/en-tutor-prep-s6-chemistry-green-chemistry-atom-economy/
/en-tutor-prep-s6-chemistry-green-chemistry-atom-economy/
General Inquiry: info@TutorZone.com.hk
Office Hours: Monday to Saturday - 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
WhatsApp Monday to Sunday - 24 hours
Hotline: +852 6828 1809
Instant Support: +852 9061 3106

S6 Chemistry | Green Chemistry and Atom Economy Prep Guide (Tutor Use) | 100 against 25.4 per cent, E-factor 2.93

S6 Chemistry | Green Chemistry and Atom Economy Prep Guide (Tutor Use) | 100 against 25.4 per cent, E-factor 2.93

  • 2026-11-17

Ask about green chemistry and most students write reduce pollution and protect the environment, then answer an atom economy question with their percentage yield. This lesson contrasts two real ethylene oxide routes: direct oxidation of ethene with half a molecule of oxygen gives 44 over 44, that is 100 per cent, while the older chlorohydrin route gives 44 over 173, that is 25.4 per cent. One route is almost waste free, the other carries roughly three kilograms of waste for every kilogram of product.

Objectives — Students can: (1) calculate atom economy for both ethylene oxide routes using molar masses, 100 per cent and 25.4 per cent, and state how atom economy differs from percentage yield; (2) work out an E-factor of 2.93 from 129 kg of waste and 44 kg of product and explain why lower is better; (3) pick three workable principles on atom economy, catalysis instead of stoichiometric reagents, and water instead of organic solvents, each with an industrial example; (4) decide across four questions which one needs atom economy and which needs percentage yield.

01 Prerequisites (3-minute check)

If any of these fails, fix it before the lesson starts.

Skill Quick check Pass mark
Molar mass What is the molar mass of ethene 28 g per mol
Definition of atom economy Is the denominator the product or the reactants The sum of all reactant molar masses
Percentage yield Theoretical 200 mol, actual 170 mol, what is the yield 85 per cent
Catalyst against stoichiometric reagent Does a catalyst become part of the waste No, it is not consumed

02 Lesson flow (45 minutes)

Time Stage Tutor does Student does
0-6 min Four opening questions What is the atom economy denominator, the molar mass of half an oxygen molecule, which figure can engineering improve, and whether the E-factor is a mass or mole ratio Oral answers while the tutor writes atom economy and yield in two columns
6-20 min Act one: what stays in the product, what actually reacted Atom economy is a property of the route and cannot be improved without changing it, while yield responds to recycle and recovery and never exceeds 100 per cent; ask which one engineering can move Students classify four statements orally
20-34 min Act two: add the molar masses route by route Direct oxidation gives 28 plus 16 equals 44 and 100 per cent, chlorohydrin gives 28 plus 71 plus 74 equals 173 and 25.4 per cent, and 111 kg calcium chloride plus 18 kg water gives an E-factor of 129 over 44, that is 2.93 Pairs calculate and check each other coefficients
34-42 min Act three: turn three principles into equipment Atom economy, catalysis instead of stoichiometric reagents, and water or solvent recovery; each needs one example such as solid acid catalysis replacing sulphuric acid Students write a principle plus an example
42-45 min Exit check Three questions marked at once: one atom economy, one E-factor, one principle Independent work

03 Teaching script (read it out)

Scene 1: Act one: atom economy belongs to the route, yield belongs to the operation

The two are routinely confused. Atom economy asks how much of the reactant mass ends up in the target product, with all reactant molar masses as the denominator, so changing the equation changes the answer. Percentage yield compares what was obtained with what the equation allows and can be improved by recycle and recovery, but never exceeds 100 per cent. Judge a route green by atom economy first, then by yield: a route at 25.4 per cent still sends only about 22.9 kg of every 100 kg of reactant into product even at ninety per cent yield, with the rest becoming waste. Have students state the difference in one sentence before moving on.

The equation sets atom economy, the operation sets yield.

Scene 2: Act two: one product, two routes, a factor of four apart

Direct oxidation: ethene at 28 plus half an oxygen molecule at 16 gives 44, the product is also 44, so atom economy is 100 per cent and the only by-product is water. Chlorohydrin: ethene 28 plus chlorine 71 plus calcium hydroxide 74 gives 173 against a product of 44, so atom economy is 25.4 per cent while 111 kg of calcium chloride and 18 kg of water, 129 kg in total, become waste, giving an E-factor of 129 over 44, that is 2.93. Write both denominators side by side, because marks are lost on coefficients rather than division: half an oxygen molecule is 16, not 32, and forgetting that turns 100 per cent into 68.8 per cent.

Half an oxygen molecule is 16, so multiply every coefficient in.

Scene 3: Act three: a principle only counts when it names a material or a unit

There is no need to recite twelve principles, because questions ask for workable practice. Atom economy: change the route or catalyst so fewer by-products form. Catalysis: solid acid catalysis replaces sulphuric acid and avoids a salt waste stream. Solvents: water replaces dichloromethane, or the solvent is recovered and reused, which pulls the E-factor down. Require a material or equipment name beside each principle, since a bare principle usually earns nothing. Close by asking whether incinerating the waste counts as green, and the answer is no, because incineration moves the problem without improving atom economy.

Every principle needs a material or a unit beside it.

04 Question types and worked steps

Type Example Steps Answer
Atom economy calculation Atom economy of the direct oxidation route Balance the equation, sum reactant molar masses, divide by the product 100 per cent
Compare routes Which ethylene oxide route is greener Compare atom economy and waste streams, not just yield Direct oxidation, 100 against 25.4 per cent
E-factor calculation 129 kg of waste against 44 kg of product Waste mass divided by product mass in the same unit 2.93
Apply a principle Give one industrial example of a green principle Name the principle and a specific material or unit Solid acid catalysis replacing sulphuric acid
Sanity check (teach this): Four checks: the atom economy denominator is the sum of all reactant molar masses, not the product or the main feedstock; coefficients must be multiplied in, so half an oxygen molecule is 16 and not 32, otherwise 100 per cent becomes 68.8 per cent; atom economy and percentage yield are not interchangeable, since only the latter can float and is capped at 100 per cent; the E-factor is a mass ratio, so comparing moles with kilograms produces a meaningless number.

05 Independent practice (3 questions)

Question Answer What to watch
Calculate atom economy Direct oxidation from 28 and 16 to 100 per cent Was the half oxygen coefficient applied
Calculate the old route Chlorohydrin from 173 to 25.4 per cent Was calcium hydroxide included in the denominator
Calculate the E-factor 129 kg of waste over 44 kg of product Are both sides in kilograms
Match examples One industrial example per principle Is there a material name rather than a bare principle

06 Common mistakes and what to say

Mistake Student writes Say this
Reporting yield as atom economy Answer says atom economy is 90 per cent because yield is 90 per cent The denominators differ. Atom economy uses reactant molar masses, yield uses the theoretical amount. Direct oxidation has 100 per cent atom economy even when its actual yield is only 80 per cent.
Half an oxygen molecule counted as 32 Denominator written as 28 plus 32 equals 60 Half an oxygen molecule is 16, so the denominator is 28 plus 16 equals 44 and atom economy is 100 per cent. Missing the coefficient is the most common lost mark here.
Answering only reduce pollution Answer says green chemistry means protecting the environment Write workable practice instead: raise atom economy, replace stoichiometric reagents with catalysts, replace organic solvents with water. A principle plus a concrete example earns the marks.
E-factor with moles over kilograms 129 mol of waste divided by 44 kg of product The E-factor is a mass ratio and both sides must share a unit. 129 kg over 44 kg gives 2.93, while moles over kilograms gives a number that means nothing.

07 Homework (paper, section and question numbers)

08 Exit check (last 5 minutes)

Question Answer Decision
Atom economy against yield One sentence naming the different denominators Confusion means re-teaching act one
Route calculations 100 per cent and 25.4 per cent plus an E-factor of 2.93 A missing coefficient means re-teaching act two
Principles in practice Three principles each with a material or unit Bare principle names mean re-teaching act three

09 Tutor FAQ

Can atom economy exceed 100 per cent?

No. It measures the share of reactant molar mass that becomes the target product, so the ceiling is 100 per cent unless an addition reaction leaves no by-product at all.

Why is the E-factor used more often?

Atom economy looks only at the equation, while the E-factor also counts solvents, water and auxiliary materials, so it tracks the real waste of a plant more closely.

Must students learn all twelve principles?

No. Examinations usually test atom economy, catalysis, solvents and energy efficiency, and knowing the names of the rest is enough. The skill being assessed is translating a principle into a material or a unit.

Find a tutor — freeTutor Registration →

A TutorZone lesson-prep guide. Written by the TutorZone team; questions and lesson flow are original and are not taken from any school or publisher material.

Join as a tutor or coach — academic, music, sports, arts, STEM. Free to register. See how it works →