S3 Chinese — Argumentative Reading: Lesson-Prep Guide for Tutors (45-minute flow, scripts, common errors)

2026-11-12

Tutor lesson-prep guides · Secondary Chinese

Most S3 students highlight the example and call it the argument. This lesson installs one verbal test that separates claim from evidence, then gives the four argument methods names the mark scheme actually asks for.

Objectives — Students can: (1) apply the removal test (take the sentence out: if the writer’s position still stands, it was evidence, not the claim) and locate the central claim at the title, the last sentence of paragraph one or the first sentence of the last paragraph; (2) sort evidence into two kinds only, fact (events, figures, historical cases) and reasoning (quotation, principle), giving one example of each; (3) name the four argument methods (example, quotation, contrast, analogy) and state which claim each one serves; (4) answer a rebuttal question in three steps: what the writer concedes, how it is countered, why the claim ends up stronger.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill	Quick check	Pass mark
Paragraph function	What does the first sentence of a body paragraph usually do?	State or carry a position, so read it as a claim
Contrast markers	What follows a marker such as however or conversely?	The opposing view or the rebuttal, which carries the real position
Reading figures	Is seventy per cent of respondents a claim or material?	Material: a factual support, not the claim itself

02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)

Time	Stage	Tutor does	Student does
0-5 min	Two-sentence sort	Write one claim and one piece of evidence, ask for a show of hands	Vote and justify the choice
5-14 min	The removal test	Model deleting sentences until one position remains	Delete to the surviving sentence
14-24 min	Four methods, four markers	Each method gets one marker word and one model sentence	Circle the marker in the text
24-34 min	Four-step answering	Show a 900-character passage, four questions, twenty marks in fifteen minutes	Write in steps, no skipping
34-40 min	The rebuttal paragraph	Three boxes: concede, counter, strengthen	Fill all three boxes
40-45 min	Exit check	Collect three answers, mark live, name the act to reteach	Hand in three answers

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Act one: a claim survives removal, evidence does not

“One test decides everything: take the sentence out. If the writer’s position is still complete, that sentence was evidence; if the position collapses, it was the claim. Take the sentence about lateness falling from twenty per cent to ten. Remove it and the writer can still argue his point, so it is material. The central claim usually sits in one of three places: the title, the last sentence of the opening paragraph, the first sentence of the closing paragraph. If you still cannot find it, ask what the writer wants you to agree with. Write the answer as a full sentence with a stance verb: should, must, is better than.”

A claim survives removal; evidence does not.

Scene 2: Act two: four methods, each with a marker word

“The paper asks for the name, not for the phrase used an example. Four names: example, with markers such as for instance; quotation, with markers such as as the saying goes; contrast, with markers such as by contrast or formerly; analogy, with markers such as just as. One paragraph can carry two methods, but you name only the one the question targets. Then pair it: after the name, write what claim it proves. A name without a pairing normally earns half marks only.”

Example, quotation, contrast, analogy, and always pair with a claim.

Scene 3: Act three: a rebuttal is not a concession, it is thickening

“The rebuttal always sits last. Step one, concede: some argue that screen time worries parents, and that concern is not unreasonable. Step two, counter with a condition or a figure: if rollout is limited to P3 to P6, training and equipment costs spread over three years. Step three, close: therefore full adoption is not impossible, only sequenced. Students skip step one and start arguing, which reads as quarrelling. Add the concession and the same paragraph reads as reasoning. Ask what the rebuttal does and the answer is those three steps: build fairness, narrow the objection, leave the claim firmer.”

Concede, counter, strengthen: all three or nothing.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type	Example	Steps	Answer
Locating the claim	What is the central claim of this 900-character passage? Write a full sentence.	(1) Read the title (2) read the last sentence of paragraph one (3) read the first sentence of the last paragraph (4) compare the three and keep the widest one	One sentence with a stance, e.g. online learning should be introduced in primary schools in stages
Sorting evidence	Which kind of evidence is the lateness figure?	(1) Ask whether it is a checkable event or figure (2) yes means factual (3) no means reasoning (4) name the claim it supports	Factual evidence, supporting the claim that online learning improves study habits
Naming the method	Which argument method does paragraph three use? Explain.	(1) Find the marker (2) fit one of four names (3) write what it proves (4) quote the claim of that paragraph	Contrast: blackboards then against one device per student now, proving equipment is no longer the obstacle
Rebuttal function	What does the rebuttal in the final paragraph achieve?	(1) State what is conceded (2) state the counter (3) state how the claim ends firmer	It concedes the training burden, narrows it by staging the rollout, and leaves the claim more defensible

Sanity check (teach this): Consistency check: (1) a claim must stand as a full sentence with a stance verb; a bare topic word is not a claim. (2) Evidence that merely repeats the claim in other words is not evidence. (3) The four method names are a closed list; two may coexist but only the targeted one is named. (4) Marks add up: four questions, twenty marks (6, 6, 8) in fifteen minutes, so the eight-mark question needs six minutes. (5) A two-step rebuttal earns at most half marks on the function question.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question	Answer	What to watch
Classify: we should therefore not ban phones in school, and seven in ten teachers have confiscated one in class.	The first is the claim (stance verb, removal breaks the passage); the second is factual evidence	Whether the student can state the removal test as the reason
A paragraph says online lessons disrupted sleep, then says however rural students met good teachers for the first time. Which method?	Contrast, marker word however	Whether the marker is named rather than just calling it an example
The writer concedes that parents may worry about screen time. What does that step do?	It builds fairness, so the counter does not read as quarrelling, and the claim ends firmer	Whether both effects, fairness and firmer claim, are written

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake	Student writes	Say this
Copying evidence as the claim	“The central claim is that lateness fell from twenty to ten per cent.”	“That is material. Take it out and the writer’s position still stands, so it is evidence, not the claim.”
Writing the claim as a topic word	“Claim: online learning.”	“A claim needs a verb and a stance. Add them: online learning should be introduced in stages.”
Naming the method as using an example	“Paragraph three uses an example.”	“The question wants the name. Four only: example, quotation, contrast, analogy. Example is not a name here.”
Rebuttal with no concession	“The writer refutes the parents, so his position is right.”	“A rebuttal starts by conceding. Add the concern is not unreasonable and the paragraph becomes reasoning.”

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

Secondary Chinese chapter index — All chapters for this subject
All lesson-prep guides — Same format in other subjects
Redo this chapter — Take another 900-character passage: four questions, six, six and eight marks, fifteen minutes, circle every method marker

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question	Answer	Decision
State the test that separates claim from evidence.	Remove it: position survives means evidence, collapses means claim	Cannot state it: rerun the opening sort next lesson
Name the four argument methods.	Example, quotation, contrast, analogy	Fewer than three: reteach act two
Name the three rebuttal steps.	Concede, counter, strengthen the claim	Only the counter: return to the three-box table

09 Tutor FAQ

Should S3 cover the difference between argument and rebuttal in writing too?

Position and function only: argument in the first two paragraphs, rebuttal last. Essay structure is an S4 topic.

What if students cannot finish a 900-character passage?

Read three places first, title, last sentence of paragraph one, first sentence of the last paragraph, write a provisional claim in thirty seconds, then scan each paragraph opener to correct it. That is exam order, not laziness.

Must students memorise Chinese definitions of the four methods?

Four names and four marker words are enough. The mark scheme rewards the name and the pairing, not the length of a definition.

Find a tutor — free Tutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.