Junior Science | Motors and Generators Prep Guide (for tutors) | Commutator, AC frequency and efficiency
- 2026-11-18
Students have played with motorised toys and hand-crank torches, but ask why a current makes a coil turn or why turning makes a current and they stall. It is the same structure run in two directions, with one reversing switch sitting in the middle.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Magnetic fields | Which way do field lines leave and enter a magnet | Out of north and into south, crowded where the field is strong |
| Magnetic effect of current | What surrounds a current-carrying coil | A magnetic field, so the coil behaves as an electromagnet |
| Power | How power, voltage and current are related | Power equals voltage times current |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 minutes | Open with a dead motor | Strip it to magnet, coil and copper segments | Name the three parts |
| 6-18 minutes | Force on a current-carrying coil | Three cases of direction | Predict the direction of turning |
| 18-30 minutes | The commutator | Reverses the current every half turn | Explain why reversal is needed |
| 30-42 minutes | Generator and frequency | 3000 rpm becomes 50 Hz | Work out a dynamo frequency |
| 42-54 minutes | Efficiency and energy | 36 W in, 27 W out | Work out losses and energy in 30 seconds |
| 54-60 minutes | Exit check | Three oral questions | Answer orally or in writing |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Start with a broken motor in your hand
Ask first what happens when current flows. Most say it gets hot, because they have shorted a battery before. It turns, and heat is only the by-product.
Then ask what would happen without that split ring. After half a turn the force reverses and pulls the coil back, so it would judder in place instead of spinning. Leave that question hanging until the third scene.
Students do: label magnet, coil, commutator and brush on a diagram.
Students say: what the coil does besides getting warm.
Scene 2: Three cases, one rule
Three demonstrations produce the rule students must write down: reverse the current or the field and the rotation reverses; reverse both and the rotation stays the same.
Add strength while you are here: a stronger field, more turns or a larger current all increase the turning effect, which is why a stalled motor draws a surge.
Students do: predict the direction for three current directions.
Students say: why reversing current and field together leaves the rotation unchanged.
Scene 3: The commutator reverses the current every half turn
Put numbers on it: 3000 revolutions per minute is 50 per second, two reversals per revolution, so 100 reversals every second. That is the carbon brush scraping the copper a hundred times a second, which is exactly why brushes wear and why sparks and carbon dust appear.
Kill the common misconception on the spot: the commutator is a rotating switch, not a rectifier in the electronics sense. An AC motor has no commutator because the supply reverses on its own.
Students do: work out the reversals per second at 1500 rpm.
Students say: why an old motor sparks and sheds carbon dust.
Scene 4: Run the same structure backwards and it generates
Energy flow: a motor takes electrical energy to kinetic energy, a generator takes kinetic to electrical, and both produce heat, so efficiency is always below one.
Numbers: 12 V at 3 A is 36 W in, at 75 per cent efficiency the mechanical output is 27 W and 9 W is lost; over 30 seconds that is 1080 J in, 810 J of work out and 270 J of heat, which is why the casing feels warm.
Then frequency: the current reverses twice per revolution, so the AC frequency equals revolutions per second. 3000 rpm is 50 per second, hence 50 Hz, and 1500 rpm gives 25 Hz. On a bicycle with a 2 m rolling circumference at 20 km/h the wheel turns about 2.8 times a second, so the dynamo delivers roughly 2.8 Hz, which is why the lamp dims and flickers when you slow down.
Students do: work out 6 V at 0.5 A with 60 per cent efficiency, then the dynamo frequency at 20 km/h.
Students say: why a bicycle lamp flickers at low speed.
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Force direction | Current one way, field to the right | Field, current, then force perpendicular to both | The coil side is pushed up |
| Reversals per second | 3000 revolutions per minute | Divide by 60, then double | 100 per second |
| Output power | 12 V, 3 A, 75 per cent efficiency | Input power first, then multiply by efficiency | 27 W |
| AC frequency | 1500 revolutions per minute | Revolutions per second equals frequency | 25 Hz |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Output power | 6 V, 0.5 A, 60 per cent efficiency | Check 1.8 W |
| Reversals | 1500 revolutions per minute | Check 50 per second |
| Energy | 36 W input for 30 seconds | Check 1080 J |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Calling the commutator a rectifier | The commutator turns AC into DC, so motors run on AC | It reverses the coil current every half turn so rotation continues; it is not an AC to DC converter. |
| Using rpm as the frequency | 3000 revolutions per minute is 3000 Hz | Divide by 60 first: 3000 rpm is 50 per second, which is 50 Hz. |
| An efficiency above one | 40 W out from 36 W in is 111 per cent | Energy is conserved, so output must be below input; a larger value means a misread meter or a wrong equation. |
| Swapping motor and generator | A motor converts kinetic energy into electrical energy | A motor converts electrical to kinetic, a generator the reverse, on the same structure. |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Junior Science chapter index — All chapters in this subject
- Magnets and electromagnets (revision) — Questions 1 to 3: coil fields and poles
- Household electricity and cost (revision) — Questions 2 to 4: power and energy
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Why a commutator | It reverses the coil current every half turn so the force keeps pushing one way | Answering rectifier means the mechanism is missing |
| Revolutions and frequency | Revolutions per second is the frequency, so 3000 rpm is 50 Hz | Answering 3000 Hz skips the division by 60 |
| Motor versus generator | One structure, two directions, efficiency always below one | Claiming output above input breaks conservation |
09 Tutor FAQ
No motor to dismantle
Use a diagram and a slow-motion clip; the spatial relationship of the three parts matters, not the model number.
Students have not met the force rule
Use the rule form instead: reverse current or field and rotation reverses; reverse both and it stays. Three demonstrations build it without any hand rule.
Should we teach AC period
At junior level only the link between revolutions per second and frequency; period and rms values belong to senior physics.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



