/en-tutor-prep-s4-economics-scarcity-choice-three-basic-questions/
/en-tutor-prep-s4-economics-scarcity-choice-three-basic-questions/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Economics | Basic Economic Concepts Prep Guide (for tutors) | Scarcity, Three Questions, Economic Systems

Economics | Basic Economic Concepts Prep Guide (for tutors) | Scarcity, Three Questions, Economic Systems

  • 2026-11-19

Students write “scarcity” for any shortage and “shortage” for any queue, so the two words collapse into one; asked for the opportunity cost of a free good, half the class says zero without a reason. This lesson separates the two ideas with three numbers and makes every answer name demand, supply and the gap.

Objectives — Students can: (1) separate scarcity (permanent, price cannot remove it) from shortage (a gap at a given price that price can remove) using demand and supply figures; (2) state that the line between free and economic goods is whether marginal opportunity cost is zero, with one example of each; (3) apply “what to produce, how to produce, for whom to produce” to a concrete case and write the allocation shares; (4) name the three rights in private property (use, income, transfer) and compare how market, planned and mixed systems answer the three questions.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Demand and supply When price rises, what normally happens to quantity demanded? It falls: a move up along the same demand curve
Opportunity cost Choosing A and giving up B: what is the opportunity cost? The highest-valued option given up
Percentages What is 60 out of 160 as a percentage? 37.5%

02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 min Opening diagnosis Ask whether a queue for concert tickets is scarcity or shortage Each writes one line, then compare with the board
6-16 min Scarcity versus shortage Show demand 160 against supply 100 giving a shortage of 60, then demand 100 against supply 130 giving a surplus of 30 Work one shortage and one surplus, with units
16-26 min Free goods and economic goods Contrast air with bottled water using marginal opportunity cost Sort five items into two columns with reasons
26-36 min The three basic questions Split 100 units of resources into 60 consumer goods and 40 capital goods Answer all three questions for the same case
36-43 min Property rights and systems Compare who decides in market, planned and mixed economies Complete a three-column comparison table
43-45 min Exit check Collect and mark two items, naming concept or number errors Independent work

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Scarcity is permanent; a shortage can be priced away

Act one fixes the definitions. Scarcity means total wants always exceed total available resources: it is relative to wants, exists in every society at every moment, and no price can remove it. A shortage means quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied at a particular price, and it is a number: demand 160, supply 100, shortage 60, which is 37.5% of demand.Now put price to work: price rises, quantity demanded falls to 100, quantity supplied rises to 130, the shortage disappears and a surplus of 30 appears. A shortage can be removed by price; scarcity cannot. That sentence is the watershed of the chapter. An answer that says only “resources are limited” has described scarcity and has not answered a question about a market situation.Add the usual confusion: a price ceiling keeps a shortage alive because price is held below equilibrium. That shortage is created by policy, not by scarcity.
Students do: compute the shortage of 60 and the surplus of 30, and label units as units, not dollars.
Students say: why a price rise cannot remove scarcity.

Students repeat: scarcity compares wants with totals; shortage compares demand and supply at one price.

Scene 2: Free versus economic goods: the test is marginal opportunity cost

Act two sorts goods. A free good costs nothing else when one more unit is taken: its marginal opportunity cost is zero. An economic good has a positive marginal opportunity cost. The popular error is “free good means no price”, which turns government-issued masks into free goods; masks use resources, so their opportunity cost is positive.Contrast air with bottled water: one more breath in an ordinary setting sacrifices no alternative use, so marginal opportunity cost is zero; bottled water needs plastic, transport and chilling, so its marginal opportunity cost is clearly positive. The same water becomes an economic good in a desert, where taking it means giving up another use.Require one sentence in every answer: whether something is a free good depends on whether taking one more unit costs nothing else in that situation, not on its price tag. That sentence can be lifted straight into Paper 1.
Students do: sort air, bottled water, free online news, government masks and sunlight into two columns with a reason each.
Students say: why free online news is still an economic good.

Students repeat: free good means zero marginal opportunity cost; price is not the test.

Scene 3: Three questions, property rights and systems: whoever answers, names the system

Act three links concepts to institutions. Every society answers three questions: what to produce, how to produce, for whom to produce. With 100 units of resources, putting 60 into consumer goods and 40 into capital goods is the answer to “what”; using ten workers or one machine answers “how”; distributing by market income or per head answers “for whom”.Private property needs all three rights: use (who may use it), income (who keeps the return) and transfer (who may sell it). Remove one and prices stop carrying information, so resources stop moving to their best use.Name the systems in one line each: a market economy lets prices answer the three questions, a planned economy lets government directives answer them, and a mixed economy uses both. Hong Kong is mixed: private markets drive most production and distribution, while government intervenes in parts of resource allocation through land supply, public healthcare and education.Close with a checking habit: before answering any economics question, decide whether it asks about a concept, a number or an institution, because the three demand different shapes of answer.
Students do: fill a three-column table answering each basic question as a market would and as a government would.
Students say: what goes wrong if the right to transfer is missing.

Students repeat: three questions (what, how, for whom); three systems (market, planned, mixed).

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Concept discrimination A queue with a capped ticket price Write demand and supply, then the gap, then classify Shortage, removable by price; scarcity is permanent
Numerical Demand 160, supply 100 Subtract, take the positive gap, divide by demand Shortage 60, i.e. 37.5%
Sorting goods Air, bottled water, free news Ask whether marginal opportunity cost is zero Air is free; the other two are economic goods
System comparison Hong Kong healthcare and land supply Ask whether price or directive allocates Mixed economy using both
Sanity check (teach this): Sanity checks: a shortage or surplus always comes from demand and supply at the same price, so a negative answer means the direction is reversed; a shortage as a share of demand must lie between zero and one hundred, and anything above one hundred means supply was divided by demand; a free good must come with a reason why one more unit sacrifices nothing; all three basic questions must be answered, and answering only “what to produce” is incomplete; calling a place a market economy requires a free-price example, and calling it planned requires a directive example, otherwise it is only a label.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Shortage Demand 240, supply 150 Check the subtraction and the division by demand Shortage 90, i.e. 37.5%
Surplus Demand 120, supply 180 Check the direction of the gap Surplus 60
Sorting Tap water, spring water, distilled water Check that each item carries a marginal opportunity cost reason Tap and distilled water are economic goods; spring water can be a free good where it is freely taken

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Treating scarcity and shortage as synonyms Writing “resources are scarce, so there is a shortage” The tests differ: scarcity compares wants with totals; shortage compares demand and supply at one price.
Judging free goods by price tag Writing “the masks are free goods because they cost nothing” Masks use resources, so marginal opportunity cost is positive and they are economic goods.
Answering only one basic question Writing “produce more consumer goods and the problem is solved” Answer all three: what, how and for whom.
Naming only the right to use Writing “private property means I can use my own things” Use, income and transfer are all needed; without transfer, assets cannot move to their best use.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Concept Scarcity permanent, shortage removable by price Reversed answers mean repeating act one
Sorting Free good means zero marginal opportunity cost Price-based sorting means three more sorting items
Systems Three questions plus three systems A missing line means refilling the comparison table

09 Tutor FAQ

What if opportunity cost has not been taught

Add one line first: opportunity cost is the highest-valued option given up. Every sorting task later depends on that line.

Should students memorise Hong Kong government spending shares

No. Such figures change yearly; an answer only needs government involvement in part of resource allocation plus one example, such as land supply or public healthcare.

Will Paper 1 ask for definitions directly

Mostly it asks for judgements in situations, such as a price ceiling producing a shortage, so practise numbers and cases rather than reciting definitions.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →