S5 Economics | Perfect Competition Lesson-Prep Guide (for tutors) | MC = MR, Break-even and Shutdown
- 2026-11-20
Students stop as soon as they find MC = MR, assume a positive price means profit, and freeze when asked why a loss-making firm keeps producing. This lesson narrows the topic to three checkable things: where the price comes from, which unit is the last one produced, and which price forces a shutdown.
01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)
If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.
| Skill | Quick check | Pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Cost types | Which cost is still paid when a firm shuts down? | Fixed cost, so the loss from shutting down equals fixed cost |
| Marginal and average | If MC is above ATC, is ATC rising or falling? | Rising, because the average is pulled up |
| Profit | How does economic profit differ from accounting profit? | Economic profit also deducts all opportunity costs |
02 Lesson flow (60 minutes)
| Time | Stage | Tutor does | Student does |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-6 min | Diagnose | Ask “what happens if a perfectly competitive firm raises its price by ten per cent?” and collect answers | Write your own answer to compare later |
| 6-16 min | Price taker | Draw the market diagram and the firm horizontal demand line side by side | Draw it once and state what MR equals |
| 16-28 min | MC = MR | Give MC 12/8/12/16/20/24 and compare MC with price unit by unit | Fill the table and state output 5 at price 20 |
| 28-40 min | Profit and loss | Compute TR and TC at that output and find the break-even price 18 | Work out the profit 8 at Q = 5 yourself |
| 40-52 min | Shutdown | Drop the price to 12 and then 6, comparing with minimum AVC 10 | Write both cells: keep producing, lose 20; shut down, lose 24 |
| 52-60 min | Long run | Explain how entry and exit push price back to minimum ATC | Say aloud: long-run price 18, output 4, profit 0 |
03 Teaching script (read it out)
Scene 1: Price taker means MR is horizontal, not downward sloping
Students copy the monopolist downward demand curve. Split it with numbers: at a market price of $20 the firm receives $20 for the first unit and $20 for the fifth, so MR = 20 = P. Raising the price sells nothing; cutting it only throws money away, so the firm accepts the price rather than setting it.
Require the sentence “because the firm is a price taker, MR = P = AR” every time MR is written. It is the foundation for every later calculation; skip it and MC = MR turns into MC against some falling line.
Price taker, so MR equals P and is a horizontal line
Scene 2: Two critical prices: break-even 18, shutdown 10
The MC schedule 12/8/12/16/20/24 with fixed cost 24 gives cumulative variable cost 12/20/32/48/68/92. Average total cost is 36/22/18.67/18/18.4/19.33, minimum 18 at output 4; average variable cost is 12/10/10.67/12/13.6/15.33, minimum 10 at output 2.
At price 20 output is 5: TR 100, TC 92, profit 8. At price 12 output is 3: TR 36, TC 56, a loss of 20, but 20 is less than fixed cost 24, so the firm keeps producing. At price 6, below minimum AVC 10, revenue does not even cover variable cost, so shutdown loses only 24. Put all three prices in one table and the boundary is obvious.
Above 18 you profit, between 10 and 18 you produce at a loss, below 10 you stop
Scene 3: Long run: entry and exit drive profit to zero
Short-run supernormal profit of 8 attracts entrants, market supply rises, price falls until it reaches minimum ATC of 18; output is then 4, profit 0, and only normal profit remains. A short-run loss pushes firms out and price climbs back to 18.
Make students say “zero economic profit does not mean closure”: normal profit is already inside cost, so zero economic profit simply means no better use for the resources. That sentence earns marks in the long essay.
Entry and exit push price to minimum average cost; only normal profit survives
04 Question types and worked steps
| Type | Example | Steps | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Output | P = 20 with MC 12/8/12/16/20/24, find profit-maximising output | Find the MC closest to but not above P and confirm MC is rising | Output 5, where MC = 20 |
| Profit | Same table with fixed cost 24, find profit | TR minus TC, with TC from fixed plus cumulative variable cost | TR 100, TC 92, profit 8 |
| Shutdown | Price falls to 6, should the firm produce? | Compare price with minimum AVC | Minimum AVC is 10, so shut down and lose fixed cost 24 |
| Long run | Long-run price and output | Find minimum ATC and its output | Price 18, output 4, profit 0 |
05 Independent practice (3 questions)
| Question | Answer | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Output and profit | MC 10/6/10/14/18, fixed cost 20, price 18: find output and profit | Check they locate MC = 18 and build TC from cumulative variable cost |
| Shutdown | Same firm, price falls to 8: produce or shut down? | Check they compare with minimum AVC of 6 rather than minimum ATC |
| Long-run adjustment | Short-run profit is positive; where is price in three years? | Check they describe entry, rising supply and price falling to minimum ATC |
06 Common mistakes and what to say
| Mistake | Student writes | Say this |
|---|---|---|
| Downward MR | Drawing MR as a downward-sloping line for a price taker | A price taker sells any quantity at one price, so MR is horizontal |
| Zero loss on shutdown | Claiming a firm that shuts down loses nothing | Fixed cost is still paid, so the loss is exactly the fixed cost |
| Shutdown too early | Stopping whenever price is below ATC | As long as price beats average variable cost, producing loses less than shutting |
| Long-run supernormal profit | Writing positive profit in long-run equilibrium | Profit attracts entrants, so price falls to minimum average cost |
07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)
- Economics chapter index — All chapters in this subject
- Lesson-prep master index — Matching chapters in other subjects
- Redo this chapter — Re-read with the script open
08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)
| Question | Answer | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| MR and P | They are equal because the firm is a price taker | A downward line needs re-teaching |
| Shutdown line | Compare price with minimum AVC | Using minimum ATC means redo |
| Long run | Price equals minimum ATC, profit zero | Claiming supernormal profit needs a redraw |
09 Tutor FAQ
Do we need calculus for MC = MR
No. At S5 the table method works: the unit where MC just reaches price is the answer, and calculus is left for interested students.
Normal versus economic profit
Normal profit is the minimum return that keeps the firm in the industry and is part of cost; economic profit is anything above it and is zero in the long run.
Shutdown versus exit
Shutdown is a short-run decision with fixed cost still payable; exit is a long-run decision where fixed assets are sold.
Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →
A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.



