Junior Secondary English | Argument Paragraph Prep Guide (for tutors) | PEEL, 60 per cent evidence and 140 words in 18 minutes
- 2026-11-21
Most students write one opinion sentence and three slogans. This lesson fixes the word budget of each of the four PEEL blocks, then fills them with one survey figure and one rebuttal.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage of an amount | What is 60 per cent of 250 students | 150 students, 250 times 0.6 |
| Introducing evidence | How to open a sentence with a survey figure | Over 60 per cent of 250 students surveyed supported the ban |
| Concession and rebuttal | How to disagree without ignoring the other side | Start with However, concede one point, then name what it ignores |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-8 minutes | Diagnostic | Give one motion and ask for a paragraph in three minutes | Write a paragraph and count how many concrete numbers it uses |
| 8-22 minutes | Act one: PEEL word budget | Put 22, 38, 52 and 28 on the board and model one paragraph | Re-sort their own paragraph into four blocks and mark the missing one |
| 22-36 minutes | Act two: evidence sentence | Model 60 per cent of 250 as 150, then 200 a day over 190 days as 38,000 | Work it out and write one sentence with number and source |
| 36-50 minutes | Act three: rebuttal and close | Model concession plus rebuttal, then a closing sentence | Write one rebuttal sentence and reshape it into a closing line |
| 50-56 minutes | Independent practice | Set three items and circulate, prompt but never write for them | Finish alone and circle their evidence and rebuttal sentences |
| 56-60 minutes | Exit check | Read three questions and note the weakest block | Answer orally and write down their weakest block |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Act one: PEEL is four slots, not four labels
Students can recite Point, Evidence, Explanation and Link and still produce one opinion plus three slogans. The missing step is the word budget. Write it up: Point 22 words, Evidence 38, Explanation 52, Link 28, totalling 140. Once the budget is fixed, students see that Explanation is the longest block and stop after evidence.
Each block is one or two sentences: a claim, a figure, two sentences of cause and effect, and a closing link. Six sentences averaging 23.3 words keeps every sentence between 20 and 25 words, which is where broken sentences start to disappear.
Ask the class to repeat the four budgets and their jobs, then hold their own paragraph against them. Most find Point and a vague Evidence with no Explanation at all. Seeing the gap is what makes act two land.
Point 22 words, Evidence 38, Explanation 52, Link 28, totalling 140
Scene 2: Act two: evidence needs numbers you can work out
The weakest evidence sentence is many students agree with me. Strong evidence carries three things: a number of people, a proportion and a source. Model it: 250 students surveyed, 60 per cent in favour, that is 150 students. The sentence reads: Over 60 per cent of 250 students surveyed supported the ban, about 150 students.
Then push the figure across a year. The school uses 500 bottles a day, a ban cuts 40 per cent, so 200 fewer bottles a day; with 190 school days that is 200 times 190, or 38,000 bottles a year. That number goes into the 52-word Explanation, and the cause now holds: fewer bottles daily, tens of thousands a year.
Warn about units. 200 is daily and 38,000 is yearly; a sentence claiming schools would save 38,000 bottles a day has the arithmetic right and the unit wrong, and content marks still go.
Evidence needs people, proportion and source; 200 is daily, 38,000 is yearly
Scene 3: Act three: concede, answer, close
A rebuttal has three parts: the other side, what is fair in it, and what it ignores. Model: Some argue that reusable bottles are inconvenient. While this is true for some families, convenience does not outweigh 38,000 bottles a year. Two sentences complete the concession and the answer, and the paragraph stops being one-sided.
The closing sentence only restates the position, never a new argument: Schools should therefore ban single-use bottles at the tuck shop. Twelve to fifteen words, short and definite, so the paragraph does not end on a half-sentence.
Finish on marks and time. The question is 12 marks, 6 content and 6 language, 20 per cent of a 60-mark paper. Eighteen minutes split as 4 for keywords, 10 for six sentences and 4 for three checks (units, tense, every block present), about 1.3 minutes per check. Chasing length breaks sentences and loses both content and language marks.
Rebuttal: other side, concession, what it ignores; then one closing line
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| PEEL paragraph | Should the school ban single-use bottles | Four blocks of 22, 38, 52 and 28 words, six sentences | Claim, figure, two cause-and-effect sentences, closing link |
| Evidence sentence | 250 students surveyed, 60 per cent in favour | Work out the number first, then state number and proportion | Over 60 per cent of 250 students surveyed supported the ban, about 150 students |
| Rebuttal sentence | Some say reusable bottles are inconvenient | One concession, one answer | While this is true for some families, convenience does not outweigh 38,000 bottles a year |
| Closing sentence | End of paragraph | One sentence, 12 to 15 words, no new point | Schools should therefore ban single-use bottles at the tuck shop |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| 60 per cent of 250 students is how many | 150 students, 250 times 0.6 | Check that they give a number, not just a percentage |
| 500 bottles a day cut by 40 per cent over 190 days saves how many | 200 a day, 38,000 a year | Check that daily and yearly figures are kept apart |
| How do 140 words split into 22, 38, 52 and 28 | They total 140, with the longest block for explanation | Check that the longest block is kept for cause and effect |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Opinion with no numbers | Many students agree that bottles should be banned. | Write people and proportion instead: Over 60 per cent of 250 students surveyed. One figure beats three adjectives. |
| No explanation | Evidence then straight to the conclusion | Two sentences of cause: 200 fewer bottles a day, 38,000 fewer a year, which is enough to justify a ban. |
| Rebuttal turns into a new point | However, the tuck shop will lose money. | Concede one point, then name what it ignores: While this is true, convenience does not outweigh 38,000 bottles a year. |
| Wrong unit or tense | Schools would save 38,000 bottles a day. | 200 is daily and 38,000 is yearly; a present fact takes the present tense. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- S3 English: data description, Section 07 practice — Do the three items in Section 07, writing one evidence sentence with a number for each, and mark the people and the proportion
- S4 English: proofreading and editing, Section 07 practice — Do the three items in Section 07 and check your argument paragraph for tense and unit slips
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| 60 per cent of 250 students | 150 students | If wrong, reteach the percentage step in act two |
| Daily and yearly savings from 500 bottles cut 40 per cent | 200 a day, 38,000 a year | If wrong, reteach the daily-to-yearly conversion |
| Word budget of the four blocks | 22, 38, 52 and 28, totalling 140 | If wrong, reteach the PEEL budget in act one |
09 Tutor FAQ
Which year group is this for
S3 fits best. S4 and above ask for two or three paragraphs, but the four jobs and the rebuttal frame stay the same; only each block grows.
Is 140 words enough
The question is 12 marks, 20 per cent of the paper, and length costs time elsewhere. Six sentences of 140 words cover claim, evidence, cause and close.
Is there practice material
Yes. The two homework lines link to Section 07 practice; check the word budget and the units when they come back.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



