the scheme. A plan without cost is a wish. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- S2 English writing paper, problem and solution task — Question 3: hand in the problem, three-solution table with a total that adds up, then 250 words in 30 minutes.
- Same paper, comparison task for contrast — Question 2: place the criteria table beside the solution table and say how comparing two things differs from changing one, in 10 minutes.
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| How many numbers in the problem paragraph | Three: total, handled, target | Answering one means reteach the first script |
| How the 45 kg gap is closed | 20 plus 15 plus 10 is 45 | Answering more is better means reteach the second script |
| What a solution paragraph needs | A cost or limit plus one effect number | Answering be specific means reteach the third script |
09 Tutor FAQ
Must there be three solutions?
Two will do if each is larger and the essay says why a third was rejected; three fit more easily into 85 words per solution.
Can students invent their own figures?
No. The data in the question is the only source; invented numbers are treated as ignoring the material and weaken the argument.
Do 250 words fit four parts?
Yes. The 30, 80, 85 and 55 split is built for 250 words, and an 80-word problem paragraph fits one data sentence and one consequence.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



