S3 English: advantages and disadvantages essays (tutor lesson plan)
- 2026-11-21
Students give three advantages, three disadvantages and stop, with no number on either side, so the conclusion decides nothing. This lesson drills one move: a number on every point, then one yardstick to weigh both sides.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Contrast and concession | When do however, although and on the other hand fit? | However opens a sentence, although takes a clause, on the other hand sets two sides against each other |
| Comparing numbers | How far apart are 58 and 66, in marks and in per cent? | Eight marks, which is 12.1 per cent of 66 |
| Paragraph jobs | How many jobs does one paragraph do? | One; the advantages paragraph carries no drawbacks |
02 Lesson flow (35 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Open two columns | One sentence for the situation, one column each side | Two headed columns with a number between them |
| 6-14 min | Advantages with figures | 37.5 per cent work 8 hours a week at 60 dollars, 5,760 dollars a term | Two points, two figures |
| 14-24 min | Disadvantages with figures | A gap of 8 marks and 96 hours of study lost | Two points, two figures |
| 24-31 min | One yardstick | Around 8 hours a week is the line; beyond it the costs dominate | One line, both sides named |
| 31-35 min | Exit check | Mark live and correct live | Three out of three |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Open two columns, then state the situation with numbers
That sentence is the floor of the essay. It is not a position but a size, and size is what lets the two sides be weighed on the same scale instead of each sounding clever on its own.
Ask the student: what share of 480 students is 180, and in which paragraph does that figure belong?
Scene 2: Attach a number to every point: money, hours and marks do the most work
On the other side, marks: part-time workers average 58 against 66, a gap of 8. Hours: 96 hours of study go missing in a term. Put those hours back into 20 a week across 12 weeks, which is 240 hours, and the loss is 40.0 per cent; that percentage argues far better than the word tired.
Ask the student: how many hours or marks does your second drawback cost?
Scene 3: Close with one yardstick and name both sides against it
The essay runs 300 words in four parts of 40, 85, 100 and 75, with 6 minutes opening columns, 24 writing and 5 checking figures. Content is 10 marks, language 10 and organisation 4; content is awarded for numbers on both sides, not for taking a side.
Ask the student: which line does your verdict use, and what happens past it?
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Situation sentence | 180 of 480 students hold jobs | State the sample, the share and the response rate | 37.5 per cent, on an 80.0 per cent response rate |
| Pay calculation | 8 hours a week at 60 dollars | Hours times rate, then times the weeks | 480 dollars a week, 5,760 a term |
| Mark comparison | 58 marks against 66 | Subtract, then express the gap as a share | A gap of 8 marks |
| Yardstick verdict | How many hours make it worth it | One line, both sides stated | About 6 hours a week |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Of 480 students, 180 hold part-time jobs: what share is that? | 37.5 per cent | Whether the division used the total, not 180 |
| 8 hours a week at 60 dollars over 12 weeks: what is the total pay? | 5,760 dollars | Whether the number of weeks was left out |
| 58 marks for workers against 66 for others: what is the gap? | 8 marks | Whether the subtraction ran the wrong way |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Counting examples instead of sizing the group | Opening with many students do part-time jobs | Many is an adjective. Say 180 of 480, which is 37.5 per cent. |
| An advantages paragraph with no figure | Writing students can earn money and learn responsibility and stopping | One figure per point: 480 dollars a week, 5,760 dollars a term. That is evidence. |
| A longer drawbacks paragraph and a neutral verdict | Spending 100 words on drawbacks, 60 on advantages, then deciding nothing | Whichever side runs longer decides the verdict. A neutral conclusion is no conclusion. |
| A conclusion that repeats the question | Writing in conclusion, there are both advantages and disadvantages | The verdict needs a line: worth it up to six hours a week, not beyond. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- S3 English writing paper, discussion task — Question 2: hand in the two-column table with one figure per point, then 300 words in 35 minutes; any empty cell counts as unfinished.
- Same paper, argumentative paragraph for contrast — Question 4: set the concession sentence beside the yardstick verdict and say how conceding to an opponent differs from holding two columns, in 10 minutes.
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| What is drawn before writing | Two columns and one measured situation sentence | Answering a position means reteach the first script |
| How many figures per essay | One per point, four at least | Answering as many as possible means reteach the second script |
| What the conclusion must contain | One line plus the result on each side | Answering a summary of both sides means reteach the third script |
09 Tutor FAQ
Must there be more advantages than disadvantages?
No. The counts need not match; what must match is a figure on every point, without which nothing can be compared.
Can one figure carry the whole essay?
No. One figure sizes the group but proves nothing about either side; money, hours and marks are the minimum spread.
Do 300 words fit four parts?
Yes. The 40, 85, 100 and 75 split is built for 300 words, and 85 words fits two points with one figure each.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



