S3 Geography | Industrial Location and Manufacturing Change Tutor Prep Guide | Contribution 70 to 85, Break-even 5,000 to 4,118
- 2026-11-17
Ask students why a factory moved to Dongguan and the answer is always cheaper labour. How much cheaper, what share of cost, and how much extra freight does it add? Nobody knows. This lesson takes a small plant making 6,000 units a month at 220, splits its cost structure, and derives a contribution of 70 and a break-even of 5,000 units. It then cuts labour from 35 to 12, adds 8 of cross-border freight, and watches contribution rise to 85 and break-even fall to 4,118, while labour falls from 23.33 to 8.89 per cent of variable cost, so relocation becomes a set of calculable trade-offs rather than a slogan.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed and variable cost | Which is variable, factory rent or raw materials | Materials vary with output, rent does not |
| Contribution | What price minus variable cost is called | Contribution, used to cover fixed costs |
| Break-even | What break-even actually means | Zero profit, where contribution just equals fixed cost |
| Location factors | The usual families of site factors | Materials, market, transport, labour, policy and land |
02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Three opening questions | What is left of 220 after 150 of variable cost, how is break-even found, is labour fixed or variable | Oral answers, the tutor writes price, variable and fixed in three columns |
| 6-18 min | Act one: factors are costs, not a list | Every location factor lands on a cost line: nearness to materials cuts freight, nearness to market cuts lead time, labour supply cuts wages, incentives cut tax | Students match five factors to the cost line each one moves |
| 18-30 min | Act two: split the cost, find the break-even | Variable 150, contribution 70, fixed 350,000, break-even 5,000, output 6,000 giving a safety margin of 16.67 per cent and profit of 70,000 | Students compute it themselves and check the profit at 6,000 |
| 30-40 min | Act three: the price of relocation | Labour falls to 12 but freight adds 8, giving variable 135, contribution 85, break-even 4,118 and profit 160,000, with labour falling from 23.33 to 8.89 per cent | Students find the 882 unit gap and say what it means |
| 40-43 min | Man-hour check | 40 workers, 8 hours, 22 days gives 7,040 hours, wage 70 against 12 | Students compute the 82.86 per cent saving and compare it with the 23 in the cost table |
| 43-45 min | Exit check | Three questions collected and marked, errors tagged to factor mapping, break-even or relocation trade-offs | Completed independently |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Act one: every location factor lands on a cost line
Match five factors to their cost lines and state that materials are 60 per cent of variable cost.
Scene 2: Act two: break-even is the universal ruler
Compute break-even of 5,000 units, a margin of safety of 16.67 per cent and a profit of 70,000.
Scene 3: Act three: the arithmetic and the price of moving
Compute a break-even of 4,118 units and a profit of 160,000, and name two costs outside the table.
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost structure | Price 220 with variable 150, what is contribution | Price minus variable cost | 70, which is 31.82 per cent of price |
| Break-even | Fixed 350,000 at contribution 70, how many units | Fixed cost divided by contribution | 5,000 units |
| Relocation | Labour at 12 and freight 8, what is the new break-even | Recompute variable and contribution first | 4,118 units, 882 fewer |
| Man-hour check | 40 workers, 8 hours, 22 days, wage 70 against 12 | People times hours times days times wage | 7,040 hours, a saving of 82.86 per cent |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Split the cost | Turn 220 into variable cost and contribution | Do the three items sum to 150 |
| Find break-even | Fixed 350,000 at contribution 70 | Is the answer in units |
| Rerun relocation | Labour 12 and freight 8, new contribution and break-even | Was freight included |
| Check man-hours | 7,040 hours at two wage rates | Is the saving 82.86 per cent |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Counting wages but not freight | Relocation takes cost from 150 to 127 | Cross-border freight of 8 is missing. The correct figure is 135, contribution is 85 rather than 93, and break-even differs by 118 units. |
| Reporting break-even in dollars | The break-even is 5,000 dollars | Break-even is a quantity, 5,000 units. Dollars will lose marks because fixed cost divided by contribution can only give units. |
| Treating fixed cost as variable | Rent goes into variable cost, so contribution is only 45 | Rent does not vary with output and belongs in the 350,000. Mixing it in understates break-even and leads to a wrong decision. |
| Assuming relocation is always better | Wages fall 82.86 per cent, so of course we move | Outside the table lead time stretches from one day to three or five, customs appear, and skilled workers leave. A full answer carries both arithmetic and cost. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Secondary Geography prep guide index — All geography chapters
- Full prep guide index — Comparable chapters in other subjects
- Redo this chapter practice — Questions 2, 3 and 4: break-even, relocation and the man-hour check
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution | 70, or 31.82 per cent of price | 150 means variable cost was quoted instead |
| Break-even | 5,000 units, then 4,118 after relocation | Dollars mean the concept is unclear |
| Relocation | Cheaper, but name lead time and management risk | Saying only that it saves money is an incomplete answer |
09 Tutor FAQ
Why must freight be added at all?
Relocation moves production further away, so inputs and finished goods cross a border. Ignoring freight overstates the gain, which is the commonest lost mark in industrial questions.
Is a margin of safety of 16.67 per cent high or low?
It depends on the industry. Light manufacturing often runs 10 to 30 per cent, and below 10 per cent a small drop in output means losses and very little pricing power.
How does this link to the population chapter?
Population covers labour supply and structure, while this chapter shows how wages enter costs. Together they explain why industry follows young labour.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



