/en-tutor-prep-s5-economics-price-discrimination/
/en-tutor-prep-s5-economics-price-discrimination/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

Economics — Price Discrimination and Discriminatory Pricing Lesson Prep Guide (for tutors) — third degree, two markets, surplus transfer

Economics — Price Discrimination and Discriminatory Pricing Lesson Prep Guide (for tutors) — third degree, two markets, surplus transfer

  • 2026-11-20

Students call two prices for one good unfair, yet cannot state either market marginal revenue; they compute the higher profit but miss why total surplus falls. This lesson uses two linear demand curves and a marginal cost of ten to turn third-degree discrimination into three checkable steps.

Objectives — Students can: 1) state the three conditions for price discrimination and give one example where resale is blocked; 2) derive marginal revenue for each market and set it equal to marginal cost to fix both prices and quantities; 3) compare profit, consumer surplus and total surplus under single pricing and discrimination; 4) use elasticity to explain why the less elastic market pays more.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Inverse demand and quantity With price equal to sixty minus quantity, what quantity goes with a price of thirty five Twenty five units
Marginal revenue For linear demand price equals sixty minus quantity, what is marginal revenue Sixty minus twice the quantity, twice the slope
Elasticity If elasticity exceeds one, does a price rise increase or cut total revenue Cut it, quantity falls proportionally more

02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-8 min Market separation warm up Show a student fare against a tourist ticket price State the three conditions with one example
8-18 min Write both marginal revenues Show the slope doubling on each curve Write both marginal revenue lines
18-28 min Price each market Set marginal revenue equal to ten, solve twenty five and thirty Compute both prices, thirty five and twenty five
28-36 min Single price contrast Combine the demands, then write marginal revenue Compute the single price and profit of eight hundred seventy five
36-42 min Surplus and elasticity Compare the two surplus areas Compute consumer surplus falling from one thousand seventy point eight to five hundred thirty seven point five
42-45 min Exit check Collect three answers and mark the slope or the merge error Work independently

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Price discrimination needs three conditions

Price discrimination means one producer charges different buyers different prices for the same good, where the gap is not explained by cost. Three conditions must hold: market power, since a price taker must accept the market price; separable markets, through student cards, membership, place or time; and no resale arbitrage, because if the cheap buyers can move the good to the dear market the gap collapses. The degrees must be separated: first degree charges each buyer the highest price he will pay and takes the whole surplus; second degree prices in blocks by quantity; third degree charges identifiable groups different prices, such as students and adults, locals and visitors. School questions are almost always third degree, because two demand curves are enough to compute it.
Ask: name one third-degree example seen in Hong Kong and the device that blocks resale.
Ask: why a firm without market power cannot discriminate.

Recap: market power, separable markets, no resale; third degree prices by group.

Scene 2: Set marginal revenue equal to marginal cost in each market

Demand in market A is price equal to sixty minus quantity; in market B it is price equal to forty minus half the quantity; marginal cost is a flat ten. Marginal revenue has twice the slope: sixty minus twice the quantity in A, forty minus the quantity in B. Setting each to ten gives twenty five units in A at a price of thirty five, and thirty units in B at twenty five. Total output is fifty five. Profit is thirty five times twenty five plus twenty five times thirty, minus ten times fifty five, which is eight hundred seventy five plus seven hundred fifty minus five hundred fifty, so one thousand seventy five. Insist on two columns, one per market, and add only at the end; the intercepts and slopes differ, so mental arithmetic invites the wrong slope.
Ask: derive both marginal revenue lines and solve both quantities.
Ask: why the two demands must not be merged before pricing.

Recap: marginal revenue slope doubles; set each to marginal cost; profit is one thousand seventy five.

Scene 3: Discrimination earns two hundred more, total surplus falls three hundred thirty three

With a single price the demands combine: below a price of forty total demand is two hundred twenty minus three times the price, so marginal revenue is two hundred twenty minus six times the price; setting it to ten gives twenty one point six seven and output seventy five. Profit is twenty one point six seven minus ten, times seventy five, so eight hundred seventy five. Discrimination lifts profit to one thousand seventy five, two hundred more, a gain of twenty two point nine per cent. Consumer surplus, however, falls from one thousand seventy point eight to five hundred thirty seven point five, a loss of five hundred thirty three point three; total surplus falls from one thousand nine hundred forty five point eight to one thousand six hundred twelve point five, down three hundred thirty three point three. Output shrinks from seventy five to fifty five, and the lost units are the extra deadweight loss. Elasticity closes the argument: market A shows one point four at a price of thirty five and quantity twenty five, market B one point six seven at twenty five and thirty, so the less elastic market pays more.
Ask: compute both consumer surpluses and subtract.
Ask: why the firm gains while society loses.

Recap: profit up two hundred, consumers down five hundred thirty three, surplus down three hundred thirty three; output seventy five to fifty five.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Two-market discrimination Given both demand curves and marginal cost of ten, find prices, quantities and profit Write each marginal revenue, set to marginal cost, substitute back Quantities twenty five and thirty, prices thirty five and twenty five, profit one thousand seventy five
Single price contrast For the same demands, find the single price, output and profit Merge demand, write marginal revenue, set to marginal cost Price twenty one point six seven, output seventy five, profit eight hundred seventy five
Surplus comparison Compare consumer and total surplus under both regimes Triangle area is half the price gap times quantity Consumer surplus one thousand seventy point eight to five hundred thirty seven point five
Elasticity judgement Explain why market A pays the higher price Slope of quantity on price times price over quantity A at one point four is less elastic than B at one point six seven
Sanity check (teach this): Both marginal revenues must equal ten; a negative quantity means that market is not worth serving; discriminatory output must be below the single-price seventy five, since output is held back to lift price; profit plus consumer surplus must equal total surplus in both cases, otherwise an area or a quantity is wrong.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Market A price equals eighty minus quantity, market B price equals fifty minus half the quantity, marginal cost ten: find discriminatory prices, quantities and profit Quantities thirty five and forty, prices forty five and thirty, profit two thousand nine hundred fifty Two columns, and substitute back for prices
Find the single price output and profit for the same demands Combined demand two hundred thirty minus three times the price, price twenty three point three three, output one hundred sixty, profit two thousand one hundred thirty three point three three Check the merge holds only below a price of fifty
Explain what happens if cheap buyers can resell Dear buyers switch to the cheap market, the dear price is pulled down and the gap disappears State that arbitrage equalises the two prices

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Adding the two demand curves everywhere Writing that the combined price equals one hundred minus one point five times quantity Both markets have demand only below a price of forty; above forty market B demand is zero, so adding counts negative units.
Giving marginal revenue the demand slope Writing that marginal revenue is sixty minus the quantity For linear demand the slope doubles: price sixty minus quantity gives marginal revenue sixty minus twice the quantity; the wrong slope doubles output.
Assuming discrimination must raise welfare Writing that selling more than before means society is better off Discrimination cuts output from seventy five to fifty five and total surplus from one thousand nine hundred forty five point eight to one thousand six hundred twelve point five; the firm gains two hundred, consumers lose five hundred thirty three.
Ignoring the no-resale condition Writing that different prices alone define price discrimination If buyers can move the good from the cheap to the dear market the dear price cannot hold, so student cards, membership, place or bundled service must block resale.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
What are the three conditions for price discrimination Market power, separable markets, no resale A missing one means reteaching act one
When market A marginal revenue equals ten, what are quantity and price Twenty five units at thirty five Wrong means reteaching the slope
Does discrimination raise or cut total surplus It cuts it, from one thousand nine hundred forty five point eight to one thousand six hundred twelve point five Answering that it rises means reteaching act three

09 Tutor FAQ

Which year group is this for

The monopoly and market structure unit of S5 Economics, and directly usable for S6 micro revision.

Is forty five minutes enough

Yes if you stay with linear demand and flat marginal cost; second-degree block pricing is reading.

Is there practice attached

Yes, the homework block links to the site chapters on market structure, elasticity and monopoly pricing, all original with answers.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →