/en-tutor-prep-s3-science-electromagnet-motor-generator/
/en-tutor-prep-s3-science-electromagnet-motor-generator/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Junior Science | Motors and Generators Prep Guide (for tutors) | Commutator, AC frequency and efficiency

Junior Science | Motors and Generators Prep Guide (for tutors) | Commutator, AC frequency and efficiency

  • 2026-11-18

Students have played with motorised toys and hand-crank torches, but ask why a current makes a coil turn or why turning makes a current and they stall. It is the same structure run in two directions, with one reversing switch sitting in the middle.

Objectives — By the end students can: (1) state that a current-carrying coil in a magnetic field experiences a force whose direction depends on both the current and the field; (2) explain that the commutator reverses the coil current every half turn so rotation continues, and work out that 3000 rpm means 50 turns per second and 100 reversals per second; (3) say that a motor and a generator share one structure and run in opposite directions of energy flow; (4) use 36 W in and 75 per cent efficiency to find 27 W of mechanical output and 9 W lost, and convert revolutions per second into an AC frequency of 50 Hz.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Magnetic fields Which way do field lines leave and enter a magnet Out of north and into south, crowded where the field is strong
Magnetic effect of current What surrounds a current-carrying coil A magnetic field, so the coil behaves as an electromagnet
Power How power, voltage and current are related Power equals voltage times current

02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 minutes Open with a dead motor Strip it to magnet, coil and copper segments Name the three parts
6-18 minutes Force on a current-carrying coil Three cases of direction Predict the direction of turning
18-30 minutes The commutator Reverses the current every half turn Explain why reversal is needed
30-42 minutes Generator and frequency 3000 rpm becomes 50 Hz Work out a dynamo frequency
42-54 minutes Efficiency and energy 36 W in, 27 W out Work out losses and energy in 30 seconds
54-60 minutes Exit check Three oral questions Answer orally or in writing

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Start with a broken motor in your hand

Bring a dismantled DC motor: two permanent magnets in the casing, one coil on the shaft, and a copper ring split into two segments pressed by two carbon brushes. Three parts, and the whole lesson can point at them.
Ask first what happens when current flows. Most say it gets hot, because they have shorted a battery before. It turns, and heat is only the by-product.
Then ask what would happen without that split ring. After half a turn the force reverses and pulls the coil back, so it would judder in place instead of spinning. Leave that question hanging until the third scene.

Students do: label magnet, coil, commutator and brush on a diagram.
Students say: what the coil does besides getting warm.

Scene 2: Three cases, one rule

Give the direction test as three fixed steps: field from north to south, current through the coil, and the force perpendicular to both. Then run the three cases: current one way, the coil side is pushed up; current reversed, it is pushed down; magnets swapped so the field reverses, and the push reverses again.
Three demonstrations produce the rule students must write down: reverse the current or the field and the rotation reverses; reverse both and the rotation stays the same.
Add strength while you are here: a stronger field, more turns or a larger current all increase the turning effect, which is why a stalled motor draws a surge.

Students do: predict the direction for three current directions.
Students say: why reversing current and field together leaves the rotation unchanged.

Scene 3: The commutator reverses the current every half turn

Return to the hanging question. After half a turn the two sides of the coil have swapped places, so with an unchanged current the force would drag it back. The commutator swaps the two segments at the moment the coil passes the horizontal, so the current inside the coil reverses and the force keeps pushing the same way round.
Put numbers on it: 3000 revolutions per minute is 50 per second, two reversals per revolution, so 100 reversals every second. That is the carbon brush scraping the copper a hundred times a second, which is exactly why brushes wear and why sparks and carbon dust appear.
Kill the common misconception on the spot: the commutator is a rotating switch, not a rectifier in the electronics sense. An AC motor has no commutator because the supply reverses on its own.

Students do: work out the reversals per second at 1500 rpm.
Students say: why an old motor sparks and sheds carbon dust.

Scene 4: Run the same structure backwards and it generates

Connect the motor to a lamp and turn the shaft by hand: the lamp lights. Make the point explicit, this is one device in two directions, not two devices.
Energy flow: a motor takes electrical energy to kinetic energy, a generator takes kinetic to electrical, and both produce heat, so efficiency is always below one.
Numbers: 12 V at 3 A is 36 W in, at 75 per cent efficiency the mechanical output is 27 W and 9 W is lost; over 30 seconds that is 1080 J in, 810 J of work out and 270 J of heat, which is why the casing feels warm.
Then frequency: the current reverses twice per revolution, so the AC frequency equals revolutions per second. 3000 rpm is 50 per second, hence 50 Hz, and 1500 rpm gives 25 Hz. On a bicycle with a 2 m rolling circumference at 20 km/h the wheel turns about 2.8 times a second, so the dynamo delivers roughly 2.8 Hz, which is why the lamp dims and flickers when you slow down.

Students do: work out 6 V at 0.5 A with 60 per cent efficiency, then the dynamo frequency at 20 km/h.
Students say: why a bicycle lamp flickers at low speed.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Force direction Current one way, field to the right Field, current, then force perpendicular to both The coil side is pushed up
Reversals per second 3000 revolutions per minute Divide by 60, then double 100 per second
Output power 12 V, 3 A, 75 per cent efficiency Input power first, then multiply by efficiency 27 W
AC frequency 1500 revolutions per minute Revolutions per second equals frequency 25 Hz
Sanity check (teach this): Sanity checks: efficiency is always below one, so an output above the input means the equation is inverted; losses are input minus output, 36 minus 27 is 9 W, and the two must add back to 36; frequency cannot exceed twice the revolutions per second, so 50 Hz from 50 rev per second is right and 250 Hz from the same figure is a factor of five slip; reversals per second must be exactly twice the frequency, and a mismatch means revolutions and frequency have been confused; a bicycle dynamo at 20 km/h produces only a few hertz, so an answer of 50 Hz has ignored that the wheel turns two or three times a second.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Output power 6 V, 0.5 A, 60 per cent efficiency Check 1.8 W
Reversals 1500 revolutions per minute Check 50 per second
Energy 36 W input for 30 seconds Check 1080 J

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Calling the commutator a rectifier The commutator turns AC into DC, so motors run on AC It reverses the coil current every half turn so rotation continues; it is not an AC to DC converter.
Using rpm as the frequency 3000 revolutions per minute is 3000 Hz Divide by 60 first: 3000 rpm is 50 per second, which is 50 Hz.
An efficiency above one 40 W out from 36 W in is 111 per cent Energy is conserved, so output must be below input; a larger value means a misread meter or a wrong equation.
Swapping motor and generator A motor converts kinetic energy into electrical energy A motor converts electrical to kinetic, a generator the reverse, on the same structure.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Why a commutator It reverses the coil current every half turn so the force keeps pushing one way Answering rectifier means the mechanism is missing
Revolutions and frequency Revolutions per second is the frequency, so 3000 rpm is 50 Hz Answering 3000 Hz skips the division by 60
Motor versus generator One structure, two directions, efficiency always below one Claiming output above input breaks conservation

09 Tutor FAQ

No motor to dismantle

Use a diagram and a slow-motion clip; the spatial relationship of the three parts matters, not the model number.

Students have not met the force rule

Use the rule form instead: reverse current or field and rotation reverses; reverse both and it stays. Three demonstrations build it without any hand rule.

Should we teach AC period

At junior level only the link between revolutions per second and frequency; period and rms values belong to senior physics.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →